4 ms·
A friend points out that the limb EFF was out on was sturdy indeed, since DOJ has issued a policy statement saying they're not going after good-faith security r
by tptacek 3y ago
A friend points out that the limb EFF was out on was sturdy indeed, since DOJ has issued a policy statement saying they're not going after good-faith security research.
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-announces-new-policy-charging-cases-under-computer-fraud-and-abuse-act https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-announces-...
- doctorpangloss 3y agoSo then you’d concede that all that’s left is these Fizzbuzz people are liars and are bad people, and that their product is crap and should not be used, and you don’t need to have personally used the app nor met them personally to know any of that, since it’s all clear from their extremely obnoxious, self destructive conduct, and that that’s just an opinion and not a forecast on whether or not their useless investors will get a return?
- tptacek 3y agoPerhaps you missed this line from my original comment: I think the good guys prevailed here.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoYeah definitely. It’s just to say that the security researchers, these classmates, didn’t get lucky. Like if I were a Stanford student, and I heard about this shitty website, you know, if I were generalizing, I wouldn’t be wrong to guess it was run by obnoxious people and that the technology was a big lie. And this website, this forum, it has a maligned love affair with the anti establishment characters, and it can’t really figure out this one because it’s dropouts v. hackers on the face of it. Most of the comments are litigating the law, by non lawyers and even when by lawyers, by people who absolutely could not predict the future of a legal decision. Why not just trust your gut? What I want to hear - what I want to be the #1 comment forever and for all time, which is just my opinion - is like, this research never needed to happen to know that Fizz or whatever is absolute trash. Do you see what I am saying? There are a lot of 18-22 year olds pursuing entrepreneurship out of college aged vengeances. Y Combinator funds many such founders! And here we see the double edged sword: if you’re at Stanford touting yourself an entrepreneurial genius with your app about antagonizing your classmates, you had better actually bring the bacon to your supposed technology. Because you have more than your founding team’s worth of classmates who hate your guts, but can actually program.
- Ajedi32 3y agoTo me that reads less as "this is legal" and more as "this is illegal, but we (the executive branch of the government) will be nice and not go after you for it as long as we think you're a good guy". That's (arguably) better than nothing, but not exactly an ideal way to structure our justice system in my opinion.
- deepsun 3y agoYes, but I don't see a better solution. If we make "security research" legal, then any hacker can just say "oh I was just going to disclose my findings to them".
- giantg2 3y agoNot really, many professional researchers notify law enforcement when engaging in something that could be viewed as illegal or generate calls to the police. What should happen is the addition of a "reasonable" standard and using existing case law policy positions to not prosecute people who have a reasonable basis supporting their claim of security research. Instead we'll be left with the lazy lawmakers doing nothing and the executive saying they'll prosecute only the people who "deserve" it.
- seanw444 3y agoI hate the use of "reasonable" in law. Who's to define what's reasonable?
- buttercraft 3y agoJudges and juries
- singleshot_ 3y agoYou are right, but there is more to it. Judges typically consider matters of law. Usually “reasonable” is a cue that you are discussing a matter of fact, which is the province of the jury. Sometimes you will have something called a bench trial, where it is agreed that the judge will also serve the role of the fact finder, and there will be no jury.
- asynchronous 3y agoI remember when the DOJ announced that and it still isn't good enough to protect security researchers by saying “we won’t prosecute, trust us”