3 ms·
> this is subtle: you can easily rack up 5-6 figure damage numbers from unauthorized security research, but Fizz was so small and new that I'm assuming nobody e
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> this is subtle: you can easily rack up 5-6 figure damage numbers from unauthorized security research, but Fizz was so small and new that I'm assuming nobody even contemplating retaining a forensics firm or truing things up with their insurers, who probably did not exist
This seems like a problem with the existing law, if that's how it works.
It puts the amount of "damages" in the hands of the "victim" who can choose to spend arbitrary amounts of resources (trivial in the scope of a large bureaucracy but large in absolute amount), providing a perverse incentive to waste resources in order to vindictively trigger harsh penalties against an imperfect actor whose true transgression was to embarrass them.
And it improperly assigns the cost of such measures, even to the extent that they're legitimate, to the person who merely brought their attention to the need for them. If you've been operating a publicly available service with a serious vulnerability you still have to go through everything and evaluate the scope of the compromise regardless of whether or not this person did anything inappropriate, in case someone else did. The source of that cost was their own action in operating a vulnerable service -- they should still be incurring it even if they discovered the vulnerability themselves, but not before putting it in production.
The damages attributable to the accused should be limited to the damage they actually caused, for example by using access to obtain customer financial information and committing credit card fraud.
- tptacek 3y agoA forensics investigation is usually required by insurers. It's not an arbitrary amount of money, it's just an amount you're not happy with. I understand why you feel that way, but it's not the way the law works.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoServices can negotiate the terms of their insurance contract or even choose whether or not to carry insurance. They agree to these terms and know the implications, and again, if the need for the investigation is legitimate then they should be conducting it regardless of how the vulnerability is uncovered. > it's not the way the law works. Which is problematic.
- woah 3y ago> This seems like a problem with the existing law, if that's how it works. > I understand why you feel that way, but it's not the way the law works. OP was saying they don't think the law should work that way.
- tptacek 3y agoWait'll they learn about the Eggshell Skull Rule.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThis is more in the neighborhood of contributory negligence.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- singleshot_ 3y agoStrange things happen every day but in my experience the jury decides on the damages, not the plaintiff.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWe're talking about what rule the law should intend to be used, not who applies the rule.
- singleshot_ 3y agoYou were talking about both but you were mistaken about the rule as well. Your focus on causation suggests you’re struggling with the idea that a second order event stemming from a breach could be compensatory damages, but of course it would fall within consequential damages if causation was found to be sufficiently attenuated.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're just misreading the post. The "victim" doesn't calculate the damages, but a rule that makes the damages depend on actions the corporation voluntarily chooses to take allows them to vindictively maximize the penalties on someone who merely embarrassed them. Which is a perverse incentive that should be removed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- singleshot_ 3y agoYeah, I guess you’re right. It would be more fair to the defendant to let him specify the damages. After all, he is the only one who knows what harm he intended to inflict. Without that knowledge, how could we establish causation?