4 ms·
Damnit. There are two 'mysteries' around mast years: One, which this article covers, is pretty much common wisdom at this point. Does 'common wisdom' need to b
by hinkley 3y ago
Damnit.
There are two 'mysteries' around mast years: One, which this article covers, is pretty much common wisdom at this point. Does 'common wisdom' need to be reviewed? Of course it does.
The bigger mystery is HOW DO ALL THE TREES KNOW? Mast years don't happen in one grove, in one strain or in one forest. They happen everywhere, even in different microbiomes that may have received more or less rainfall that year.
I was hoping this was delving into that secret, for which no theories have survived testing.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoThere are, of course, theories that trees / plants communicate in some way (e.g. chemical markers, similar to pheromones), but if you haven't found anything solid then they haven't found any conclusive evidence yet. There's probably loads we haven't discovered yet. I mean didn't they discover a whole new system in humans (next to the blood vessels, nerves and lymphatic system)?
- hinkley 3y agoThey discovered the lymphatic system has channels in connective tissue. Is that the one you're thinking about? A lot of Eastern Medicine and massage people I'm sure felt vindicated by that one.
- hyllos 3y agoWell, I'd be not too much surprised if it's an external factor like sun cycle, earth magnetism or any other natural rhythm. Did they exclude that? How, if?
- dtgriscom 3y agoUneducated hypothesis; the choice of a mast year isn't random, but is some sort of response to the environment. If that's true, then multiple trees in the same environment will tend to have the same mast years.
- hinkley 3y agoIt's all the trees in at least a bioregion though. If they're not upwind or downwind from each other, if some are in the foothills and see more rain, nobody has caught them masting on a different cycle. Which is just fuckin' weird.
- trhway 3y agofungi network? There were studies how the trees help each other through the fungi networks - though my thinking is that it is fungi who balance the tree coverage to their liking. Either way the studies clearly established that the fungi network is a tree communicating network of at least grove-scale. I think it may as well be much bigger - especially if it is fungi who would orchestrate, or at least symbiotically help to orchestrate, the mast year behavior.
- vlovich123 3y agoHas the mycorrhizal network been tested as the communication method?
- rcme 3y agoWouldn't this occur naturally if trees were "programmed" to have a mast year every N years? Sure, some trees wouldn't be synchronized at first, but the likelihood of propagation is proportional to the number of other trees sharing a mast year, so eventually groups of trees that were synchronized would emerge.