3 ms·
> It felt like more than a few inches. It's hard to tell because the camera is at such a weird angle, but from what I can see the vehicle remains pretty firmly
by lolinder 3y ago
> It felt like more than a few inches.
It's hard to tell because the camera is at such a weird angle, but from what I can see the vehicle remains pretty firmly behind the stop line throughout the entire encounter. We can quibble about how fast it was accelerating, but I regularly see worse false starts at lights.
> When this car made this mistake, someone else (Elon) had to stop it. These are not equivalent. In the former case you can argue no accident was going to happen, but in the latter you can't.
I'm actually more worried about the human case than the human+autonomous case. In the human case it is up to the entity that made the mistake to correct their own mistake. In the autonomous vehicle case you effectively have a second set of eyes as long as the driver is paying attention (which they should be and Musk was). This is why I say that it makes a difference that this was internal testing—the driver wasn't a dumb consumer trusting the vehicle, it was the CEO of the company who knew he was using in-progress software.
> This is on a public road. Try pulling this off (well, please don't) in medicine and see how it goes.
Requiring that autonomous vehicles never be tested on a public road in real world conditions is another way of saying that you do not believe autonomous vehicles should ever exist. At some point they have to be tested in the real world, and they will make mistakes when they leave the controlled conditions of a closed course.
- dee-bee 3y ago> Requiring that autonomous vehicles never be tested on a public road in real world conditions is another way of saying that you do not believe autonomous vehicles should ever exist. Sure, but that's a wildly different case than "it's ready for public roads we super promise"
- lolinder 3y agoAs I noted at the very beginning of my first comment, I am a huge critic of many things that Tesla does, and releasing their software in beta to casual drivers is something I'm strongly opposed to. All I'm saying here is that this specific critique of this specific video is misplaced.
- dee-bee 3y agoFair.
- Veserv 3y agoThe dash visualization clearly shows the blue line that indicates the intended driving course heading straight into the center of the intersection. External intervention was required to stop the car from entering the center of the intersection.
- dataflow 3y ago> remains pretty firmly behind the stop line throughout the entire encounter That's not the same thing as "inched forward" is my point. > In the human case it is up to the entity that made the mistake to correct their own mistake. You're completely ignoring how likely these events are or how severe the errors are in the first place. You can't jus count the number of correction points and measure safety solely based on that. > Requiring that autonomous vehicles never be tested on a public road I never said that. (How did you get from "look at how it's done in medicine" to "this should never be done"?) What I do expect is responsible testing, which implies you don't test in production until at least you yourself are damn sure that you've done everything you possibly can otherwise. Given everything in the video I see no reason to believe that was the case here.