4 ms·
An IP address was never supposed to be personally identifiable info. If we treat it as such then no P2P service can ever work, and the internet will forever be
by paxys 3y ago
An IP address was never supposed to be personally identifiable info. If we treat it as such then no P2P service can ever work, and the internet will forever be under the control of a few large corps running data centers.
The real solution here is to completely disconnect an IP address from a person or physical location. Broad adoption of IPv6 will be a big step towards that.
- jan_Sate 3y agoHow could IPv6 help on that? They could just use the prefix to figure out which network you're coming from.
- byteknight 3y agoI think they are referring the the shear number of IPs available and ease of switching. Not a solid argument, but it is the only thing I can think of though for their argument.
- paxys 3y agoYes, but "network" itself is an abstract concept. Because the addresses aren't scarce you can theoretically get a new one every day, or every time you log on, and throw it away right after. Each device you own can also have its own IP, without any NATs in the way and no way to tie them together.
- Anon_Forever 3y ago>but "network" itself is an abstract concept. This is incorrect. IPv6 network routing prefixes are not an "abstract" concept. They are effectively the same PII as an IPv4 address. You can identify a user by their routing prefix, much like you can identify a user by their IPv4 address. All of their devices will have IPv6 addresses from their unique prefix much like all of their devices will have the same unique IPv4 address if they're using NAT.
- ynik 3y agoIPv6 has the advantage that the ISP can give customers multiple prefixes at the same time, thus allowing rotation of the prefix without interrupting existing TCP connections. With IPv4, ISPs that want to rotate IP addresses have to forcibly disconnect their users (e.g. every 24h). This is a common practice, though probably mostly intended to allow charging business customers more if they need a stable IP. But the privacy side effect is also nice. But other than that minor point (which many ISPs are not taking advantage of), IPv4 addresses and IPv6 network prefixes are essentially the same privacy-wise: uniquely identifying an ISP customer, i.e. a family, not an individual.
- para_parolu 3y agoQuestion from someone who don’t know much about IP. Isn’t ipv4 better for privacy from practical standpoint? Most of the time users are behind bunch of NATs. And with ipv6 premise (I may be wrong here) it “public ip for every device”. Which should make it easier to track people.
- paxys 3y agoWhile end devices are usually behind NATs, most ISPs out there still ensure that every customer has a unique public facing IP address which is tied to them long term. My own residential IP (with Comcast) hasn't changed in years.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoThere's NAT and then there's CGNAT and basically all of the new wave ISPs are using it. But, I'd rather deal with the cgnat annoyances than ever have a financial relationship with Mediacom again.
- betaby 3y agoISPs in Singapore for example absolutely store mapping of your name+your CGNAT RFC6598 IP + port.
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoRegulatory compliance?
- betaby 3y agoIt is. Also that data is stored for 3+ years.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoThere is a router with one IP address. If there is more than one user/device behind the router, how are you going to have IP address for each user?
- davidmurdoch 3y agoMeanwhile, we've got ISPs like MetroNet removing support for IPV6 in markets that previously had it, and entering new markets with CGNAT (many customers with 1 IP) as default.
- kstrauser 3y agoHIPAA defines an IP address as PII, especially in combination with any other identifier. If you have a first name + IP, or an email + IP, then federal law says that’s PII.
- that_guy_iain 3y agoThey were saying it wasn't meant to be personally identifable. Not that it wasn't. And they're right, a large part of the foundations of the internet were built and designed for the past and what was happening in the past with no real idea of how it would all grow and we would continue to use these building blocks. Email is a great example. We've patched things on top of it to try and fix the fundamental flaws but they're still there. An easy one is that you don't have to prove you own an email address to send an email that looks like it's from that sender. We added DKIM, DMARC, etc. But the flaw still fundamentally exists.
- kstrauser 3y agoUnderstood, and I don't disagree with their idea of how it ought to be. But realistically, that ship has sailed. It's even coded into law now: an IP identifies a finite group of specific people. I wish that weren't the case, and I roll my eyes every time that comes up in a legal conversation, but we lost the argument. As an aside, although I haven't seen any explicit language discussing this, I'd say that an IPv6 (even a random one thanks to privacy extensions) is exactly equal to an IPv4 address. My house has a static IPv6 prefix, so if you see an IP from that subnet, it's someone in my house, exactly as if our shared IPv4 address showed up in the logs. In my opinion, the host portion of the address is basically equivalent to a random port number for identification purposes.
- devwastaken 3y ago>An IP address was never supposed to be personally identifiable info. Says who? an IP is absolutely PII from its inception. It's an identifier. "IP X is requesting xxxsite.com? That's assigned to Larry in accounting. Better call HR." >internet will forever be under the control of a few large corps running data centers. It alway was, is, and forever will be. Someone has to host things, this only works at scale. >The real solution here is to completely disconnect an IP address from a person or physical location This is called a VPN. or as I like to call it, an IP tumbler. When the major super powers no longer need it for espionage the current loopholes will be closed. The net became popular, it is by nature easy to abuse, therefore people will regulate it until it is "safe", of course it will only look that way.
- fluoridation 3y ago>Says who? an IP is absolutely PII from its inception. It's an identifier. "IP X is requesting xxxsite.com? That's assigned to Larry in accounting. Better call HR." No, it's locally identifiable information. IP X is assigned to Larry's computer. That might be Larry making that request, but it should be considered a leap in logic to reach that conclusion without more information.
- dragonwriter 3y agoIdentifiers assigned to objects associated with people, even indirectly, are PII even if it is possible for them to be misleading. PII doesn't require that the information be incapable of being misleading, otherwise almost nothing would be PII.
- open592 3y agoDidn't read the article, but the more prevalent issue with obtaining your IP from Skype usually isn't that it's going to uncover your identity, but that someone will be able to DDoS you (for example while playing online games)
- kube-system 3y agoAn IP address was always designed to identify a computer. That’s the point of an address. The part that made them (approximately) personally identifiable is the invention of personal computers.
- mschuster91 3y ago> An IP address was never supposed to be personally identifiable info. Fact is, it is legally classified as PII, at least in the GDPR sphere. > If we treat it as such then no P2P service can ever work, and the internet will forever be under the control of a few large corps running data centers. We are already at that point. Host anything on the Internet without Cloudflare, Akamai or other CDNs and you will get targeted by skiddies running exploits on everything they find on Shodan, and if you're a noteworthy social media person (i.e. a streamer), there are enough completely braindead trolls that will stop at nothing to get you off the internet: if you are lucky you'll just get DDoS'd, if you attract the more toxic arseholes, you will end up having your door kicked in by a SWAT team. > The real solution here is to completely disconnect an IP address from a person or physical location. Broad adoption of IPv6 will be a big step towards that. That doesn't fix anything, it just makes hacking a specific machine a bit harder. Bad actors will just spam your entire /64 (because that's your provider's default allocation) instead. The solution is to kick bad actors off of the Internet - and all sorts of bad actors at that: people running compromised devices that are used by the actual bad actors, people running services that end up being used by bad actors such as SS7 access brokers or VoIP providers lacking auditing, bad actors themselves, and nation states like Russia, China, North Korea, Iran that actively conduct or tolerate hacking campaigns or India and Turkey that don't do shit against scam callcenters.
- p1mrx 3y ago> completely disconnect an IP address from a person or physical location The main purpose of an IP address is to deliver packets to some location in the world via the shortest path. You could imagine adding a Tor-like indirection layer to IP, but this would necessarily make the network slower because we can't increase the speed of light. Perhaps an ISP could regularly reshuffle its IP addresses within a geographical region, but it only takes a few bad actors to send the whole region to CAPTCHA hell.