4 ms·
Lithium Ion should be replaced ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely. As far as I'm concerned this should have never gotten as far
by jacquesm 3y ago
Lithium Ion should be replaced ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely. As far as I'm concerned this should have never gotten as far as it did and manufacturers that produce crap batteries (of which there are plenty!) should be held responsible.
Apropos: not rare at all to open AAA brand battery packs to find burned out wiring, burned out circuit boards, signs of combustion that somehow didn't go outside of the case. Take no risk with these things, even with the good ones: in case of doubt place in fireproof container and deliver to a recycling station that knows how to handle them safely. If you have no experience with these then do not try to repair a pack because the risks are nothing to be trifled with.
Finally: cheap stuff containing 18650's should be avoided like the plague, if the device is cheap then that means the components are even cheaper. Only use devices that use quality cells, that haven't been recycled and that have only been used within spec.
Your fire insurance policy protects you from monetary loss, but it won't revive you or your companions...
- Filligree 3y ago> Lithium Ion should be replaces ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely. As far as I'm concerned this should have never gotten as far as it did and manufacturers that produce crap batteries (of which there are plenty!) should be held responsible. What should they be replaced with? I'm curious to know what alternate chemistry you're proposing for my e-bike battery.
- tecleandor 3y agoUsually, the safer replacement for Lithium Ion would be LiFePO4. Although I don't know how good performs in e-bikes (I guess it should be fine, as they're used in cars and other stuff...)
- jacquesm 3y agoIt works just fine for that application. But: it is a little bit more expensive for the same capacity, and unfortunately the voltage is a little bit lower so it isn't a drop-in replacement.
- Filligree 3y agoIsn't it also quite a bit heavier?
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, about 50%. So for the same amount of energy you need a larger and heavier battery. Typically the largest capacity Lithium Ion in 18650 format is roughly comparable to a 26650 LIFEPO4. And then there is still the voltage difference (nominally 3.2 for LIFEPO4 and 3.6 for Li-ion).
- loeg 3y ago50% heavier is kind of a problem for E-Bike applications, although maybe not on the low end.
- getarofilter 3y ago[dead]
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, it is, otoh on the weight of the whole bike it isn't a huge problem.
- loeg 3y ago> otoh on the weight of the whole bike it isn't a huge problem. Why do you say this? Non-ebikes can be sub-16 lbs; ebike battery packs can weigh, like, on the order of 50 lbs. Ebike users sometimes need to lift the bikes (up stairs at home, or on/off transit). Battery pack weight absolutely dominates the design and utility of ebikes; any double-digit percent factor is very relevant (IMO).
- jeffbee 3y ago> on the order of 50 lbs A really large e-bike battery is 4kg. Nobody is riding an e-bike with 50 pounds of batteries. Even the battery pack on a Zero FX, an electric motorcycle, is only 42 pounds.
- thworp 3y ago> Lithium Ion should be replaces ASAP by safer chemistries so we can sidestep this issue completely That would be nice, but so far there are no good candidates that have anywhere near the energy density of Li-based cells. As far as I understand it, besides material degradation and overcharge/overdraw, the energy density itself poses a risk. So even if we had that miracle cell chemistry it would be still pose a fire hazard when subjected to mechanical stress. The stored energy has to go somewhere.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's true, there are some inherent risks that are hard to mitigate. But those are roughly equivalent to say a gasoline fire or something like that. They are not due to handling the stuff or working on it. Though in fairness: working on an ICE car, especially the fuel supply system is not without risk.
- clomond 3y agoLi-ion is a very big umbrella of battery chemistries, and within can have broadly different safety and stability profiles. More important is that Li-ion cells are no joke, and are not equivalent to ‘AA’ or ‘AAA’ battery formats. You can NCM, NCA, LFP, Cobalt chemistries and blends within - not even accounting for differing mAH and charge/discharge capacities. 18650 is simply a form factor. Better labeling, specing, regulated and certified repair processes are just a start for solutions as it is currently a Wild West. However, statements like ‘Li-ion should be replaced ASAP’ do not factor in that… lithium ion as a platform is not going anywhere and has essentially won at least the next half century for 18650 type form factors and applications. Moving away is not a reasonable solution.
- jacquesm 3y agoLithium Ion without further designation refers to Lithium Polymer or plain Lithium Ion cells such as this one: https://eu.nkon.nl/products/sony-murata-us18650-vtc6.html https://eu.nkon.nl/products/sony-murata-us18650-vtc6.html Other chemistries are usually indicated by a different designation, such as LiFePO4, LTO and so on.
- sbradford26 3y agoSorry but that just isn't right. The battery you listed is an just an NMC battery , the listing pages are just lazy and don't list it. There isn't just a plain lithium ion cell. Also lithium polymer just means that a polymer electrolyte is used instead of a liquid electrolyte. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's pedantic. They're sold that way by the truck load and anybody that buys them for DIY purposes knows that this is how they are designated. People are buying based on the working voltage nominally 3.6V, Lithium Ion chemistry, battery capacity, form factor. Not on the internal details of the battery, which are not normally listed in sales documentation on consumer oriented outlets anyway. Yes, you can go into the details of the exact chemistry, the packaging, the manufacturers specs and so on but for bulk DIY purposes this is the reality. The detailed chemistry obviously has some implications for safety but because you will have no idea what is in a pack unless you open it (and plenty of times the cells are unmarked) you just have to assume the worst. That's the safest.