4 ms·
I'm one of the more vocal Tesla critics on here, but I think we can do better than this example. The left turn arrow turned green, the car inched forward a lit
by lolinder 3y ago
I'm one of the more vocal Tesla critics on here, but I think we can do better than this example.
The left turn arrow turned green, the car inched forward a little, and Elon immediately put on the brakes. The situation was no more dangerous than when a human driver mistakes which light is theirs and does the same thing, which happens pretty regularly in my experience.
And that this is a test version of the software isn't irrelevant, it makes a huge difference—I am much less opposed to internal company testers who know what they're doing than I am to a public beta in the hands of people who believe Tesla's (really egregious) marketing.
- causi 3y agoI am much less opposed to internal company testers who know what they're doing than I am to a public beta in the hands of people who believe Tesla's (really egregious) marketing Which category do you think Elon Musk is more likely to belong to?
- echelon 3y agoThe fervor over this is unwarranted. When cars first debuted, they were incredibly dangerous and killed lots of people. Yet we persisted. Airplanes, too. Fully autonomous cars are on the streets of San Francisco. They run into trouble, yet the experiment persists. We should allow for civil suits, especially when negligence is found, but the only way to progress forward is to make real world attempts. The promise of autonomous driving is worth trillions of dollars for all of the opportunity it will unlock. And as macabre as it may be, there will continue to be deaths along that development path.
- whiddershins 3y ago[flagged]
- swexbe 3y agoCars were not "incredibly dangerous" when they first debuted because they topped out at about 40 mph (and went considerably slower most of the time). That's pretty comparable to a horse and carraige.
- asciii 3y agoYes they were. Besides the speed aspect, there were other things too. For example, the hand crank was known to be fatal and pushed the founder of Cadillac, Henry Leland, to get it rid of it when it his friend was killed after helping a lady on the side of road. https://www.studebakermuseum.org/blog/the-1912-cadillac-a-self-starter/ https://www.studebakermuseum.org/blog/the-1912-cadillac-a-se...
- rob74 3y agoYeah, the danger posed by cars was initially limited because they had to share the road with lots of slower traffic (carts, bicycles, pedestrians etc. etc.). Only forbidding pedestrians from using the same space as cars enabled cars to become dangerous in the first place...
- tzs 3y agoAlso, horses were incredibly dangerous. In NYC in 1900 for example the pedestrian fatality rate from horses was higher than the NYC 2003 pedestrian fatality rate from cars [1]. Similarly in England and Wales deaths from horse-drawn vehicles were around 70 per 1 million people per year in the early 1900s. That's in the same ballpark as motor vehicle deaths in the 1980s and '90s (80-100 per 1 million people per year) [2]. (It should be noted that medical technology is better now. A lot of those 1900 fatalities would probably have been preventable if they had current medical technology). A lot of people on HN seem to view the horse era as some sort of idyllic safe, quiet, and unobtrusive pedestrian and rider paradise. It was not. From that second article: > It is easy to imagine that a hundred years ago, when cars were first appearing on our roads, they replaced previously peaceful, gentle and safe forms of travel. In fact, motor vehicles were welcomed as the answer to a desperate state of affairs. In 1900 it was calculated that in England and Wales there were around 100,000 horse drawn public passenger vehicles, half a million trade vehicles and about half a million private carriages. Towns in England had to cope with over 100 million tons of horse droppings a year (much of it was dumped at night in the slums) and countless gallons of urine. Men wore spats and women favoured outdoor ankle-length coats not out of a sense of fashion but because of the splash of liquified manure; and it was so noisy that straw had to be put down outside hospitals to muffle the clatter of horses’ hooves. Worst of all, with horses and carriages locked in immovable traffic jams, transport was grinding to a halt in London and other cities. and > Motor vehicles were welcomed because they were faster, safer, unlikely to swerve or bolt, better able brake in an emergency, and took up less room: a single large lorry could pull a load that would take several teams of horses and wagons – and do so without producing any dung. By World War One industry had become dependent on lorries, traffic cruised freely down Oxford Street and Piccadilly, specialists parked their expensive cars ouside their houses in Harley and Wimpole Street, and the lives of general practitioners were transformed. By using even the cheapest of cars doctors no longer had to wake the stable lad and harness the horse to attend a night call. Instead it was ‘one pull of the handle and they were off’. Further, general practitioners could visit nearly twice as many patients in a day than they could in the days of the horse and trap. [1] https://legallysociable.com/2012/09/07/figures-more-deaths-per-capita-in-horse-accidents-in-nyc-in-1900-than-in-auto-accidents-today/ https://legallysociable.com/2012/09/07/figures-more-deaths-p... [2] https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/31/cars-and-horses https://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/31/cars-and-horse...
- waffleiron 3y agoIf we allow criminal suits when drivers kill someone due to carelessness we should allow criminal suits when companies kill people due to carelessness. Companies shouldn’t be held to lower standards than individuals.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoI wouldn't really say “we persisted” in the case of cars, as much as the auto industry threw boatloads of money at lobbying to make people shift the blame from cars to their victims. Cars didn't get safer (for the people outside them), we just started blaming the people they killed instead.
- echelon 3y agoThat's absolutely part of the equation. Back when we used horses for everything, people used to walk aimlessly in streets and children used to play in them. We advocate against that now. Society chose a new mandate. It wasn't just the auto companies - it was all of us.
- cornercasechase 3y ago> The promise of autonomous driving is worth trillions of dollars for all of the opportunity it will unlock. And as macabre as it may be, there will continue to be deaths along that development path. “We should kill people because it will unlock market opportunity”, is why we need to start charging the people in charge of these companies with murder when they inevitably do just that. I don’t care about Tesla stock, I care about not being killed by one of Musk’s “hype” projects.
- echelon 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rxhernandez 3y ago> And that this is a test version of the software isn't irrelevant, it makes a huge difference—I am much less opposed to internal company testers who know what they're doing than I am to a public beta in the hands of people who believe Tesla's (really egregious) marketing. There is absolutely no reason you should assume "testers" know what they are doing. I have met plenty of people with decades of experience in "testing" barely know what they are doing. Even in the case they know what they are doing, they shouldn't be testing a *deadly* vehicle with potentially broken software on heavily populated *public* roads.
- lolinder 3y ago> Even in the case they know what they are doing, they shouldn't be testing a deadly vehicle with potentially broken software on heavily populated public roads. This is another way of saying that self-driving vehicles shouldn't exist at all. At some point we have to test them on public roads, preferably before putting the software into the hands of regular users. If you ban even internal company testing, then what you're saying is that self-driving vehicles should never exist.
- jjoonathan 3y agoAgreed, but I'd go further. > This is another way of saying that self-driving vehicles shouldn't exist at all. It's another way of saying that self-driving vehicles should be invented somewhere else, so that in 10 years you have to beg and plead for an overpriced second-rate implementation with a worse safety profile.
- rxhernandez 3y agoNot even remotely the same thing. You completely glossed over me saying potentially broken software and heavily populated. Surely there is a way to simulate a left turn signal in a more safe manner on software this early in the testing process.
- lolinder 3y agoAll software is potentially broken. If you've only ever tested your software in a controlled driving range, then you don't know how it will behave when you take it out into the real world. If you've only ever tested it on lightly populated roads, then you don't know how it will behave when you take it onto heavily populated roads. It's not surprising that it made a mistake during testing. That's what testing is for: rooting out mistakes.
- jjoonathan 3y agoThey seem to be serious about attentiveness monitoring and strikes. No more weights: https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/zv5xp9/a_warning_to_all_steering_wheel_weight_users/ https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/zv5xp9/a_warni... How strikes work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otknSUQ4ICY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otknSUQ4ICY
- Veserv 3y agoExcept for the part where they can not even detect trivial cases. One of the easiest possible cases, a giant teddy bear in the seat “holding” the wheel (by attaching a simple weight to the wheel), is determined to be a attentive driver [1]. A T-ball and they strike out. The inability to robustly solve simple, obvious cases and not failing safe is indicative of a sloppy development and validation process that is incompatible with the deployment of a safe safety-critical device. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPMoLmQgxTw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPMoLmQgxTw
- dataflow 3y ago> the car inched forward It felt like more than a few inches. (I'm not splitting hairs here, I really do feel it was qualitatively significantly different from your description, which made it sound like the car was cautiously starting to move just a bit.) > and Elon immediately put on the brakes. The situation was no more dangerous than when a human driver mistakes which light is theirs and does the same thing, which happens pretty regularly in my experience. When humans make this mistake, they stop the car themselves. When this car made this mistake, someone else (Elon) had to stop it. These are not equivalent. In the former case you can argue no accident was going to happen, but in the latter you can't. > that this is a test version of the software isn't irrelevant, it makes a huge difference—I am much less opposed to internal company testers who know what they're doing This is on a public road. Try pulling this off (well, please don't) in medicine and see how it goes.
- andsoitis 3y ago> When humans make this mistake, they stop the car themselves. When this car made this mistake, someone else (Elon) had to stop it. These are not equivalent. In the former case you can argue no accident was going to happen, but in the latter you can't. This is not nuanced enough. I've been in a cab to JFK in the snow and the driver was speeding around a turn that the car started sliding and eventually crashed into the side of the road. There are now over 40,000 car accident fatalities in the US per year. So no, humans make mistakes that they cannot correct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...
- dataflow 3y agoEr, your comment is the one lacking nuance. There was no snow here, nor did I claim accidents never happen. I was trying to get across a point about the parent's argument.
- frumper 3y agoYour point boils down to a "what if" though. If it's as dangerous as you make it, then you should be able to show plenty of examples where actual harm is happening. Showcase those.