9 ms·
You can activate the emergency stop in any train. Just like that, go figure! No security around those things at all, sometimes a thin pane of glass but that's e
by jacquesm 3y ago
You can activate the emergency stop in any train. Just like that, go figure! No security around those things at all, sometimes a thin pane of glass but that's easily taken care of. Or light an emergency flare next to the tracks. If it's that simple you almost have an obligation to show how insecure this is. And you could easily orchestrate this or do it again a short while later on another train.
/s
Whatever happened to personal responsibility? Hackers without ethics (no matter whether acting on their own or for some larger entity) are less than useless.
- rightbyte 3y ago> If it's that simple you almost have an obligation to show how insecure this is. Please don't spread this "white hat hacker" extortion mindset to my neighbourhoods. I don't even lock my door. Thank you.
- jacquesm 3y agoSorry, that should have had an /s appended (I thought it was obvious given the last sentence). Fixed. Personally I've had it with the so called 'hackers'. They're just criminals. Oh and I think you meant to write 'lock' not 'look'.
- rightbyte 3y agoHeh ok ye well you never know.
- raverbashing 3y agoIt's always funny when those "grey hats" or similar "it's just a prank bros" find out they're "vulnerable" to a pair of handcuffs, or to judicial findings, or even worse things
- jacquesm 3y agoI've had a several months long run in with a so-called 'hacker' on HN who is now - fortunately - in jail for something else. This got really tedious and the lack of support was quite frustrating (to put it mildly). I'm sure he thought it was all fun and games. He's threatened swatting people on here, destroying their businesses, families and so on. And all from the relative safety of what he believed to be anonymity. Such people have no place in society and setting them loose on neighboring countries is inviting a tit-for-tat that we can all do without. Personally I think these attacks are very close to - or already over the threshold for - acts of war.
- pjerem 3y ago> You can activate the emergency stop in any train. Just like that, go figure! No security around those things at all That’s false, at least on modern trains, in France, for what I know. Any modern train will not stop when you pull the alarm lever. The first thing that will happen is that you will be in communication with the conductor, then the train will be stopped in only two scenarios : either you are communicating a real emergency or you don’t respond at all to the conductor asking you what happens after a given delay (which IIRC is 10 seconds). And fwiw, a friend of mine who is conductor explained to me that if you activate the alarm lever by inadvertence, the worst thing you can do is to not answer by fear of having problems. If you say it’s an error, the conductor will just ignore it and continue its day while if you say nothing, the conductor is forced to emergency brake the train and all the trains on the line.
- jacquesm 3y agoSo: just that: you don't need to do anything beyond pulling the lever to get the train to stop. The override is that you say everything is ok, but if you do not the train will absolutely stop. This is to ensure that if the driver / conductor is incapacitated the train will still come to a halt. And that in turn is because runaway trains have happened.
- johannes1234321 3y agoI don't know the French way, but coming form Germany: For logner tunnels etc there is an override, where emergency break doesn't break immediately as stopping a train mid-tunnel is most of the time the worst choice. Smoke in tunnel is dangerous. Emergency help can't reach it. Evacuation has confined space. etc. There emergency break rings an alarm with the engineer. If they ignore it, it will stop after a while, but usually they will use intercomm to understand the reason. A way however you can stop trains on a German train line is by putting a 2kHz electromagnet on the tracks. That will tell the train that it just crossed a red signal and will stop.
- jacquesm 3y agoPlease edit your comment and take that info out. I understand you mean well but spreading this is stupendously risky.