3 ms·
> I'm pointing out that that isn't a good way to screen papers, because most English speakers don't share the same dialect. You did not make that clear at all.
by bowsamic 3y ago
> I'm pointing out that that isn't a good way to screen papers, because most English speakers don't share the same dialect.
You did not make that clear at all.
> Perhaps unstated or understated is the implication that, were you to discard papers in this way, you're liable to miss out.
Indeed, that implication was totally missing.
> Feel free to downvote my comment if you don't feel it was appropriate or informative or otherwise didn't uphold whatever criteria you're judging it by.
I would certainly do so. Like their paper, it is quite poor, and not helpful for this forum. Unfortunately, /u/dang has removed my ability to downvote.
- maxbond 3y agoAlrighty. Thanks for the feedback. Have a great day. (For what it's worth, I often feel my comments are too long and wordy, and occasionally I've gotten feedback to that effect, so I was trying to be brief in my original comment.)
- bt1a 3y agoi understood your original comment :) totally agree that dismissing the content of a paper for its grammatical mistakes alone is foolish. this isn’t a paper about classic roman literature