2 ms·
This article is very inconsistent and misleading. - Right off the bat, the Venn diagram is wrong (with regard to the author's thesis that there is only open so
by kazinator 3y ago
This article is very inconsistent and misleading.
- Right off the bat, the Venn diagram is wrong (with regard to the author's thesis that there is only open source and proprietary) since it suggests that there is "source available" that is not proprietary (outside of the proprietary bubble) and not open source (outside of that bubble). Why draw a diagram that doesn't follow your rhetoric?
- "any software whose license doesn't belong to the OSI's list is proprietary software" is just ridiculous. He's literally saying that if you hire some lawyers and create a new FOSS license, it's proprietary because it doesn't appear on OSI's list.
- "All licenses on this list are guaranteed to adhere to a fixed set of criteria. These criteria guarantee four essential freedoms:" is just off the cliff. He's claiming that all the OSI licenses jibe with the GNU Projects or Free Software Foundation's definition of free software. A counterexample is any BSD or MIT licensed software which has users that do not have those freedoms due to receiving only a binary. Both OSI and FSF agree that those licenses are, respectively, open source and free, but the FSF will not agree that those licenses preserve those freedoms. BSD-licensed software is free because it's GPL-compatible: a GPLed program can use BSD-licensed pieces. Since OSI burst on the scene some quarter century ago, pushing the open source rhetoric and agenda, they permanently locked horns with Stallman and his Free Software crusade. The OSI has its own definition of what is open source: https://opensource.org/definition-annotated/ https://opensource.org/definition-annotated/
The obvious conclusion is that the author is barely starting to be knowledgeable in this area.
And, no, software is not exhaustively partitioned into open source and proprietary. A binary executable (or ROM image or whatever) can land into the public domain. Then you have non-proprietary code that isn't open source because there is no source.