4 ms·
This idea of the "desktop" still persists. I have often read description of the BSD projects as "server" oriented. Thus some may conclude, NetBSD is for server
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
This idea of the "desktop" still persists. I have often read description of the BSD projects as "server" oriented. Thus some may conclude, NetBSD is for servers.
However when I look at the personal computers I run today, there is no "desktop" because I prefer textmode and I am running many tiny servers. These serve only me not the internet at-large.
The dream I had at the time of NetBSD 5.1 was a framebuffer where I could launch GUI applications from the command line in VESA textmode, without any context switch (Ctrl-Alt-F1, etc.) back to X11.
If I have the choice between "desktop" and "server" in 2023, I choose server. The "server" is a more useful metaphor for for me than the "desktop" ever was. Eye candy GUIs can be seductive, but IME servers operated with text commands and text configuration files are more powerful and ultimately more useful. As it happens, the server metaphor is quite common. For example, it's used to run the web.
NetBSD 5.1 was great. Arguably one of the best releases in the project's history.
- accrual 3y agoI like the idea of a textmode computing life. What is your preferred way to browse the web?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago1. Make HTTP requests with variety of software, but not graphical web browser, including shell scripts, TCP clients and custom UNIX-like programs, i.e., small, easy-to-use in pipes. 2. Use text-only browser to read HTML. I make heavy use of HTTP/1,1 pipelining so I'm not "browsing" as much as I am doing bulk HTML or JSON retrieval from a single host. This cannot be done with graphical web browser nor with curl, wget or even aria2.^1 Often I get downvoted by HTTP/2 or HTTP/3 fans on HN when I discuss this because it is not contemplated in their vision for the web, i.e., interactive websites, graphical advertising and imperceptible data collection and tracking. (For example, they will say something like, "No one else does that". Who cares.^2 I'm doing it. The way the majority of people use the web has nothing to do with how they want to use it. They made no choice between one option or another that is significantly different. They are only using the web in the way dictated to them by so-called "tech" companies and legions of hivemind web developers, all praying to the same God of Advertising. The web was not created nor designed for mandatory delivery and receipt of advertising, it was created for whatever people want it to use it for; it's quite versatile.) Sometimes I play around with nghttp2 and it just feels totally inflexible. Bad ergonomics for how I use the web. Using a browser from an advertising company shapes the way people think of the web. It limits thinking and especially thinking outside the box. Look for the replies that seek to discredit those who aberrate from use of the web as mechanism for delivery and receipt of advertising. If I preferred what was "common", then I would not be using NetBSD. And if it was as popular I suspect it would be less good. Quite confident other NetBSD users have had that thought before. Some software developers stuggle to understand why others might not care about popularity because they live their lives desperately hoping/trying to get others to use the software they write. But I'm not a software developer and I like stuff that is not popular, especially non-popular software. 1. To be truthful, with aria2 it's technically possible but not designed for use in UNIX pipes. 2. Answer: Advertisers, but certainly not me.
- nvy 3y ago>However when I look at the personal computers I run today, there is no "desktop" because I prefer textmode and I am running many tiny servers. That puts you in the vanishingly-small minority. To borrow a phrase from Tom Ptacek: to a decent first approximation, zero people including you are daily-driving text mode for their personal machines. People describe "desktop-oriented" distros as such because they're filled with niceties such as support for multiple physical displays, sub-pixel LCD hinting, sane defaults for mouse/touchpad input, graphical wifi managers, and usually desktop environments. They ship with these things out of the box. Imagine recommending with a straight face that someone go to starbucks and manually edit wpa_supplicant.conf to get onto the wifi. People describe distros as "server-oriented" because while you could achieve the aforementioned niceties with them, it's usually a hassle. In my experience BSD (or Gentoo) aficionados tend to eschew the term "hassle" in favor of sayings like "minimal" or "exactly what I want and no more" or the ever-popular but always meaningless "cohesive" when describing those operating systems. In any case, the "desktop" metaphor might not be useful to you but consider that your use case is far from common.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>Imagine recommending with a straight face that someone go to starbucks and manually edit wpa_supplicant.conf to get onto the wifi. Linux in a nutshell.
- megous 3y ago> Imagine recommending with a straight face that someone go to starbucks and manually edit wpa_supplicant.conf to get onto the wifi. Editing config files is not specific to TUI, you can do it even with GUI editor, and you have to if you want to do anything more complicated with your computer, like route some traffic over VPN and some not, or have a dynamic VPN setup based on what wifi network you're connected to. Also in the TUI land, there's iwd these days which has nicer end-user text mode UI than wpa_cli, with one command to start a scan, and another to connect. There's also wifi-menu, or nmtui. All pretty much equivalent to the GUI wifi selection menus people use on windows.
- rahen 3y ago> NetBSD 5.1 was great. Arguably one of the best releases in the project's history. What would make it one of the best in your opinion? I used to like 1.6 and 2.0 a lot, personally.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIs it even possible to download the 1.6 source these days. Everything was moved to archive.netbsd.org, not FTP access and all I can get from https://archive.netbsd.org/pub/NetBSD-archive/NetBSD-1.6/source/sets/ https://archive.netbsd.org/pub/NetBSD-archive/NetBSD-1.6/sou... is this error <?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?> <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Strict//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-strict.dtd"> <html> <head> <title>503 Backend unavailable, connection timeout</title> </head> <body> <h1>Error 503 Backend unavailable, connection timeout</h1> <p>Backend unavailable, connection timeout</p> <h3>Error 54113</h3> <p>Details: cache-[redacted]</p> <hr> <p>Varnish cache server</p> </body> </html> closed