7 ms·
> There's no room for arguing, and there's no in-between — any software whose license doesn't belong to the OSI's list is proprietary software. There's plenty
by kube-system 3y ago
> There's no room for arguing, and there's no in-between — any software whose license doesn't belong to the OSI's list is proprietary software.
There's plenty of room for arguing. The FSF, in fact, approves a few licenses that OSI doesn't.
- bee_rider 3y agoThere is always room for arguing. If not, we will have an argument about whether or not argument should be allowed. I think when someone says there is no room for argument, they are just signaling that they aren’t open to being convinced of anything. Which makes discussion a bit of a dead end.
- Flimm 3y agoSemantic drift is a real problem. Too much semantic drift can make it difficult to communicate, because we no longer have a common vocabulary to communicate with. I don't think semantic drift is inevitable, but it is inevitable if it isn't resisted by a large enough fraction of the community. The whole discussion here is about semantics. What does "open source" mean? I think having a clear definition of "open source" (at least when it comes to software) is a good thing for the world and for the community. It helps us communicate to have the OSD definition. If "open source" changes its definition to no longer require no restrictions on usage, we have lost a good and useful term that will make it harder for the "real" open source community to communicate. By analogy, imagine if some people started arguing that ceasar salads (with chicken) are vegetarian, because salads contain mostly vegetables. Wouldn't it be reasonable for everyone to resist that semantic drift? The term "vegetarian" would lose both its history and its usefulness. Those who state historically accepted definitions in strong terms are trying to resist semantic drift. It doesn't mean "they aren't open to being convinced of anything", that's a bit uncharitable. It means they aren't open to semantic draft regarding this term.
- dgb23 3y agoSemantic drift is of course a very natural thing that can’t be stopped. A very fun thing is to look up word origins of words and terms I care about. There’s often a revealing or thought provoking history. One of my favorites is the German word “enttäuschen” which means to disappoint but has a different original meaning. However what irks me is when interest groups try to force a semantic change in order to fullfil a typically financial or political agenda. Terms that have a positive connotation like “Open Source” need to maintain a degree of integrity in order to stay useful at all.
- kube-system 3y ago> By analogy, imagine if some people started arguing that ceasar salads (with chicken) are vegetarian, because salads contain mostly vegetables. Wouldn't it be reasonable for everyone to resist that semantic drift? The term "vegetarian" would lose both its history and its usefulness. There are some things vegetarians disagree on: eggs, dairy, gelatin, etc.
- brabel 3y ago> any software whose license doesn't belong to the OSI's list is proprietary software. This is an absurd interpretation from someone who does not understand why people actually even care about Open Source. Any license that meets the currently accepted definition of "Open Source" should be considered "Open Source" (tautological, I know). Whether it's in a list by some organization or not is mostly irrelevant. Having the OSI list is useful only because it helps people check whether a certain license adheres to the definition or not... but if the license is not in the list, you could still check yourself whether it meets the definition, and if it does, it's Open Source. Now, one could argue about who "owns" the definition of Open Source... well, then yes, I would agree that OSI's is the most widely accepted definition and everyone does well to try to follow that. That does NOT imply only OSI has the right to claim a license is open source!
- ReleaseCandidat 3y ago> the currently accepted definition of "Open Source" And that's the problem. I'd say anything between (and including) "Source is available" and "only Free Software" is sufficiently common.
- commoner 3y agoNot really. People commonly misuse "their", "there", and "they're", but doesn't change the currently accepted definitions of these words. The OSI's Open Source Definition gains credibility from its broad support from the FOSS community, and because it has been explicitly recognized by quite a few governments: https://opensource.org/authority https://opensource.org/authority
- bayindirh 3y agoWell, starting from your point, I can write my software as a complete blob and add its 10 line launcher as a small source file, license that 10 line launcher as MIT, while adding a very restrictive EULA to the blob. Then put it out as open source. Makes sense.
- commoner 3y ago