2 ms·
I'll second this. I downvoted the comment not because of a strong disagreement to its main thesis, but rather the aggressiveness and that it brings oversimplifi
by godelski 3y ago
I'll second this. I downvoted the comment not because of a strong disagreement to its main thesis, but rather the aggressiveness and that it brings oversimplification to the matter rather than incorporating more nuance in the discussion. I just detest those that lump everything together as if we can compartmentalize things into neat little boxes rather than acknowledging the messiness and complexity that is the world we live in.
I often downvote people I agree with who similarly oversimplify. Interestingly this can sometimes lead to fights as any response is often taken as opposition. But I similarly often upvote points I disagree with, when I find the arguments are good and bring up points I was missing. These actually tend to turn into the best conversations and are a main part of what keeps me coming to this website.
People vote for many different reasons. A vote is an aggregate of many different metrics. It's likely unsurprising that this leads to misinterpretation of the metric.
- ahahahahah 3y ago> that it brings oversimplification to the matter rather than incorporating more nuance in the discussion Do you then also downvote all the insipid claims of HN superiority that, at best, have similar oversimplification?
- godelski 3y agoFrequently, yes, but I'm only one man. I'm not scrolling through every comment looking for these because I'm not hyper obsessed. And I can never downvote replies to my own comments even if they are attempting to make lazy "gotchas" checking for inconsistency that are so common of humans, realistically only looking to validate their own predisposition rather than recognizing that the expectation placed on the question is exceptionally high and nearly impossible unless properly contextualized. Those aren't really adding to conversations so much as they are masturbation. Frankly, I don't enjoy when people masturbate in public. But yeah, when I see them, I do just downvote and move on. Sometimes comment. Depends on my mood ¯\_(ツ)_/¯