3 ms·
I maintain mental lists similar to this tool, and my mental "foes" list isn't people I tend to disagree with, it's people whose style of discourse is inflammato
by lolinder 3y ago
I maintain mental lists similar to this tool, and my mental "foes" list isn't people I tend to disagree with, it's people whose style of discourse is inflammatory and counterproductive. This style has tended to get more upvotes lately than it used to, and it creates whole subtrees that aren't worth reading because emotions are running hot.
Having this mental list helps me in exactly the way TFA describes: if I see one of the bad names I can immediately collapse the whole subtree and avoid the whole argument that ensues.
Edit: To be clear, I wouldn't use a tool like this, I think it's healthier for the list to remain in my head. It's less permanent that way, so if a user improves over time then their "foe" status will naturally fade. I'm just explaining how someone could use a tool like this for non-ideological reasons.
- adsharma 3y agoThen why not run the comment through a classifier and label the comment instead of the person? Like this one: https://huggingface.co/alexgshaw/hyperpartisan-classifier https://huggingface.co/alexgshaw/hyperpartisan-classifier
- godelski 3y agoI think that the mental list has an advantage in that it is highly forgetful. Someone has to make a real impression on you (or at least be quite active) for you to form an opinion about them in one way or another. Otherwise all comments return to equal footing quite quickly. I find this a feature and not a bug, in that it prevents strong bubbles (bubbles always exist). But then again, I recognize your name but I do not have strong opinions about you. Though I do lean positive.