3 ms·
> The eventual goal is to then repopulate parts of the Arctic with the new woolly mammoth and strengthen local plant life with the migration patterns and dietar
by lolinder 3y ago
> The eventual goal is to then repopulate parts of the Arctic with the new woolly mammoth and strengthen local plant life with the migration patterns and dietary habits of the beast.
This makes very little sense to me. They seem to be comparing this to the reintroduction of wolves to Yellowstone, but we did that less than a hundred years after we exterminated them, so the other species in the ecosystem were still the same ones that co-evolved with the wolves. The wooly mammoth has instead been extinct for over 4000 years—at this point won't reintroducing it be more akin to introducing a new species, with all the ecosystem risks involved in such an endeavor?
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- hackerlight 3y agoIs 4000 years long enough for that to be a concern? Humans haven't changed that much in 4000 years, probably most other species haven't either. I suppose 4000 years could be long enough, because the climate has changed and evolution can happen quickly, but we'd need to actually analyze the ecosystem to come to that determination.
- AussieWog93 3y ago4000 years should be long enough for another species to come along and occupy whatever niche the mammoths were in.
- lolinder 3y agoThe whole premise of their argument is that the ecosystem is completely different than it once was. Humans are unchanged because we've been the primary changers, but the Arctic ecosystem would be unrecognizable to a mammoth: > The loss of these large cold-tolerant Mammoths over the past 10,000 years has stripped this ecosystem of the grasslands that once efficiently absorbed carbon. Instead, there are mossy forests and wetlands, which aren’t as helpful with combating rising temperatures. [0] It seems like the most likely outcome is the mammoths don't take. If they do take, it's pretty hubristic to assume that we'll get grasslands back instead of just ruining the ecosystems that do exist there now. [0] https://colossal.com/mammoth/ https://colossal.com/mammoth/