5 ms·
This is the inevitable result of thoughtless densification. People _have_ to move into denser cities, because they are the only places with jobs. This in turn
by cyberax 3y ago
This is the inevitable result of thoughtless densification.
People _have_ to move into denser cities, because they are the only places with jobs. This in turn results in more and more jobs moving into denser cities.
And people have to live in ever-smaller apartments.
- smadge 3y agoCities are the engines of the modern economy. We can revert to an agrarian society if you please, but not without consequences.
- tomcam 3y agoI can’t see where GP said anything about reverting to an agrarian society. Was the post edited?
- cyberax 3y agoCities are the engines of the early 20-th century economy. The modern economy is much better served by people living in comfortable suburban locations. Work from home and cars enable that.
- kibwen 3y agoThe modern economy is much better served by people living in comfortable locations that are walkable rather than requiring a wasteful car to merely live. (American-style) suburbs will never be the engine of anything, they're neither agriculturally productive like rural areas nor as economically efficient as urban areas.
- midoridensha 3y agoOn top of that, the car requirement is in effect a gigantic tax: every person has to pay tens of thousands of dollars just to own a car, and many thousands to tens of thousands every year to operate and insure and maintain it. And that's a direct tax on every person. Then there's the maintenance costs for all the roadways needed to support all these cars, all the parking lots to park them in, etc. All that comes out of either direct taxes on people, or an indirect tax in the form of higher prices. Finally, this doesn't even consider the climate consequences of everyone driving around in a 6000-pound SUV; all these cars spewing emissions are turning those suburbs into very *un*comfortable locations with deadly heat waves. But good luck getting any Americans like the OP to understand any of this.
- cyberax 3y ago> On top of that, the car requirement is in effect a gigantic tax: every person has to pay tens of thousands of dollars just to own a car, and many thousands to tens of thousands every year to operate and insure and maintain it. And that's a direct tax on every person. Wait until you hear how much public transit infrastructure costs. You'll faint from shock! > Finally, this doesn't even consider the climate consequences of everyone driving around in a 6000-pound SUV What if you drive a small EV instead? And here's the CO2 footprint data for transit: https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint > But good luck getting any Americans like the OP to understand any of this. I guess you never even tried to question your assumptions.
- midoridensha 3y ago>Wait until you hear how much public transit infrastructure costs. You'll faint from shock! Considering how cheap it is for me to take the subway anywhere I want in Tokyo every day, it's not that much. Compared to roads, highways, etc. in sufficient size for every single person in the city to drive a car everywhere, public transit infrastructure costs are cheap. Strangely in America, though, drivers aren't required to pay every time they use those roads. Seems like socialism to me. >And here's the CO2 footprint data for transit: https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint Yeah, it says right in your link that transit is the greenest way to travel, other than walking or bicycling (which should be pretty obvious). >I guess you never even tried to question your assumptions. I guess you've never questioned yours, or ever been outside the US even.
- cyberax 3y ago> Considering how cheap it is for me to take the subway anywhere I want in Tokyo every day, it's not that much. Nope. You're just free-riding on taxes paid by other hard-working people, nothing is "free". > Strangely in America, though, drivers aren't required to pay every time they use those roads. Seems like socialism to me. In the state where I live, most of road maintenance is done with taxes based on road usage: https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/state/state-infrastructure-spending/ https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/state/state-infrastructur... > Yeah, it says right in your link that transit is the greenest way to travel, other than walking or bicycling (which should be pretty obvious). Reading comprehension much? Bus: 105g/km, small EV: 46 g/km, national rail: 41 g/km, London underground: 31 g/km. Basically, we just need to double the average occupancy of cars (easily doable with mild carpooling and van-type self-driving taxis), and they'll be more efficient than even subways. > I guess you've never questioned yours, or ever been outside the US even. LOL. I speak 5 languages (Russian, Ukrainian, English, German, Mandarin Chinese) and I got my first driving license at the age of 30. Before moving to the US, I lived in several European countries. I know exactly how much transit sucks compared to cars in well-designed cities.
- cyberax 3y ago> The modern economy is much better served by people living in comfortable locations that are walkable Why? Walkability ties you down to your neighborhood by rote, it limits your economic prospects, and in general makes your life more miserable (you'll _waste_ a lot more time on chores). At the same time, remote work and service-based economy allows people to avoid having to attend the office every day. > (American-style) suburbs will never be the engine of anything LOL. Sour grapes? The US suburbs are _already_ the powerhouse of the country. People living there produce something like 85% of the wealth (using individual tax returns as a proxy).
- SECProto 3y agoWhat makes you think it is "thoughtless densification"? To deliver services to a given population, it is easier, faster, & cheaper if they are in more dense metropolitan areas (up to a certain point). Same trend happens in every developed country as the proportion of the labour force required for farming/forestry decreases. Land scarcity in Japan just amplifies the density in urban areas - you cant live outside the city and drive your car in, because you'll end up spending as much on a parking spot as you would on renting a small apartment.
- cyberax 3y ago> What makes you think it is "thoughtless densification"? I'm writing a book about it :) I've argued a lot about it on the Internet, and people periodically tell: "but Tokyo!" So I studied the situation there. It's a great example of generational shittification: your grandparents live in a nice separate house, your parents live in an apartment, and you are forced to live in a "microapartment" because you can't afford anything else. > To deliver services to a given population, it is easier, faster, & cheaper if they are in more dense metropolitan areas (up to a certain point). That's incorrect. If you use the number of municipal workers per capita as a proxy, the most efficient cities are around 50-200k in population. After that, you're starting to need transit, zoning, and all other stuff. For example, NYC has around 200000 municipal employees (excluding schools) for the population of 8 million (2.5%). Boise, ID has the population of 240000 and 2100 employees (0.9%).
- SECProto 3y ago> I'm writing a book about it :) That doesn't answer the question... what makes it thoughtless? For that matter, what makes a small urban apartment worse (or better) than a home in an abandoned village? I was certainly happier and had a better time balancing my budget living in a small apartment in Japan than trying to find out how to budget to live in north america. > > (up to a certain point) > That's incorrect [...] the most efficient cities are around 50-200k in population So we agree on the fundamental, you just define the turnover point as 50-200k. I think it is inseparably tied with density - a city of 2million might be the turning point in a land constrained country like Japan, but I wouldn't be surprised in the breakeven in a suburban sprawly north american city is in the 100-200k range you mention. > If you use the number of municipal workers per capita as a proxy, This is a poor proxy. Capital budgets might be better, or ratio between median taxation and median income. > After that, you're starting to need transit, zoning, and all other stuff. Without breaking down what categories the employees work in, that's a poor comparison. Boise and NYC both have transit, zoning, etc so that alone doesn't make any difference. But for example car ownership rates are dramatically lower in NYC. If it's $2000 extra in taxes to pay for the transit drivers in NYC, but a household has an average 1 car instead of 3, then the NYC residents come out way ahead in terms of budget. Additionally, you mention zoning - most of the smallest municipalities in the US have much more restrictive zoning than cities in Japan. > For example, NYC [...] Boise [...] Can you provide some Japanese examples, since we're talking about Japan?
- shrubble 3y agoWhat is the reason that high speed Internet is not more widely available in these locations? Could people work remotely if there was good Internet?
- ekianjo 3y agoMaybe but not in Japan since Japan loves the workplace culture and the drinking addiction that goes with it
- fomine3 3y agoActually FTTH is mostly available even in rural area, except it's very rural in the mountains. Also you know now Starlink is available. Though I rarely see story anyone use Starlink in Japan rural house, but often see enthusiasts in Tokyo use instead.
- YouMeWeThem 3y agoIt's finding a domestic company that allows remote work five days a week that's the challenge.
- phendrenad2 3y agoThat's not true though, people are not living in smaller and smaller apartments, they're just building taller apartment buildings.
- midoridensha 3y agoYep, apartments in Tokyo are getting bigger. Decades ago, a tiny little apartment with no toilet or bath was not uncommon: all the residents of a building shared a couple of toilets, and had to go to a public bath down the street. These days, there's no such thing as a modern apartment without these conveniences. The one-bedrooms LDKs are available in larger sizes now, and the 3-4BR LDKs are getting quite large. Near me, they've torn down several 50-year-old 5-story apartment buildings and are replacing them with bigger 13-story buildings.
- cyberax 3y ago> Yep, apartments in Tokyo are getting bigger It's somewhat true. The average apartment in Tokyo is 66 square meters (with 40 square meters of living space). That's slightly up from 48 square meters total in 1990. However, 1.5 million homes in Tokyo have living space smaller than 20 square meters. And that number is growing, because of new "microapartments" being built all the time.