3 ms·
Not surprised. Bangladeshi politics still has the scars of their Independence War and the subsequent coups as the families leading both the Awami Party (the ru
by alephnerd 3y ago
Not surprised.
Bangladeshi politics still has the scars of their Independence War and the subsequent coups as the families leading both the Awami Party (the ruling party) and the Nationalist Party (the current opposition but formerly in power) have been in a violent struggle with each other since the 80s (eg. The current president Sheikh Hasina literally saw her father shot by the General who's wife is leading the BNP).
This rivalry has been further inflamed by the power struggle between China and India, as the BNP leans closer to China+Pakistan and the BAP leans closer to India. This has incentivized toxic political behavior - check out Nepal for another buffer zone seeing similarly dysfunctional politics.
Over the past few years, BNP multiple activists have been shot and arrested, and the party was essentially banned a couple years ago, and the US has starting placing limited sanctions against the BAP, though I doubt they would have much impact as UAE+KSA+India+Thailand+Singapore haven't enforced sanctions.
Also, from an ideology standpoint (though ideology doesn't really matter in Asian politics), BAP was traditionally center-left and Secular leaning while BNP was traditionally center-right and also Islamist leaning because the pro-Pakistan Islamist party Jamaat-e-Islami was banned in 2013 and it's activists joined the BNP.
The politics of violence was really inflamed from the early 2010s when the founders of the JeI was executed after being found guilty of murders, rapes, and torture of Bangladeshi nationalists and Hindus during the Bangladeshi War of Independence, which then hardened the ideological battle lines. This lead to massive riots in retaliation, which had a direct impact on governance in Bangladesh and even India, as the same ethnicities live across the border.
On top of that, the Rohingya refugee crisis has destabilized Eastern Bangladesh as there aren't enough jobs or ability to provide aid, causing some Rohingya to turn to the Drug Trade as Myanmar is a major Opium and Meth (ever heard of Yaba in Thailand?) manufacturing region.
- rayiner 3y agoThis analysis is accurate, but as someone whose family left the country under General Ershad, I think it misses the forest for the trees. Sheikh Hasina's government, while repressive, is also extremely popular. Her tack to neoliberalism has been enormously successful for the country, and most Bangladeshis do not want to change course. Her approval rating in multiple polls is 70-80%: https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/op-ed/322206/why-sheikh-hasina’s-approval-rating-remains-high https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/op-ed/322206/why-sheikh.... She has the popular mandate. But in a country with the kind of history Bangladesh has had, minority movements can destabilize the government and overrule the will of the majority. It's hard to have free-wheeling political discourse in a country where people don't have a long history of democracy and aren't above using bombs and assassinations in the political process. (Last time I left the country, I did so under armed guard during a hartal.) Every fledgling democracy in Asia has gone through an authoritarian stage while the country developed and solidified its institutions. Good take from Charlie Munger on this: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZT8YND31g/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZT8YND31g/. I don't think it's even limited to Asia. The U.S. Congress passed the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798. The most important thing, I think, is that America should leave Bangladesh the fuck alone, which it has not been doing: https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/08/03/washington-bangladesh-democracy-elections-hasina/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/08/03/washington-bangladesh-d.... The United States clearly has no idea how to build democracy in the developing world. I'm scared to see this article in the New York Times, and what it might mean for what the neocons have in store for the country.
- alephnerd 3y agoThanks for adding this! I didn't want to talk about Sheikh Hasina's popularity because I'm not Bangla. > I'm scared to see this article in the New York Times, and what it might mean for what the neocons have in store for the country In all honestly, they can't really do much. Bangladesh is pretty insulated because most critical services are provided by Chinese and Indian companies working closely with Bangladeshi companies. Exports aren't drastically impacted either as anything Bangladeshi could be re-exported via the UAE, Singapore, or India, should worst come to worst. And most critically, the US is a bit player in the region. They have no bases, local allies, or power projection in that region.
- selimthegrim 3y agoSee my comment about the Adani PPA downthread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37286639 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37286639
- alephnerd 3y agoYep! It's one example of multiple key projects in Bangladesh run by Indian corporations (a major reason why India supports Sheikh Hasina and the BAP), though to be fair it's not only Indian corporations. QatarGas and Gazprom are both the primary partners with PetroBangla, the Padma Bridge (one of Bangladesh's most critical logistics arteries) was constructed by Chinese companies using Chinese originated loans, and the expressway projects in Bangladesh are being built and managed by a major Thai construction company with close links to the Thai govt. To be fair, American companies don't really touched LDCs anymore - they get better RoI in investing within North America. Countries like Japan, South Korea, UAE, Qatar, KSA, Türkiye, China, India, Thailand, Malaysia, and Russia fill the financing gap in LDCs and Developing countries as they have more experience operating and executing in those kinds of environments.
- selimthegrim 3y agoThe plant is in India, BD is just buying the power at above rack rate (hence the hue and cry)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]