3 ms·
I mean I hate Chromebook, or more like any crappy Laptop Which is what 99% of Chromebooks are. But > Google imposes expiration dates, even if the hardware stil
by ksec 3y ago
I mean I hate Chromebook, or more like any crappy Laptop Which is what 99% of Chromebooks are. But
> Google imposes expiration dates, even if the hardware still works.
The article doesn't even say what does it mean by expiration. The link [1] which expiration points to talks about Auto Update Expiration.
> “I hit the update button and found out it couldn’t update,” Mr. Nielsen said.
Well yes. That is like every MacBook or Windows 8 - 10 Laptop etc. Software update isn't free. Your iPhone dont get infinite iOS update, the same with Android.
So what exactly is the expiration, which the submitted article takes about, it turns out as listed in the second article [1] it meant,
> Immediately after a Chromebook’s expiration date, you won’t experience much of a difference. In fact, you’ll likely be able to use the device normally for months. But some sites might start to act funny.
It turns out Chrome inside Chromebook don't get updated like the original browser. So Chrome ( browsers ) may get outdated. And some shitty website will act funny. How the heck is that a Chromebook expiration? You could install Firefox on your Chromebook and it would still work. Complaining about Website not working on your expired Chromebook? That is a website problem.
Again I hate Chromebooks, they are shit, just like pretty much every Google product ever existed apart from early days Gmail and Google Reader. But you know what is even worst than Google, modern mainstream media reporting.
[1] https://archive.is/RqE36 https://archive.is/RqE36
- scheeseman486 3y agoChromebooks conceptually are fine, they only need to be powerful enough to run a word processor and play youtube videos and most of them pass that bar. I don't think it's a great idea to give kids an OS and web browser that can be remotely exploited, Chrome gets patched to fix zero days as much as add new features. Firefox can work as an alternative but runs in an Android/Linux VM which impacts performance, it's a worse experience. Software updates are free for a lot of things, as much as anything can be free. Most web browsers are free, all open source software is free. The Linux kernel that Chromebooks run upon is free. You can use a decade old Windows 7 key to activate a copy of Windows 11. It's not like Google stop getting "paid", they're a software as a service company supported by advertising. Continuing to update Chromebooks would be a support burden, particularly if the hardware is reliant on proprietary driver blobs. But Google have a responsibility not to create a bunch of e-waste, so they should get their shit together and figure it out.
- WWLink 3y ago-gets on soapbox- I think giving kids locked down appliances is a terrible idea and a great way to limit the number of people who become software engineers in the future. -gets off soapbox-
- scheeseman486 3y agoIn this case they are an appliance, the hardware is owned by the school and user accounts are managed through them. Those taking an interest in coding could be given access to a Linux VM with an IDE and compiler, they don't need ring 0 access to the computer they're currently using to learn to code. Given these computers often change hands between students, it would actually be somewhat dangerous to allow one of those students to, say, install a rootkit. Once the school (or any other org) is done with them I'm all for removing all locks on the hardware so it has a fighting chance of staying out of landfill.
- leejoramo 3y agoYou are missing the point about Student Testing software/services The Student Testing can ONLY be done on systems verified to be CURRENTLY SUPPORTED and UPDATED. These tests are legally mandated. While you or I can continue to get many years out of a unsupported ChromeBook, schools loose the most critical usage immediately.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoThere’s no reason why tests administered in-person have to be on a computer anyway for the typical school situation, other than some disability accommodation circumstances which might also have other solutions. They can just be proctored the traditional way, whether they are graded by scanning machine (as can be done for multiple-choice bubble tests) or by a human. If a computer test is legally mandated with no option for the school or the district to pick a paper version, then that’s the politicians’ or administrators’ fault for forcing a wasteful budget of purchasing and replacing simple but short-lived devices (or paying more to maintain and support longer-lived devices) just for that reason.
- franga2000 3y ago> That is like every MacBook or Windows 8 - 10 Laptop etc. Software update isn't free. It's not about being free, it's about being possible. The only time I wasn't able to update a Windows laptop was when 32-bit support was dropped with Windows 11 and when the hardware was just too slow (and even then I was able to, it just sucked to use).
- gochi 3y agoWe're not talking about personally upgrading devices, these schools can easily switch to a linux distro if they want. It's about software support, so in that same sense, Microsoft wouldn't support you for updating on hardware that isn't in their support list.
- franga2000 3y agoDepends on what you mean by "support you". You can install and regularly update Windows on any device that complies with certain standards and the general minimum requirements and Microsoft will provide you the same level of support as somone buying a laptop with Windows today (which is basically none, but neither does Google). There is no "supported device list" that Windows Update checks and refuses to run if you device isn't on it. At worst it checks a few system components (like the recent TPM).
- gochi 3y agoMost companies outline what constitutes as support for organizations, especially ones like schools that have signed contracts with them for their offerings. I know that consumers don't usually care about support for windows, as they just use random advice online to fix things, but technically if you were to talk to Microsoft for help and you are out of support, they will refuse to help you. Just like if you were to try to ask Apple for support on getting iOS 16 on your iPhone 5. Unrelated, but windows update does use a supported device list, and they use it regularly for a variety of reasons one of them being to note when to release an update for users on X hardware. As they have multiple times for AMD processors. They also use it to prevent you from updating to a newer version of windows, and therefore ending your support window. Microsoft published lifecycle dates regularly so you can go check that out and see when you officially aren't supported anymore.