3 ms·
> You could use Rust, assuming it had existed back when they started it, and you would get memory safety, but also an entire kitchen sink of useless garbage (li
by jeroenhd 3y ago
> You could use Rust, assuming it had existed back when they started it, and you would get memory safety, but also an entire kitchen sink of useless garbage (like C++). Youd also have to shell out to unsafe{} in a lot of places, unless you use a crate for it, which will then do unsafe{} for you.
I'm not saying C is a wrong choice here, but this argument doesn't make much sense to me. All the other languages also come with "useless garbage" (some even with a collector for them). I don't see why you'd need that many unsafe blocks either.
I feel like Rust, as a language, is much better equipped for writing a daemon like this. I'll even go as far as to say that modern C++ (C++2x) is a better choice than C for this stuff with its superior memory and resource management tools.
Of course most of the OpenWRT development is done in C, so doing it in another language requires a very good reason. I wouldn't look at the concept of "a networked daemon exchanging messages between arbitrary services" and think C of all languages is a good fit unless every other developer on the team can only write C.
Zig would've been a nice way to meet halfway, but the language isn't finished yet.
Of course the point is moot because this particular project existed years before any of the modern alternatives or many of the C++ improvements were even available. Still, if they'd start a project like this again, I'd hope they'd pick a better language for it.