I can't disagree with almost anything you said except maybe one thing: in the physical nature there are objective and physical criteria about whether a certain

I can't disagree with almost anything you said except maybe one thing: in the physical nature there are objective and physical criteria about whether a certain organism will procreate and thus propagate its (presumably) successful genes. Not sure if the AI area, represented by human supervisors, does so in such an objective and ruthless manner as nature does. If there's no fitness function and natural selection then the AI area might be doomed to meander and go in circles for centuries.