7 ms·
A better question that I always ask, before any other questions in the interview: "Why do you want to work here?" Then I reject any answer that's not somewhat u
by msg 15y ago
A better question that I always ask, before any other questions in the interview: "Why do you want to work here?" Then I reject any answer that's not somewhat unique to our business. "You could do that anywhere, is there anything specific to this place?" Then I probe the final answer to make sure it's not BS.
Bad answers: I've heard you make a lot of money here, I want to work on software development, I like Java. Better: I have friends who've told me about it and it sounds like the kind of place I want to work. The best answer: I understand a lot about how your business works and it is a win-win for me to be here for the following reasons... despite the following minuses...
I was playing Resistance this weekend for the first time. Essentially Resistance is Mafia with rules, blue vs. red. One of the first things I did was ask people, "are you a spy?" Like a melodramatic detective. I think there is an instinct to try this first, and win the game on the basis of a twitching lip or "say no, nod yes" sort of reaction.
This may work on easily startled people. Same with slamming your hand on the table in a security clearance interview.
A smarter candidate will figure out you're playing games, which defeats the purpose. I think you also want to consider the reaction of the candidate after the interview. Suppose they answer honestly, then figure out what you did to them.
There's a big difference between trying to learn a prospective employee's motivations the old fashioned way and trying to trick it out of them. Especially when a highly motivated employee can be lowballed in a salary negotiation.
- drostie 15y agoThat's an even stranger question, given how little I know about a given business before I have worked there. I can't help but think my answer would be, "I don't know, I've only seen you guys in person for about five minutes. Why do you want to work here? What about this place makes you smile every day?"
- lhnz 15y ago> A smarter candidate will figure out you're playing games, which defeats the purpose. I think you also want to consider the reaction of the candidate after the interview. Suppose they answer honestly, then figure out what you did to them. It won't make any difference. A smarter candidate would know you're playing a game but not care. They would give you their honest answer because if you were not interested you wouldn't hire them and they would not care because of the manipulation, and if you were interested in hiring them they would not be as interested because of the manipulation but would understand that despite their honest answer on a personal question you were impressed by them -- this would help even things out. It's win/win.