4 ms·
In our modern society, everyone is a victim and it's always someone else's fault. My opinion that people in America do have choices and their lives are the sum
by WalterBright 3y ago
In our modern society, everyone is a victim and it's always someone else's fault. My opinion that people in America do have choices and their lives are the sum of those choices inevitably elicits a lot of rather angry responses.
All the people I've gotten to know over the years are all where they are as a result of their choices.
The interesting thing about deciding to own your choices is it's empowering - you can choose to change your life. The victims, however, have unpowered themselves, and thus remain forever hapless victims.
For example:
1. Live in a bad location? Move
2. Uneducated? Education is free over the internet
3. Weak? Exercise
4. Overweight? Eat less
5. Drug addicted? Treatment is available
6. Criminal record? Start your own business
7. Unhappy with your finances? Learn how to invest
8. Your friends drag you down? Discard them
9. Hate your boss? Quit and get another job
And so on. None of this is easy. It will take effort. It's up to you.
- FranzFerdiNaN 3y agoAh yes, people just stopped taking personal responsibility these last forty years, resulting in an obesity epidemic and mass addiction to phones and social media. Makes total sense. Just have some more willpower!
- ajb 3y agoResponsibility does not mutually exclude. I'm a bit disappointed in a compiler engineer not being alive to the logic of that. So many political arguments (in both directions) based on this bogus reasoning, that A can affect an outcome, so therefore B who exerts influence on it has no responsibility. Doesn't work that way.
- WalterBright 3y agoSince you brought up compiler engineer :-), I'll share that at the outset 100% of my colleagues and friends all said I had zero chance of succeeding writing compilers. They literally laughed, and it was a running joke among among them. The only person who believed in me was my dad, and he had no idea what I was trying to do. I chose the path. Everyone tried to kick me off that path. I could have easily stayed with my nice, safe, corporate job at Boeing. Lots and lots of people do. Influence should not be conflated with force. If someone put a gun to my head, I'd probably do whatever they ask. In fact, I have. Twice. That's force. It's a heluva lot different from mere influence.
- sph 3y agoEverything is easy if you trivialise it enough. This is why self-help books are America's #1 genre and literary export. Real life, on the other hand, is a tad more complicated. The rule of thumb is don't waste time with people that think they have all the answers. Either they're lying to you, hopelessly naive, or have no real life experience. > Drug addicted? Treatment is available > Criminal record? Start your own business > Unhappy with your finances? Learn how to invest I mean, seriously? You forgot "poor? Become rich."
- WalterBright 3y agoI specifically wrote it wasn't easy.
- sph 3y agoThe "it isn't easy" is the bloody important part that none of your slogans touch upon, so they're not even worth the memory they're stored in. There is no insight to be gained from any of them. Or do you truly believe that people with hardship in their lives are so hopelessly stupid that they don't know they will have to put some effort, instead of sitting around crying over themselves? Come on now.
- WalterBright 3y ago> that they don't know they will have to put some effort I wrote that because the usual responses I get are that it isn't easy. Thought I'd deal with that up front. My dad used to tell me I wasn't afraid of hard work. I could lie down right next to it and go to sleep.
- latency-guy2 3y ago> Or do you truly believe that people with hardship in their lives are so hopelessly stupid that they don't know they will have to put some effort, instead of sitting around crying over themselves? Come on now. I don't think that's what Bright said. Unless you're the type of person to say never take risks, because chances are you'll fail. If the world was filled to the brim with that type, then what's the point in living? Don't tell me you actually believe in that.
- jasona99 3y agoI agree to some extent that people can control their situation with choices, but I would like to push back on a few of those examples as I think it's a little disingenuous to say everyone can simply make choices in our society and do better. For example, living in a bad location also often means one would have limited options for work, which limits their income and prevents them from being able to just move out of that situation. Limited free time from working multiple low-paying part- or even full-time jobs to support oneself or others can make paths to gaining more education, whether free or not, just not feasible. Good luck getting a somewhat reasonable SBA loan with a criminal record! I know you are giving very simple examples, but many of them fail to account for the situation one would be in to require improving the situation. In theory, yes, I agree, there are ways out of bad situations simply by taking the correct steps, but those paths out may just not be open for people in the very situations where they might most benefit. I've seen many truly impoverished areas of the United States (large swathes of West Virginia primarily come to mind, no offense to the West Virginians on here) where these paths are not tenable. Many of these areas straight up don't have regular internet access. These whole regions are lacking in education and options for mobility are severely restricted. I simply do not believe it is because everyone in that area has decided they just don't want to do better for themselves, but that there are systemic problems preventing these people from being able to take these steps.
- WalterBright 3y ago> move Allow me to point out the millions of immigrants that walk across a continent to try and slip over the border into America. The ones that make it rarely have more than the clothes on their back. Yet they moved away from a bad situation to a better one, and have made it to every corner of the country. > but that there are systemic problems preventing these people from being able to take these steps. Nobody there has their feet nailed to the ground.
- jasona99 3y ago> Allow me to point out the millions of immigrants that walk across a continent to try and slip over the border into America. Sure, but even when they get to America, unless they already have some degree of monetary means, a large portion of those immigrants will end up stuck in low-paying, high-labor jobs, often in agriculture and heavy industry, without savings or means to move elsewhere for years. Those paths to better work, education, or location once in America are not going to be open to them as they will have no resources to draw upon. Not being a citizen also can be severely restricting. Most mobility is not seen for one or more generations and many immigrants simply remain in deep poverty indefinitely. Immigration is not a silver bullet to a great life, even if an immigrant does everything correctly. Would you say they get stuck here of their own volition after risking their lives and the lives of their families to get to America, or that it is systemically hard for an immigrant to rise out of poverty in America? > Nobody there has their feet nailed to the ground. I am trying to highlight that moving, especially to a higher cost of living area, is expensive and people risk being homeless for a non-trivial amount of time at an often slim chance of doing better. That can be very dangerous for a myriad of reasons and I imagine a risk that is simply too great for most, even if they are willing to do difficult things to do better. I would argue that this is not their fault for simply being born in an area with poor wages, education, and support systems, but that the area they originally lived in has a more systemic issue preventing mobility.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoHumans have a limited amount of willpower. The average person can handle addressing a couple of these issues, but some people (especially the poor and the ill) have so many simultaneous issues that their willpower is too divided for them to make meaningful headway.
- WalterBright 3y ago> ill I usually preface my comments on this topic with legal adults of sound mind and body. > poor The millions walking over the border have nothing, but they see opportunity in the US.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI think you have a quite limited understanding of the funds and planning that go into crossing the border, and also how effectively people who make that crossing solve other issues in their lives. My brother-in-law's family crossed the border illegally out of dire necessity. However, they still have many others issues (managing money, working for awful bosses, living in crappy housing, family in-fighting, unhappy marriage, etc.) that they have struggled to fix. Some of these issues are so bad that it has led my brother-in-law to distance himself from some of them. So yes, they did a really hard thing to solve an extremely pressing problem, but it does not mean they have solved all of their problems. There is only so much one person can do to fix their life when there are many things wrong with it. They can usually only prioritize a couple of things.
- WalterBright 3y ago> I think you have a quite limited understanding of the funds and planning that go into crossing the border, and also how effectively people who make that crossing solve other issues in their lives. And yet they managed to do it. They could and did move to where there's more opportunity. > but it does not mean they have solved all of their problems Nobody solves all their problems. But they can prioritize, make a plan, and knock them down one at a time. Success isn't instant, either. Or do nothing and remain a victim. America was populated by Europeans arriving here with nothing. They worked their way into the middle class and the rich. The American West was populated by people walking across the continent. It's still happening today. People have choices.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]