4 ms·
i think the bigger issue is probably that the paper straws are about an order of magnitude higher in mass, virtually 100% organic chemicals, and so represent ab
by kragen 3y ago
i think the bigger issue is probably that the paper straws are about an order of magnitude higher in mass, virtually 100% organic chemicals, and so represent about an order of magnitude higher resource consumption
the bigger issue than that is that disposable straws, even after that order-of-magnitude increase in impact, are an absolutely insignificant issue in ecological terms and yet have somehow become a political issue and spawned new laws and ridiculous greenwashing marketing
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- audunw 3y agoTo me it doesn’t seem that paper straws is about the resource consumption or oil used or anything like that. I think you have completely misunderstood the purpose. Even with the order of magnitude increase in resources used it’s still insignificant, as you touch on. What’s not insignificant is that in the contexts where straws are used.. fast food and coffee shops and such, they’re all too likely to be just thrown out into nature rather than being properly disposed of. Any material in that category needs to be biodegradable. That’s just a hard requirement in my opinion. So plastics is just not a suitable material. Yes, there are other sources of plastic pollution that are much worse in volume. Though they tend to end up in other places. We need to work on all the sources of plastic pollution in parallel. (Unless we go the other route and do massive bioengineering of microorganisms to let them break down plastics)
- kragen 3y agofrom my point of view, it depends on how much of it there is and what effect it has on the environment sand, glass, metal, and rust aren't biodegradable either, but i don't think we should ban mountains because they throw sand out into nature when they erode plastic straws are generally polypropylene, which is photodegradable to relatively nontoxic materials
- dddssddd 3y agoDidn't realize Mountains were pollution until you pointed it out. Thanks for your meaningful and on discussion contribution!
- kragen 3y agoyou seem to have interpreted my comment as saying the opposite of what it did in fact say, presumably for humorous effect
- marcus0x62 3y agoDude drank through too many PFAS-enhanced paper straws and now has reading comprehension problems :(
- chmod600 3y agoPlastic straws strewn in a natural setting feels a lot worse than sand. I can't tell you exactly why, but I still think that "don't throw plastic around" is a good starting place for a discussion and I don't think it's productive to argue that point.
- kragen 3y agomaybe what feels good or bad to people in a natural setting is not actually a useful measurement of what affects the well-being of nature maybe the actual health of the motherfucking ecosystem matters more than what looks nice on a postcard common sense is what tells you the world is flat, chemotherapy is bad for you, and lead paint and sassafras are good to eat
- yyyk 3y agoGlass is biodegradable. Metal is so easily recycled. I'll note though that biodegradability is not the only consideration, and there are other important advantages to plastic straws.
- 3y ago
- ricardobeat 3y agoSources needed. This study says paper straws uses slightly less energy and emits about the same CO2 as a plastic one: https://www.appropedia.org/HSU_straw_analysis#:~:text=A%20single%20paper%20straw%20is,dioxide%20emissions%2C%20and%20costs%20%241.29 https://www.appropedia.org/HSU_straw_analysis#:~:text=A%20si.... Even if that’s not the case, “resource usage” is not the right metric to optimize for, this cost-focused mentality is exactly how we ended up with plastic [literally] everywhere. Hundreds of billions of plastic straws are thrown away every year, this is a massive problem even if its only a few % of the total.
- kragen 3y agoprobably it's good to have plastic everywhere if it decreases environmental damage the hsu analysis is wrong because it's omitting the energy consumed by growing the trees; it rates "craft paper" as 12.6 kJ/g, but according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_chemical_reactions_(oxidation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_chemical_rea... burning wood produces 18 MJ/kg = 18 kJ/g, which is to say, more energy than that is still available in the end product, without even taking into account the "embodied" energy dissipated in processing the energy consumed by the tree in growing is about 20× larger than this, 300–400 kJ per gram of wood, which is close to 700 kJ per gram of paper, because about half the tree is lignin, which is digested in the papermaking process and then discharged into waterways it does give a reasonably plausible (if misleadingly precise) figure of 95.4 kJ/g for the polypropylene straws also, it incorrectly compares 200-mg polypropylene straws against 200-mg paper straws. but paper straws are, as everyone knows, enormously thicker than polypropylene straws of the same level of durability; even with the accounting error of omitting the embodied energy of the paper, its conclusion presupposes the opposite of my premise above, which you should have mentioned in your comment (but presumably could not because you had not actually read the study you were citing) in fact, a typical 6-mm-diameter paper straw made from 330 gsm paper at a length of 200 mm weighs some 1250 mg, roughly 6× as much as the hsu study's 200-mg estimate. a 200-mg paper straw would be 53 gsm; that's like tracing paper. it would collapse immediately if you tried to suck on it finally, it is not correct that hundreds of billions of plastic straws are thrown away per year, and those that end up in landfills (which is the vast majority) are not a problem at all. nor are they a few % of the total, as you say, but 100× less than that; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_straw#Environmental_impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_straw#Environmental_i... says, 'In total, they are less than 0.022% of plastic waste emitted to oceans.'