3 ms·
To add a bit of context for those not too well versed in Eastern European history (from someone with a Croatian background): Back in the real-sozialist/communis
by mschuster91 3y ago
To add a bit of context for those not too well versed in Eastern European history (from someone with a Croatian background): Back in the real-sozialist/communist era, the people didn't have much rights (especially not those that were against the dictators), but in exchange at least the government took somewhat of a care of providing everyone with a life worth living (notable exception: the remote areas of Russia that have historically served only as a supply for young men to grind in Russian wars) - it's not unlike the societal reality currently in China. The nation blocks, either the Soviet Union or the "non aligned movement", supported each other and distributed workload to make sure everyone (both in terms of nations as well as people) could make a living - even if that was often far less efficient than Western countries, because the Communist nations prioritized jobs for their people over having machines do these jobs.
Then, Communism fell... corrupt entities took over many of the countries, only looking to enrich themselves, and as the international solidarity system failed against "cheaper" products there was no hope to keep the often horribly outdated factories alive, and at the same time Western societies hungry for more labor force (and way more attractive currencies) began to "brain drain" the former Communist countries.
Today, the people may have rights on paper, but in practice they're worthless (either due to corruption or because the state is too poor), and society is crumbling apart from decades of looting and corrupt elites on one side and young generations moving abroad because they can't see any way that their country escapes the death spiral. Many people struggle with survival every day. So yes, in conclusion it's warranted to say that the fall of Communism led to a massive drop in quality of life.
TikTok and the "gangsta" life style are just the cherries on the cake.
- supazek 3y agoYou really skipped over that “didn’t have rights” part. How many people were in Gulag? And you think there was no corruption in the ruling communist class? Corruption is a feature of any political organization and should be stopped, but money was just as much a motivator for the communists as it is for the capitalists. The only difference is that it wasn’t available to the working class so they weren’t incentivized to produce or invent.
- wddkcs 3y agoPeople love to pretend that it wasn't the Soviets themselves that ended the USSR.
- mschuster91 3y ago> And you think there was no corruption in the ruling communist class? Real-socialism/communism failed for good reasons and deservedly. I shed no tears for that period. My point is that what came after tended to be even worse - the post-downfall period, the breakdown of intra- and inter-block trade, the looting by criminals and corrupt (former) elites and other destruction and the resulting brain drain had consequences that have held or taken the affected countries back in development for decades. Of course the elites were corrupt. But there was a marked difference in corruption when there still was some sort of government that held them a bit accountable, or when the government essentially vanished and the criminals became the government. Russia is the easiest example (because it's best documented, information on the Balkans is pretty scarce): Your average Russian "elite" back in the USSR era, he maybe had a couple villas and Western cars, that's it. Your average Russian "oligarch" (or to put it better, kleptocrat) today? Buys a soccer club for billions of euros, has multiple luxury yachts and stashed away many billions of dollars more. Hell, the billionaire Russian oligarchs alone have a net worth of over 500 billion dollars [1] despite the war, and that doesn't include the millionaire mini-oligarchs. Imagine where Russia would be, had that wealth remained in the hands of the nation, and its leaders invested it into education, social cohesion and modern industry?! [1] https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/russian-billionaires-see-wealth-rise-over-half-trillion-dollars-forbes-2023-04-22/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/russian-billionaires-...
- soared 3y ago> society is crumbling … many people struggle with survival every day What locations are you talking about? Even from the article above in a remote poor town in Albania that sounds pretty bad, their society is definitely not crumbling and while poor, not struggling to survive every day.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Even from the article above in a remote poor town in Albania that sounds pretty bad, their society is definitely not crumbling and while poor, not struggling to survive every day. Albania's average wage is about 600-700 USD per month depending on whom you ask. Croatia's is a bit higher, around 1100... but the prices even for everyday staple foods are higher than in Germany. It's all shiny and nice in the tourism areas, but outside of them life can suck pretty hard.