9 ms·
A venture-backed startup has quietly bought more than 80 mom-and-pop shops
- Dalewyn 3y agohttps://archive.is/P1cUy https://archive.is/P1cUy Archive link because clickbait can die in a fire.
- kdamica 3y agoOpenStore is doing something similar for small e-commerce businesses: https://open.store/ https://open.store/
- mariodiana 3y agoIt's difficult to develop products without understanding customer needs, and it's difficult to understand customer needs without a variety of customers. That's the problem their business model is it solving.
- zdw 3y agoThis sounds like they're going to be collecting a large amount of data from a huge variety of small businesses that all operate in different ways and have very different clientele. I wonder how practically useful all of this data collection is going to be, and whether doing it will be accurate and result in insight. Learning about small niches where modest profit can be made (which is where many small businesses tend to fit, IMO) is not the typical/theoretical "scale to the heavens" startup plan, but if just getting ideas is the goal... good luck?
- birdyrooster 3y agoIt's a boondoggle.
- gopher_space 3y agoThe people doing real estate forecasts want actual numbers to crunch and would enumerate the fleas on your dog and rank sort its name on the date of sale if you let them. They think confounding variables are for quitters.
- tempusalaria 3y agoSounds like an easy and cheap way to bump up revenue and metrics for next raise. Prob buying at 1x revenue and selling stock to investors at 100x revenue
- ochoseis 3y agoThere’s a whole world of folks who do this, with acquisitions and sophistication ranging from really small businesses[0] to ones in the range the article discusses[1]. It does seem like a numbers game where it makes sense to pool the risk. [0]: https://www.amazon.com/Buy-Then-Build-Acquisition-Entrepreneurs-ebook/dp/B07JKM2F5Q https://www.amazon.com/Buy-Then-Build-Acquisition-Entreprene... [0]: https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01KP33K4Y https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01KP33K4Y
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jeremyjh 3y agoThey aren't buying them for the business upside, but to force the business to buy its own ecosystem of Fintech products.
- notahacker 3y agoDoesn't make any sense to do that without a financial upside as well, as the businesses are unlikely to spend more their entire valuation on fintech products (and 84 mom and pop shops owned by the VC signing up isn't much of an illusion of growth to boost the fintech companies' valuation either)
- ralferoo 3y agoThe financial upside is that they also own 85% of the company shares, so get 85% of the profits, reducing to 20% over 20 years by selling shares back to the employees. Selling here implies they'll also make profit from that too.
- sangnoir 3y agoEmployees who'll likely withstand lower than market rate wages and/or poor conditions because of sunk-cost fallacy. Sucking up profits from both the captive businesses using software licensing, revenue, and employees (as they buy shares from the startup) is well-thought-out evil genius, OR a path towards fully automated luxury worker-led communism, but I'm guessing it's the former in the guise of the latter.
- 52-6F-62 3y agoWhy do they call this fintech? Isn’t this essentially a reworked trust?
- Kiro 3y agoThe irony that "reworked trust" is even more of a nonsense word.
- 52-6F-62 3y agoIndeed…
- op00to 3y agoBecause the idea is to sell fintech products to the acquired businesses.
- bornfreddy 3y agoThat sounds like a cherry on top to me. I mean, considering the cost of the business that they paid for, fintech expenses shiuld be negligible. Otherwise it sounds like a great business - buy successful businesses without successors, shape them up, motivate employees and reap the benefits, long term. Win-win-win for everyone involved and society too.
- foobarian 3y agoIt's like any acquisition, you don't let the acquired shop keep running workday if the main company is running base camp. It makes sense to consolidate.
- asu_thomas 3y agoOnce they lose control by selling 80% to the employees, they no longer have that power though, right?
- sangnoir 3y ago
- maxerickson 3y agoSo is their plan that the businesses will be employee owned but not employee controlled, thus locking nice rates for their services?
- jancsika 3y agoThis is brilliant. Instead of saving on labor costs by pretending your employees are contractors like Uber and friends, they go in the opposite direction. You're not a contractor, or even an employee, but an owner. Just imagine how big your milkshake will be once you all own 80% of the business! Admittedly, a business where this company has slurped out most of the value and saddled you with various software license fees or whatever in perpetuity. But a business nonetheless. And now when the business goes belly up and these owners are destitute, the HN logic applies-- hey man, most businesses fail. So why not just learn some python and code up some nice fintech that extracts value from other rubes?
- robertlagrant 3y ago> the HN logic applies-- hey man, most businesses fail. So why not just learn some python and code up some nice fintech that extracts value from other rubes? I haven't really seen this here. Is there any need to perpetuate such silly stereotypes?
- googlryas 3y agoRight, I would more ascribe that viewpoint to some journos on Twitter. I think if that viewpoint is referenced on HN, it is done so derisively.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt was a big thing ten years ago - why not learn to code if your job has gone overseas? At the point Mayor Bloomberg tweeted something about learning to code, it seems Jeff Atwood felt it was time to weigh in[0]. [0] https://blog.codinghorror.com/please-dont-learn-to-code https://blog.codinghorror.com/please-dont-learn-to-code
- borski 3y agoI think the point is that it wasn’t big on HN.
- kristopolous 3y agoSocialists like Richard Wolff have been advocating for a similar thing for a while ... Some kind of ESOP continuity plan. Is that a business strategy now? Take some socialist idea and repackage it as a for profit one? It's probably been a business play for a long time and I just never realized it
- brnaftr361 3y agoI think with proper terms this would be a good launchpad for tested and tried businesses to transition into worker owned cooperatives, which I think would be a noble endeavor. As it's set up currently it reads more or less like a tribute system, which is pretty trashy - it draws a line in the sand where they're effectively minimizing risk to themselves and slowly foisting responsibility onto others in exchange for a quasipermanent deal. I'm curious as to how the "ownership" works, as well, I'm sure there are caveats written in that secure the stake of Teamshares.
- monero-xmr 3y agoPrivate equity rolling up small businesses is extremely common for decades. There is even a major plot in the 2000s HBO show “Six Feet Under” of the evil PE guys buying up all the mom and pop funeral homes to corporatize it. Nothing new or innovative about this.
- smcameron 3y agoService Corporation International. I used to know a guy that worked for them back in the early '90s doing AS/400 stuff, I think.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- soared 3y agoThis is not a fintech company, it’s a holding company. Selling their financial products they said is a secondary new revenue stream - their primary revenue stream is from the companies they acquire, which for some reason decreases over time as they sell back stock to employees. Maybe they’ve identified that employees in small business will overpay for stock in the company they work at. Then this is just a financial move to own that stock and sell it overvalued to employees?
- wombat-man 3y agoWell, it sounds like the long term strategy is to develop business software solutions that work perfectly for their various arms, that they can then take external and pitch to other small businesses.
- esjeon 3y agoIt's like real estate development. You buy a land, develop it, and sell it at a higher price. Same here. You buy a small business, improve it by adapting your solution, and sell it back at higher price. Of course, the "improve"-ment part better be real, but it sounds like a win-win business model if properly conducted.
- gremlinsinc 3y agoit sounds like it square bought food truck businesses that weren't using square pos and basically installed square pos and resold the business with contract stating they couldn't switch pos providers....I mean it's a way to guarantee vendor lockin but it's also risky. I do hope they follow through with the 80 percent ESO plan later on, as I'd love to see that the norm not the exception in the next generation.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIt’s generally a bad idea to buy stock in the business where where you work. It’s the opposite of diversification. If it’s equity compensation OK, but you should diversify that into other investments as soon as you can.
- brookst 3y agoAny headline that uses “quietly”, “finally”, or “openly” is a signal of a bad faith article. And headlines using “This company” rather than naming the company are clickbait. Funny that TechCrunch wants to cast aspersions using cheap devices like that.
- tgv 3y agoYou need a bit more substance than association by guilt (and not even a strong association) to criticize an article or a headline. My reading of e.g. "quietly" is that either they're claiming a scoop, or they're critical of the acquisition, not of bad faith.
- robertlagrant 3y agoWhat is "association by guilt"?
- _0ffh 3y agoMaybe they mixed up "guilt by association".
- robertlagrant 3y agoPossibly, but then I would ask how that's relevant as well!
- tgv 3y agoI did mean guilt by association. The comment's author assumes the articles uses cheap devices based on an association the word "quietly" with bad faith arguments.
- robertlagrant 3y agoHow's that guilt by association?
- TimPC 3y agoSo is the idea that they acquire the company for debt they place in the company and then they offer a complete suite of fintech products (including servicing that debt) to each of the companies they acquire? They aren’t too worried about giving away much of the company because with the debt inside the company the valuation is near zero? But if the employees can successfully grow the company it represents a decent return since they’ll be able to share 80% equity.
- numair 3y agoProtip: If someone says they are trying to be like Berkshire Hathaway, and their business plan doesn’t include a strategy for cornering some segment of the insurance market, they do not understand and will not become like Berkshire Hathaway.
- jononomo 3y agoI would even go so far as to say that if someone says they are trying to be like Boeing, but their business does not involve manufacturing jumbo jets, they do not understand and will not become like Boeing.
- siliconc0w 3y agoSeems like sorta a middle ground between a bs PE buyout, a roll-up, and a holding company. I think they're hoping the fintech fairy dust is going to give them tech multiples.
- 55555 3y agoThis is pretty strange. The real business model could probably be described in just a few blunt sentences, but without that happening we're left to speculate.
- htrp 3y ago> Certainly, it’s among the more unique fintech models this reporter can recall. Its not a fintech business model. This is more like a McDonalds franchise model where they are extracting value by forcing stores to buy amounts all mannner of services from Food to Ordering Automation along with paying a percentage of gross sales back to Corporate. Except in this case TeamShares won't even provide for good marketing support or branding to drive traffic.
- skeeter2020 3y agoMcDonalds always had the implicit promise that you'll work hard, make us very rich but you'll also be "small town rich" too. TeamShares doesn't even pretend to deliver on the last part.
- birdyrooster 3y agoThis idea is potentially so terrible I almost feel bad for the founders -- if it also wasn't scummy. The crux of their problem is that these businesses have a very finite lifetime regardless of the succession plan. The succession plan is completely secondary, the bigger question is the viability of the business plan, which for many small businesses, is not robust. TeamShares is merely acquiring customers until they abandon after the business plan is replaced and changes the quality or price of service. Of course business owners who are selling to them are happy because they can buy their business back for less when TeamShares goes tits up. TeamShares is probably going to find this scheme will only work if the businesses being acquired are very homogeneous. Trying to scale something which inherently cannot or should not scale is kinda silly.
- wand3r 3y agoThis sounds a lot like the Search Fund model except at scale. Typically in a search fund an entrepreneur raises a small pool of capital for operations and search for a traditional low tech company to acquire where they can optimize operations typically leaning on their MBA education. When a target is found, they make a capital call to the investors and buy out the company. This basically seems like a search fund run at scale. Its actually a cool concept that I suspect is quite profitable. From the article though I don't really know if there is a tech component. It's more like a pure-play private equity company, e.g. finance. That said, there are a lot of interesting opportunities here and probably limited competition.
- billjings 3y agoWow: > The plan instead is to generate revenue from a growing array of fintech products that it sells to the businesses it buys. If these products were any good, couldn't they make money with them on the open market? The only thing that owning gives you is the ability to force them to buy from the company store, so to speak. This isn't tech. This is pure capitalist financial engineering: extracting money from people who actually do real work for real paying customers.
- dsr_ 3y agoThe one really negative bit: "And so we recruit people from some really great companies — McKinsey, USAA, Tesla and Amazon — and train them to run these small businesses."
- gunapologist99 3y agoThat might not be a bad thing.. but it could be.
- screwturner68 3y agoIt just assumes that only people that work for companies like Amazon and Tesla have the pedigree to manage a company. I look at it like how every politician either elected or appointed seems to have gone to one of 10 well known universities -you know Harvard, Yale, Stanford..etc. It's not about what they know or what they want to do as much as the fact that they are all in the same club. I've always said that being a CEO is just a game of playing follow the leader -one CEO cuts their 401K, they all cut their 401K, one CEO switches to "unlimited vacation" they all switch to "unlimited vacation". It's not a surprise that these companies all act the same, all the leaders all went to the same schools with professions that went to the same schools. They've all bee taught to think alike, they aren't disruptive-it's just group think. When was the last time you heard of a CEO that went to community college and some shitty state school -even if they founded the company they are quickly replaced by a person more suited to be the CEO- someone for a Ivy school/FAANG once they IPO.
- sangnoir 3y ago> The one really negative bit It being a negative depends on which end of the table you sit. I agree it's telling on the kind of leadership they expect, given the reputation of the environments and people who work at those organizations.
- _spduchamp 3y agoAging business owners should look at Employee Owned Trusts. They exist in the US and UK with slightly different structures. Canada will have some legislation around EOTs sometime soon.
- theunixbeard 3y agoLooks like PE and venture-backed tech have a bad rep these days given how cynical the comment section is... It seems the core problem at hand attempting to be solved is baby boomer small business owners retiring and having no one to buy their business (or pass down to who actually wants to run it)... That seems like a worthy problem to tackle. Definitely will keep an eye on this company over the years to see if the model pans out or not.
- hiatus 3y agoThis reads very much like a franchising arrangement, except instead of goods you pay for back office services. Even if the acquirer's products would succeed on the open market, a captive audience of guaranteed business seems like it might align the incentives of the parent company to _not_ bleed their acquisition dry.
- rmoriz 3y agoSomehow reminds me of Constellation Software.
- iancmceachern 3y agoIt's like amway or other MLMs but instead of locking them in with proprietary products to sell, they're locked into proprietary ways of doing business. In a way, it's a lot like a franchise model.
- ajkjk 3y agoOne thing's for sure: there's no possible way this makes the world a better place to live in.
- burcs 3y agoWhy would you think that? There was no succession plan for these businesses, there was a high potential for them to shutter and the jobs would dry up with them. Honestly, this feels like one of the better/more practical uses of venture capital that I've seen in a while.
- ajkjk 3y agoBecause the businesses are now owned by a profit-maximizing anonymous fintech company. If you can't imagine any of the thousand ways that ends up sucking for everybody and draining life out of the world it's not likely that anything I say could convince you.
- smeej 3y ago85% owned out of the gate, decreasing to 20% over 20 years. Just because you can't imagine a way it could be good doesn't mean they're evil.
- screwturner68 3y agoShow me a merger that has been good for the customer and good for the employee. I'll wait.
- sema4hacker 3y agoFinding mom+pop businesses with growth potential can be difficult. If there is no growth you might not be able to squeeze any money out of the business at all. I recently did due diligence on the highest rated bakery in our area owned by a couple that did just about all the work but wanted to retire. Unfortunately all the profits became their salary. Replacing them meant their replacements' salaries would eat all the profits too. Their weekly sales were the same regardless of how many days they were open because new customers were rare and existing customers either squeezed into or spread out to whatever hours they were open. 40 other local bakeries meant competition was stiff. Everything was cash so an accurate audit was essentially impossible. Perhaps Teamshares is good at identifying acquisitions with sufficient margins to permanently afford Teamshares services, but if I was an employee at a company being bought I'd be concerned that after the owners retired with their cut and after Teamshares kept extracting their fees, I'd be left holding the bag, ie, a non-growing company slowly dying.
- adrianmonk 3y agoMakes sense. At https://www.teamshares.com/brokers https://www.teamshares.com/brokers , if you click on "Download buyer's profile", it says a few things that suggest they've taken that into account: > Due to our specific needs, we are often forced to pass on good businesses. And they want companies with: > at least two managers or supervisors supporting the owner in bookkeeping, dispatch, sales, or project management And: > Our structure requires the inclusion of certain expense items (like presidents, finance leads, and/or general managers) that other buyers may not have to factor in. This means sometimes our price comes in lower than an individual buyer who benefits from that salary.
- SoftTalker 3y ago> And they want companies with: >> at least two managers or supervisors supporting the owner in bookkeeping, dispatch, sales, or project management That sounds like a bigger business than “mom and pop” to be honest.
- JKCalhoun 3y ago
- yieldcrv 3y ago> just 15% or so of small business owners pass along their company to a family member, with many others simply closing up shop at some point. Businesses shouldn’t be immortal so it’s fine. People should celebrate closing as most owners are indifferent.
- dbingham 3y agoI understand the cynical takes and it's totally fair to be wary. We're all used to seeing startups where the only goal is to make money, and when they're venture backed, the goal is to make a _ton_ of money - externalities be damned. If that's the case here, then the cynical takes are logical. But it is possible (just possible) that there's something else going on here. It's possible that the founders genuinely are dedicated to increasing the prevalence of employee owned and governed businesses. And that they've found social impact investors aligned with that mission. In that world, they aren't looking for astronomical returns, just modest returns and enough revenue to keep going. If you assume that's what is happening here then a lot of these decisions make sense and don't look so ominous. Employee owned businesses often struggle to get financing and insurance from traditional banks and insurers. Because those companies don't know what to make of them. So creating financing and insurance products allows Teamshares to provide those services to businesses that would otherwise struggle to get them. (And if they're doing that - why not offer them to others as well?) The gradual increase in ownership is how employee buyouts often go. And retaining the 20% ownership stake also makes sense - it's a pay it forward thing, allowing Teamshares to continue to help businesses make the transition to employee owned. If you assume it's on the level - that the founders and investors are genuinely interested in helping owners sell their small businesses to their employees when they retire - and that they're genuinely dedicated to increasing the prevalence of employee ownership - then this is _brilliant_ and _incredible_ and to be lauded. It is also possible the whole thing is a scheme to screw the employees and extract a ton of wealth from them for venture capital. Only time will tell. Personally, I'm going to choose to be optimistic and hopeful for the moment.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- silisili 3y ago> small businesses represent 99.7% of U.S. employer firms and 64% of private-sector jobs Is this accurate? Those percentages just -feel- way too high at first glance. Is it counting every gig worker and etsy seller as an independent small business or some other trickery, or were my assumptions just that far off?
- MattGaiser 3y agoI would bet every individual corp is counted as an employer, so under this very few Wendy’s staff count as working for Wendy’s and rather for the franchise business.
- pdonis 3y ago> Those percentages just -feel- way too high at first glance Not really, no. Large corporations have lots of employees per corporation, but there just aren't that many of them, so the total number of jobs they represent is still a minority of all jobs, and the fraction of firms they represent will indeed be tiny.
- silisili 3y agoSeems my issue was with the definition of small business. Found this link helpful in explaining what all qualifies in this number, and it's quite more than I expected... https://www.shopify.com/blog/what-is-considered-a-small-business https://www.shopify.com/blog/what-is-considered-a-small-busi...
- JakeAl 3y agoSounds like these are businesses with aging owners with no succession plans that can also be modernized. They are sustainable and healthy but will run out of steam at some point so they buy them, modernize them, and ultimately sell them back t the employees who will own 80% of the stock after 20 years. Not that uncommon of a business model except the stock ownership part. Typically you see business flippers do this and sell them after 3-5 years, but much like an incubator they leverage the businesses they buy so they also use each others services and lift them all up while keeping the employees employed.
- drt5b7j 3y agoI might've missed something, but.... If they're diluting themselves to 20% in order to incentive worker-owners, do they lose control? If so, they have no leverage to force the business to buy their fintech products. Theyll have to compete for those customers with other fintech firms. On the other hand if they keep control, then it's just extracting the earnings to the holding company with extra steps.
- kwar13 3y agoThis is more or less what a search fund does. Their typical buyout target is a business with no continuity plan and a founder looking for an exit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_fund
- lippihom 3y agoSearch funds don't usually focus on the employee ownership part though. Exit model is usually focused on scaling big enough to become a PE target.