3 ms·
According to the District Court's October 27, 2022 Order, hiQ's litigation was being funded by a third party. Who was this "litigation funder".^1 Perhap the f
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
According to the District Court's October 27, 2022 Order, hiQ's litigation was being funded by a third party.
Who was this "litigation funder".^1
Perhap the funder wanted to settle, even though hiQ could have prevailed at trial on the CFAA claims. Arguably, hiQ's goal was not to establish new CFAA precedent, it was to compete with LinkedIn. It wanted a Court to order LinkedIn to stop blocking its access to public data.
This took too long. hiQ ran out of money. (Or its funding source(s) ran out of patience.)
If hiQ had the funding to go the distance, then it's impossible to predict what would have happened.
It's sad that the top comment in this thread believes LinkedIn sued hiQ to stop it from scraping. That's not what happened. hiQ's "business" was going to fail because LinkedIn was effectively blocking its access, even when hiQ was using proxies and mechanical turks. hiQ filed for a declaratory judgment against LinkedIn: hiQ sued LinkedIn.
Here is the Order for anyone who cares to read it.
https://ia600100.us.archive.org/29/items/gov.uscourts.cand.312704/gov.uscourts.cand.312704.404.0.pdf https://ia600100.us.archive.org/29/items/gov.uscourts.cand.3...
1. According to the Order, the funder is identified in some correspondence filed as an exhibit. It is not clear from the Order whether names in the correspondence were redacted, i.e., it's not clear whether it's public or private information. I'm assuming the former.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Klonoar 3y ago> it's interesting that the top comment in the thread believes LinkedIn sued hiQ to stop it from scraping. At time of writing, I believe that top comment is mine - and I'll be clear that I wasn't saying that I think that's why LinkedIn sued HiQ. In fact I don't particularly care why they did it, I'm just interested in what precedents the case has set and whether the typical comments thrown around regarding the case have any actual merit. There's a comment replying to mine that has a better breakdown of it all that I'd trust over my own anyway. ;P
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"In fact I don't particularly care why they did it, I'm just interested in what precedents the case has set and whether the typical comments thrown around regarding the case have any merit." What are the "typical comments thrown around". Perhaps could provide some references.
- Klonoar 3y agoI know, I linked to that blog over in my comment chain already. :)
- KieranMac 3y agoI am not certain who it is. And even if I were, I would not dox someone who wanted to keep their identity private.