3 ms·
I know if I could get a report on my body that said something like: Death by heart disease - 50% chance by age 65 - 99% chance by age 87 D
by ryandrake 3y ago
I know if I could get a report on my body that said something like:
Death by heart disease
- 50% chance by age 65
- 99% chance by age 87
Death by cancer
- 50% chance by age 67
- 99% chance by age 78
Death by stroke
- 50% chance by age 73
- 99% chance by age 92
... and so on, and it was fairly accurate: It would make me a nervous wreck for the rest of my life. Nothing good would come of this knowledge. Maybe I'd exercise more.
- gojomo 3y agoThis is absolutely true of many personality types! But not others. (And there are perhaps some marginal temperaments that could, with more practice & supporting culture, become more sanguine about any worrying-but-non-terminal interim/probabilistic estimates.) So, rather than denying the info from those who could use it without becoming a 'nervous wreck', maybe the optimal policy would be to offer it based on a psychological pre-screen?
- yieldcrv 3y ago> maybe the optimal policy would be to offer it based on a psychological pre-screen? or have the other ones seek therapy
- gochi 3y agoYou cannot pre-screen for whether or not someone will be affected by receiving a report that they are 68% likely to die by heart disease in the future. That's illogical and quite frankly insane.
- gojomo 3y agoOf course you can. It's not a unique tendency uncorrelated with all other aspects of personality/temperament/anxiety. There are expecially emotional people, especially neurotic people, especially gloomy people – and their opposites, who remain cold in the same situations that freak others out. And it's largely, though not perfectly, predictable. Many people will have enough of a self-conception – like the author of the post to which I replied – that they will have a fairly accurate idea of how they'll react. Any many "in the middle" might, by considering, rehearsing, & precommitting to moods/strategies beforehand, helpfully prep/prime themselves to more-calmly handle whatever probabilistic results come back. Those too concerned, by their own self-knowledge or that of experts/pretests, can skip the risk of "knowing too much" via an elective test, while others can proceed, knowing the risks, with informed consent.
- OnuRC 3y agoAlso majority can't handle truth, even it's about their body. Humans dont follow logic, they're emotional.
- Mistletoe 3y agoYou can already get numbers like that. Put your cholesterol and blood pressure values into this one and see! https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/locations/cannon-falls/services-and-treatments/cardiology/heart-disease-risk-calculator https://www.mayoclinichealthsystem.org/locations/cannon-fall...