6 ms·
Doing a CT or PET scan just for fun is not a great idea, because of the radiation dose received. However, MRI is completely benign. It doesn't expose patients
by cyberax 3y ago
Doing a CT or PET scan just for fun is not a great idea, because of the radiation dose received.
However, MRI is completely benign. It doesn't expose patients to any dangerous radiation and is minimally intrusive (you just need an IV for contrast).
The justification "but then we'll have to check the findings!" is super-weak.
- tptacek 3y agoNo, it's not at all a weak justification, and it is the primary reason you shouldn't get these scans done. The problem here is our old friend the Bayesian Base Rate fallacy. The diseases you're looking to intercept and intervene against are, in the general population, pretty rare. That means that even if the indications you'd get from diagnostic imaging are extraordinarily accurate (they aren't), the overwhelming majority of the flags they raise are going to be false positives. The cost of a false positive imaging flag is far worse than having to have an unpleasant chat with your doctor, or worrying for several weeks (do not discount the cost of worrying for several weeks, though; these scares can absolutely fuck up a month of your life). Rather: you'll pay the price in follow-up imaging, which won't be as benign as the MRI, or worse, in unnecessary intrusive diagnostics.
- jstummbillig 3y agoSeems plausible. So what's up with the wealthy? They do not care? They do not know? They get talked into it by greedy physicians? Or is the story more likely just not true?
- DragonStrength 3y agoWell, it's not as if wealthy people are any different from the average Joe. They may go on HN instead of FB for their medical advice (and I've seen these sorts of scans advocated in comments here, to be clear), but that doesn't mean they have any more knowledge of outcomes for these screenings. What they do have is a knowledge of their own (and parents') mortality and means to do anything they can to prevent it. Buy a bunker in NZ, try to build a base on the moon, or spend a couple grand on a frivolous scan? Rich people gonna rich people. Yes, the medical system in the US is for-profit and fee-based. Medical providers make money by building small businesses which do a lot of procedures. Here is another very expensive, uncovered procedure for them to bill.
- robwwilliams 3y agoIn general, physician do not understand false discovery rates, and when profit motives are involved they do not even want to hear about FDRs.
- bcrosby95 3y agoI've noticed that many educated people expect other, otherwise educated people to not exhibit certain dumb behaviors. In reality, people are people. They will do dumb shit regardless of how rich or educated they are.
- prepend 3y agoThey can afford it. And they are able to pay for anything medical their doc recommends. I am curious but not willing to spend $5-20k in scans and tests. Especially since they can be done annually. Why not? There’s no medical guidelines for what period has higher positive impact. My doctor has mentioned tests that cost thousands and have a low probability of useful information. I say no. If I was rich, I’d probably do any test if the only downside was cost.
- refurb 3y agoYes, they actually do. The question about "VIP healthcare" pops up all the time on certain subreddits and the physicians who comment usually say "it's not worth it at all".
- DragonStrength 3y agoYes, orthopedics has gone down this road. Intervention based only on imaging does not have the best outcomes. Not every abnormality is cause for alarm. Using genetic profiling and family history to decide who to check for conditions is not merely for the benefit of the at-risk; it is also to protect those who might show false positives from unnecessary interventions.
- robwwilliams 3y agoAbsolutely right! The WSJ article could have done a much better job on this topic but instead ends with a rare true positive cancer detection success by a for-profit scanning company. That one rare success needs to be weighed against NN false positives. And a fraction of the true positives might well resolve on their own. What next—trolling assisted living communities?
- zajio1am 3y agoPoint is that if you know that overwhelming majority of the result are false positives so that it is not worth to follow-up them with additional diagnostics, then reasonable step is to not follow-up in that case. It is a fallacy to account the cost of follow-up procedure to the initial scan, when the follow-up procedures are not necessary regardless of the result from the scan.
- prepend 3y ago> then reasonable step is to not follow-up in that case. Then a more reasonable step is not to get the scan. Why do the scan if you don’t follow up. This is why not all screenings are recommended. People think that insurance won’t pay for scans because insurance is a jerk. They don’t pay because the scans aren’t medically effective at protecting populations.
- coryrc 3y agoBecause you can check it on the next scan and see if things are growing.
- drcode 3y agoFollow up procedures should be adjusted based on whether the original test was preventative or not, titrating the amount of risk and cost appropriately The fact that we treat diagnostic results the same regardless of priors just means our medical system is still stuck in the stone age Saying the screenings aren't recommended is just saying "we're too dumb to use the results of this screening the correct way, so you shouldn't get the screening" We can only hope that the new developments in AI will mean that modern statistical procedures will finally be applied to medicine as a side effect (though I wouldn't hold my breath)
- civilitty 3y agoIt's really easy to demonstrate with some basic math too. All of the numbers below are pulled from memory from a textbook example: Imagine you have a test with a 1% false positive rate when screening for a disease that has a prevalence of 1 in 1,000 and the invasive operation to confirm the diagnosis has a 10% chance of serious (potentially life altering) complications like internal infection or an embolism. If you test 10,000 people, you'll identify 10 true cases (assuming 0% false negative rate) and 100 false cases. Meanwhile testing those 110 people will result in 11 patients suffering serious complications. Once you include the complicated math of quality-adjusted life years, it's almost never worth it. In reality the numbers are a lot worse - there is a long tail of diseases with 2-10% false positive rate tests and 1 in 10,000 incidence or worse, with 20% of patients experience QALY effecting complications from false positives. On top of that there are a lot of interventions that require invasive procedures with low rates of success.
- cyberax 3y ago> Once you include the complicated math of quality-adjusted life years, it's almost never worth it. This is an actuarial argument, that applies is you want to have the most efficient overall healthcare system. In other words, if you have to ration the access to MRIs and to followup tests. Now suppose that you are not limited by scarcity. It would absolutely make sense to use the minimally invasive procedures, but perhaps weigh the results a bit less heavily for followup tests.
- moralestapia 3y agoHmm ... idk. I disagree with that (sort of) argument in so many ways. >The disease [...] are, in the general population, pretty rare. Cancer is not rare, particularly from a certain age. Early detection heavily skews the odds on one's side. This is such common knowledge that it feels weird having to justify it here. I know I'm not a "survey performed under the most strict standards of quality" but among my close groups of friends and family there have been a few cases where they got lucky enough to detect this disease very early on, and their treatment and outcome was significantly better (and cheaper, while we are at it, bc you mention cost as well) than if they've just waited even a couple more months. OTOH, I have yet to hear a story from someone who had some sort of scan done, found something worth to take a look at, that then turned out to be nothing and, for some strange reason, had its life significantly affected by that. Doctors are not stupid, they know (or intuitively correct for) this Bayesian Base Rate you mention, plus they have other things like years of experience in their particular field. It's not like someone's going to cut your arm the moment you find a weird looking lump growing inside. >these scares can absolutely fuck up a month of your life That sounds quite immature, tbh. It's definitely a small price to pay compared to all the trouble you save by potentially detecting issues early on. "Oh, but needles hurt :'(", sure, but their benefit far outweigh such small nuisance. This is also an argument I would've thought anyone would just get naturally, and yet I have to explicitly bring it up here, weird. Also, if it came to be the case that everyone got scanned regularly, that massive trove of new data would definitely help improve the accuracy of said tests. It definitely won't make matters worse, but better.
- BeetleB 3y ago> Cancer is not rare. Early detection heavily skews the odds on one's side. Depends on the cancer and even the doctors are torn. Most breast tumors and prostate tumors will not kill you or affect your life much. Treating them likely will (especially for prostate). Depending on the model, the overall health of the population is actually reduced by early detection because in most of these tumors treatment is worse than the disease. One of my doctors is a strong believer in periodic prostate exams after 40. The other recommends only if there are other symptoms. You can guess which is the older one and which is the younger one. Years ago there was the whole Gardasil controversy. What was often excluded in the noise was that if it were mandated for all girls as some states were recommending, it would be so expensive that funding for other health programs would need to be reduced. The studies were showing that this kind of preventative approach would again reduce the health of the state's population. Preventive medicine is good - to an extent. Beyond that it is bad.
- quadrature 3y agoWhy isn’t it sufficient to follow up with MRI scans to ensure the cancer (assuming a tumour) isn’t growing ?.
- foundart 3y agoThe Bayesian Base Rate fallacy is the key here. "Suppose that at your regular physical exam you test positive for Disease X. Although Disease X has only mild symptoms, you are concerned and ask your doctor about the accuracy of the test. It turns out that the test is 95% accurate. It would appear that the probability that you have Disease X is therefore 0.95. However, the situation is not that simple." For the exciting conclusion to this story, please see https://stats.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Introductory_Statistics/Introductory_Statistics_(Lane)/05%3A_Probability/5.12%3A_Base_Rates https://stats.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Introductory_Statis...
- jfoutz 3y agoI read your comment and was all ready to write a, I guess, rant about joint probability distributions and costs associated with tests and on and on. You know, a good old rant. But I took a moment to actually read the article. Low and behold, the first line, or perhaps the actual headline, "Wealthy People Are Getting Full-Body Scans. Early Detection or Unnecessary?" "Wealthy" appears 3 times. Multiple allusions to income, "summer in the Hamptons" and such. I'd need to reflect a bit, but I think I'm pretty comfortable with applying FDA requirements and prohibiting any health claims, but feel free to let the snake-oil salesmen fleece away. As an aside, I wanted to say snake-oil alone, but I learned recently snake-oil itself got a bad rap - https://www.collectorsweekly.com/articles/how-snake-oil-got-a-bad-rap/ https://www.collectorsweekly.com/articles/how-snake-oil-got-...
- drcode 3y agoIt's has nothing to do with the Bayesian Base Rate fallacy. In this case we ABSOLUTELY KNOW the base rate is lower, since it was a preventative scan. The fallacy only happens if you then subsequently fail to adjust for the differing base rate. If doctors later in the diagnostic process fail to take the differing base rate into account, that is not the fault of the preventative test, that is an error in determining what the correct follow up care is.
- Calavar 3y ago> If doctors later in the diagnostic process fail to take the differing base rate into account, that is not the fault of the preventative test, that is an error in determining what the correct follow up care is. In today's medical malpractice climate, many physicians intentionally ignore the differing base rate.
- drcode 3y ago100% correct But now we're no longer having a conversation about medicine we're having a conversation about our broken legal system and our broken regulatory frameworks
- tptacek 3y agoSounds like it does in fact have a bunch to do with the base rate fallacy.
- drcode 3y agoI suppose that's fair way to look at it, but people are being left with the impression that the problem is inherent in the tests, when the problem is entirely separate from the tests themselves.
- tptacek 3y agoI suppose it's a fair way to look at it, too! It's good when we can reach a shared understanding of what's happening; so often, the dynamics of message boards work against that.
- cyberax 3y ago> No, it's not at all a weak justification, and it is the primary reason you shouldn't get these scans done. Yes, it is weak. The so-called downside is that you might need to do intrusive procedures as a followup. But guess what? You don't HAVE to do that. > The cost of a false positive imaging flag is far worse Now think about the costs of not detecting a true reading. Most cancers start having visible symptoms only when they are far too advanced to be cured. So the status quo is: you wait until you get an incurable disease, and then use MRI to solemnly confirm that. And then use it to give you estimates on how soon you'll die. > Rather: you'll pay the price in follow-up imaging, which won't be as benign as the MRI, or worse, in unnecessary intrusive diagnostics. Or you can just wait for a bit and do another MRI to check if there's any worsening. If you can afford an MRI, you likely can afford a second one.
- alkibiades 3y agoyes but the expected value of having a true positive is infinite because it saves your life. so that seems to outweigh the cost of false positive even if that’s more likely
- inkyoto 3y ago> The problem here is our old friend the Bayesian Base Rate fallacy. The diseases you're looking to intercept and intervene against are, in the general population, pretty rare. This is pseudoscience at best and quakery at worst. Body is not a Kubernetes cluster that can be restarted or reprovisioned from scratch when it has become too late to fix an aling pod or a service on the spot. Physiological processes taking place in the body are more akin to stochastic processes whose behaviour can be accurately projected only to a certain extent (the extent varies depending on what the actual process is) based on levels of our current (but evolving) understanding of the biochemistry and phsysiology. Therefore, our bodies require a set of anomaly detection monitoring alarms, of which preventive health scans (whatever that means, not just CT/MRT/etc) are one example. If one such stochastic process goes awry, it can trigger an irreversible cascading failure in the body with the only outcome: premature death. Take inflammation as an example. Inflammation is a root cause of multiple severe as well as degenerative health problems that impair the healthy aging of the body. Inflammation is notoriously difficult to detect via conventional testing means such as blood tests, unless somebody is looking for a specific inflammation biomarker. Routine blood tests do not do that (other than checking the monocyte and eosinophils counts), and when the inflammation reveals itself, it is already loud (pain or impaired wellbeing) and severe (a heart attack) or it is already too late (late stage cancers). Inflammation starts out small and incospicous, and it takes a long time to progress and develop into something more unpleasant. Alzeheimer's, Parkinson, cancers, heart disease, IBS and many, many other health conditions have all been implicated to be caused by chronic inflammation processes that went undetected and were allowed to unfold, with plenty of sufficient (although not always fully conclusive yet) evidence. The vast majority of people of this planet are thought to have inflammatory processes going on of varying degrees of severity – from benign (that the body eventually suppresses) to malignant. If a routine preventive health scan can unravel an inflammatory process early on, it is a win – for the patient (improves the long term prognosis and the quality of life) and for the health care system (early treatments are usually simpler and are more cost efficient, therefore less or no expenditure later). Even if a preventive health scan is a false positive, it is still a net positive, is a net win as it indicates the lack of a health problem, and it is long term investment that time, effort and money for everyone.
- bookofjoe 3y agoBase rate fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy#:~:text=The%20base%20rate%20fallacy%2C%20also,only%20to%20a%20specific%20case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy#:~:text=The%...).
- lend000 3y agoDoing an MRI without contrast is probably benign (and typical of what you would do for sports injuries), but gadolinium contrast is likely to be reevaluated in the near future, as it is a toxic heavy metal that is not fully removed from the body, even in its chelated form [0]. If you ever had a brain MRI with contrast, you would know it's a lot worse than a typical hangover, which is usually not a great sign for health impact. [0] https://www.fda.gov/drugs/fda-drug-safety-podcasts/fda-drug-safety-podcast-fda-warns-gadolinium-based-contrast-agents-gbcas-are-retained-body-requires https://www.fda.gov/drugs/fda-drug-safety-podcasts/fda-drug-...
- bsder 3y ago> However, MRI is completely benign. Unless you use a contrast dye--which is basically needed to be useful at spotting anything. And an MRI will find something. So, the real problem is that you now need 3 or 4 followup MRIs over a period of 2 years to classify them as benign or not.
- eigenhombre 3y ago> And an MRI will find something... Not my/my family's experience - in fact MRI were used to clarify CAT scan false alarms / rule out real issues.