4 ms·
If what you say here is accurate, that's all very good news. But how does that square with the fact that the online ad industry continues to be at war with peop
by JohnFen 3y ago
If what you say here is accurate, that's all very good news. But how does that square with the fact that the online ad industry continues to be at war with people who don't want to be tracked?
- jaclaz 3y agoThe two things do not seem to me as contrasting, there is an industry gathering the data and selling them (with promises and snake-oil) and other people buying those data. Whether what is sold is accurate or not is another thing, as long as it is perceived as "good enough" by the buyers it will be bought anyway. I don't think that many companies (buyers) have the guts to stop for - say - 6 months all advertising on a given channel and see what happens.
- legitster 3y agoAgain, take the data buying and selling and set it aside. That's kind of like a whole separate thing. Even without data brokers, there is tons of fraud and snake-oil. When you are comparing advertising success, website traffic, email delivery, product usage, etc - actually getting consistent user data between them is a nightmare. Everyone has incentive to pump up their own numbers. And oftentimes the reporting you are engaging in is so complicated that a lot of companies rely on consultants to do all of the work. > I don't think that many companies (buyers) have the guts to stop for - say - 6 months all advertising on a given channel and see what happens. Our company had a broken ad run on LinkedIn for 6 months. It cost us over $100k. The manager's response was "Can we turn them on again until we fix them? I need to spend the budget or I will lose it."
- jaclaz 3y agoYes, we are saying exactly the same things, though in a slightly different way. The results of this (or that) advertising are either non-measurable or poorly measured, and the way advertising budgets are calculated (and spent) is - to say the least - perverse.
- legitster 3y ago> If what you say here is accurate, that's all very good news. Ummm. Except for the part where basically a few players will have a monopoly on online advertising. It's really a slow return to how TV advertising and etc worked. > continues to be at war with people who don't want to be tracked How so? There are infinitely more privacy rules and safeguards than there were a decade ago. Let alone the amount of tools like AdBlocker or Ghostery or Brave or etc. Keep in mind that the awareness of your online presence is probably growing faster than your actual online presence. In fact, just like standard of living, it's easy to lose perspective of just how fast our entire idea of privacy has changed. 100 years ago, hotel beds used to be shared amongst strangers. Within our lifetimes, books with every person in town's name, number, and address used to be delivered to everyone's home.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Except for the part where basically a few players will have a monopoly on online advertising. Not being in the ad industry, this seems a lateral change to me. I can see how it would be problematic to others in the industry, though. > How so? There are infinitely more privacy rules and safeguards than there were a decade ago. The online ad industry has poured enormous amounts of time, money, effort, and even lobbying to bypass efforts from end users to prevent being tracked. And that effort continues. There are more privacy rules and tools than before, but that's just because of the back-and-forth nature of the battle. Sometimes privacy edges ahead, then the ad companies push the gains back or route around them, then privacy edges ahead, etc. > Within our lifetimes, books with every person in town's name, number, and address used to be delivered to everyone's home. I'm old enough to remember phone books. And I remember that people who didn't want to be listed, or only wanted limited information in them, had that option. Those books never had every person's information. They were, in modern parlance, opt-out (although you did have to pay a fee to be omitted, which was considered outrageous in the day, but there wasn't a way around that.)
- dylan604 3y ago>Within our lifetimes, books with every person in town's name, number, and address used to be delivered to everyone's home. This example is only half-hearted at best I feel. Anyone touting this as an example also leaves out it was very possible to be omitted from this book or have a name other than your legal name listed. It is absolutely not possible with online tracking. Anyone throwing out this as an example of how "not bad" their industry is can take a long walk off a short pier.