3 ms·
It's a short blurb, so excerpt below is essentially the entire post, but it's not inaccurate: >> [...] the U.S.’ ongoing failure to pass even a basic privacy l
by ethbr1 3y ago
It's a short blurb, so excerpt below is essentially the entire post, but it's not inaccurate:
>> [...] the U.S.’ ongoing failure to pass even a basic privacy law or meaningfully regulate data brokers. We haven’t done those things for two reasons.
>> One, the dysfunctional status quo (where companies mindlessly over-collect data and fail to secure it, resulting in endless privacy scandals) is hugely profitable to everybody in the chain.
>> Two, the government long ago realized it can abuse the barely regulated info-hoovering user tracking system we’ve built to avoid having to get warrants.
In being most charitable towards the piece, I'd put an emphasis on basic (as in, basic privacy law).
The GDPR largely starts from first principles (these are private things) and then assigns ownership explicitly to the person they stem from, along with personal rights that can be exercised to control those things.
US privacy law, on the other hand, generally carves out a specific piece of data (health and financial information, information about children) and then imposes regulation on that data.
HIPAA is the closest general US approach I'm aware of, in that it assigns rights over that data to individuals, but it's a travesty that a similar approach doesn't extend outside of the healthcare space.
The onus should be on companies to prove their data isn't PII, if they expect to be able to use and sell it freely.
- briffle 3y agoFERPA is older than HIPAA, but only covers education, so not as noticable for young adults. It's very strict on who can view and share student information, and how to opt out of directories, etc.
- kube-system 3y agoI've always thought FERPA's main utility is in protecting professors from having to field phone calls from helicopter parents.
- kube-system 3y agoHIPAA doesn't even completely accomplish that. It it pretty narrow in the types of businesses it covers. There are a lot of retailers, tech companies, and health-adjacent businesses that aren't covered under HIPAA.
- candiddevmike 3y agoAnd those companies try their hardest to keep it that way.
- moate 3y agoAlso, as someone who works in the Pharma advertising space, trust me, HIPAA doesn't matter when private non-healthcare companies (read- entities that fall outside the regulations) are able to hoover up so much personal information that anyone who wants to cobble together your profile can. And again, at it's core the issue is that the US government wants to be able to access as much information about as many people as possible in order to "freedom" or something. It's the reason nobody has been able to pull back the "War on Terror" era civil rights abuses everyone gleefully ran towards. There's not enough political will because everyone wants to fight about gay beer and bathroom usage and not esoteric ideas like "government overreach as it exists to benefit the 2-party system, and not as an attempt to punish the other party for doing what your party is doing now that it's in power".
- kube-system 3y agoWe fail to regulate the tools big business uses to make money because they've achieved regulatory capture, and use that data to make more money.
- moate 3y agoThe fact that police can access a private database to circumvent warrants also helps create a perverse feedback loop from within the public sector side as well, I promise. The call to preserve the status quo of massive data brokerage is coming from inside the house.
- hot_gril 3y agoFrom the outside, I don't understand what privacy HIPAA even protects for health. My insurance still knows everything, and school/employers aren't restricted from it (as we tested with vaccinations). It's probably restricting more specific usages, but so what, the ones that really matter appear to be exempt.