3 ms·
The question actually asked about privacy laws is one to which the answer is actually yes, not no: the US has (several) federal privacy laws that impact what co
by dragonwriter 3y ago
The question actually asked about privacy laws is one to which the answer is actually yes, not no: the US has (several) federal privacy laws that impact what companies can do with personal data they collect, they provide radically different coverage for different kinds of data and impose little to no restrictions on many kinds of datat that might be important, but the question doesn't ask about the adequacy of federal laws on data use, only whether at least one such federal law exists. (And “internet-era” isn’t part of the question, despite the headline, though several of the applicable laws were passed in the “internet era”, and even with the internet specifically in mind.)
So a more accurate headline would be “vast majority of Americans aware that the US has some federal data privacy laws”, but that’s not as useful for the PR purpose this is put together for.
- svachalek 3y agoThe question is "Does the United States have a national privacy law that sets common standards for what companies can do with all data their products and services collect?" The key word, but tricky, is the word "all". I think this makes the "no" answer correct but is not a great form of the question. If the answers were "all, some, none, not sure" it would have been more illuminating.
- username135 3y agoThis is why I hated standardized tests. There's no room for outliers or edge cases that make the answer to a question not really 100%.
- hedora 3y agoThe word "all" doesn't appear in the version of the question in the story I see. It just says this: "The U.S. does not have a national privacy law addressing how companies can use the data they collect" Even still, "all" wouldn't falsify the statement. There are some laws enumerating illegal things you could use data for. Anything not prohibited by law is legal. That's how the US legal system works. "Common standards" also doesn't exist in the version of the question in the article. However, setting common standards would prevent states from pass stronger restrictions, with the effect of actually weakening privacy law. [edit: Flipping some negations around, I think your version of the question is logically equivalent to "In the US, state and local governments do not have the authority to pass any laws addressing how companies can use any of the data they collect."]
- hgsgm 3y agoClick through to Pew and then Topline. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/2023/08/PI_2023.08.17_Digital-Knowledge_TOPLINE.pdf https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/wp-content/uploads/site...
- ethbr1 3y agoIt's a short blurb, so excerpt below is essentially the entire post, but it's not inaccurate: >> [...] the U.S.’ ongoing failure to pass even a basic privacy law or meaningfully regulate data brokers. We haven’t done those things for two reasons. >> One, the dysfunctional status quo (where companies mindlessly over-collect data and fail to secure it, resulting in endless privacy scandals) is hugely profitable to everybody in the chain. >> Two, the government long ago realized it can abuse the barely regulated info-hoovering user tracking system we’ve built to avoid having to get warrants. In being most charitable towards the piece, I'd put an emphasis on basic (as in, basic privacy law). The GDPR largely starts from first principles (these are private things) and then assigns ownership explicitly to the person they stem from, along with personal rights that can be exercised to control those things. US privacy law, on the other hand, generally carves out a specific piece of data (health and financial information, information about children) and then imposes regulation on that data. HIPAA is the closest general US approach I'm aware of, in that it assigns rights over that data to individuals, but it's a travesty that a similar approach doesn't extend outside of the healthcare space. The onus should be on companies to prove their data isn't PII, if they expect to be able to use and sell it freely.
- briffle 3y agoFERPA is older than HIPAA, but only covers education, so not as noticable for young adults. It's very strict on who can view and share student information, and how to opt out of directories, etc.
- kube-system 3y agoI've always thought FERPA's main utility is in protecting professors from having to field phone calls from helicopter parents.
- kube-system 3y agoHIPAA doesn't even completely accomplish that. It it pretty narrow in the types of businesses it covers. There are a lot of retailers, tech companies, and health-adjacent businesses that aren't covered under HIPAA.