6 ms·
Huawei reportedly building 'secret' semiconductor fabs
- woooooo 3y agoSecret to whom? Were they supposed to file permits with the US after we cut them off?
- bilekas 3y ago> It has also received some $30 billion in government subsidies to help That's such an incredible amount of money. It would be fair to say they are really just an arm of the government right ?
- f6v 3y agoIt’s kind of space industry. Does US government own Starlink? Yes and no.
- Matl 3y agoI mean they're clearly vital to China, but private industry receives tons of subsidies in the U.S. too, 'defense' contractors, fossil fuels, farming... It's a pretty normal thing for a government to do regarding sectors it considers important. Obviously that buys them influence, in China and in the US alike.
- rhamzeh 3y agoYes, just as much as airlines are an arm of the US government: > U.S. airlines avoided broad bankruptcies and cuts with the record $74 billion in government Covid-19 aid (https://skift.com/2021/07/29/federal-aid-saved-u-s-airlines-from-the-worst-of-the-pandemic-but-was-it-a-success/ https://skift.com/2021/07/29/federal-aid-saved-u-s-airlines-...) Or the US semiconductor industry > Most of the money is going into industry and supporting industry investments. Of the $52.7 billion in subsidies, the bulk of that will end up going to private companies. (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nearly-53-billion-in-federal-funding-could-revive-the-u-s-computer-chip-industry https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nearly-53-billion...) Of course there's more examples for almost any country. I'm not debating your conclusion. I think it is spot on. I am calling out the tone though as if this was not the norm for all the mega corps/mega industries.
- throwaway29812 3y agoYes but no government puts listening devices into their planes to spy on passengers considering they have full control. Wait, that's actually a good idea. Probably likely that one of China/Russia/N Korea/Iran have done this.
- throwaway29812 3y ago..a good idea from the perspective of an authoritarian government. Not saying it's good for airplanes to do this.
- shapefrog 3y agoMusk has pocketed $5bn and that excludes "government contracts". It would be fair to say they are really just an arm of the government right ?
- analognoise 3y agoAbsolutely?
- k7sune 3y agoAt this point we are definitely treating SpaceX as the US space agency and not a private business. People were outraged when Musk was considering whether to continue supporting Ukraine with StarLink. Imagine if he refused to do the same when China cuts the cables to Taiwan, someone will probably try to charge him with treason, only to realize that a private business has no obligation to do so.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoSupport as in keep charging $500 for $1500 equipment and allowing use that wasn't agreed on at the outset?
- dotnet00 3y agoGovernment contracts are work done in exchange for money. They are not subsidies as much as you might wish for them to be. If the government buys 1000 pens because it literally needs them to do its job, it isn't subsidizing the pen industry.
- georgeg23 3y agoIn the case of Musk, that isn't true. The COTS contract awarded half the money ($150M) without any hardware built--it was up-front. This amounted to more than the total amount Elon invested and more than covered Falcon 1, meaning he never had to spend his own money.
- Kognito 3y agoNot to say you’re wrong, but “TSMC seeks $15 billion in US subsidies for Arizona chip plant”[1] and the fact they may get a sizeable share of the EU’s $46 billion subsidy pot [2], suggests that this is just the sort of money that governments are willing to spend to secure access to one of the 21st century’s most critical resources. If anything, given China will not have access to ASML’s latest tech and will need to develop much of the tech itself, the $30 billion seems a bit low for a whole “network” of fabs. [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tsmc-seeks-15b-subsidies-wants-130836706.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tsmc-seeks-15b-subsidies-want... [2] https://www.reuters.com/technology/tsmc-feeling-good-about-possible-germany-plant-talks-subsidies-2023-06-06/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/tsmc-feeling-good-about-p...
- wpwpwpw 3y agoWhat about the CHIPS act and its $52 billion in subsidies and tax benefits? Is Intel just another arm of US government now? And EU will do the same. I believe it's understandable that every political block wants to be independent in such important technologies.
- bilekas 3y ago> CHIPS act and its $52 billion in subsidies and tax benefits? This is a fair point, and I don't know or will assume but is all of that going to 1 company ?
- wpwpwpw 3y agoIt should be safe to assume they are pumping money to other companies, such as SMIC and, more recently, Moore Threads. Although they are years behind and, for example, MTT S80 is at 750Ti levels in lots of aspects, it's quite astonishing the advancements they made in such short amount of time.
- sneak 3y agoThere is a pretty strong argument that there are a set of companies that the USG considers "too big/important to fail" given the roles they have played in defense and associated industries. Boeing and Lockheed certainly, Microsoft and Intel and Dell most probably. Without Intel, the CIA and NSA can't do CIA and NSA stuff. I think they're safe. I can't see them changing their domain controllers and sharepoint out for macs and mediawiki any time soon, any more than I can see them flying A330s.
- HFguy 3y agoDell??? Agree on Intel, MS, Boeing. And there are others. But how is Dell strategic?
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWant your government to buy Lenovo instead of Dell?
- analognoise 3y agoYou think Intel, AMD and NVidia aren't? It's a carrot not stick model over here, but they're absolutely arms of the government and this is squarely in the realm of industrial policy. Everything else is pretend. Intel is supposed to capture how many billions from the CHIPS act (alone - then add in state subsidies) and NVidia can't sell it's most powerful GPUs to China (they have capped memory bandwidth of 600GB/s). AMD tiptoed around x86 designs in "mainland" China through a complex subsidiary agreement - and none of those designs were the most complex (they were reduced in various ways). The gloves are off and we've stopped pretending it's a free market.
- RobotToaster 3y agoThe US Chips and Science Act gives $52bn in subsidies and $24bn in "tax credits" to semiconductor companies.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> That's such an incredible amount of money. It would be fair to say they are really just an arm of the government right ? If so, then every major US bank, oil, car, tech, transportation, banana, etc company is just an arm of the government. It's not just trillions in subsidies that we've provided for them over the past few centuries. We've fought wars to help these industries. The US government committed genocide against native, asians, middle easterners, etc to help these companies and industries.
- paxys 3y agoEvery Chinese company is an arm of the government, whether they have state funding or not. Look at what happened with Jack Ma and the Ant Financial IPO. If the CCP can exert this level of control over a $280B company is anyone out of reach?
- hunglee2 3y agoGovernment definitely is above the Corporations in the China. Perhaps the reverse in the US
- unmole 3y ago> That's such an incredible amount of money. For reference, Huawei reported a revenue of $92 billion last year. I might be biased by my time there but I never got the impression that Huawei particularly cared about anything beyond business. Sure, the ownership structure meant management could take a more long term view but finally it was still about the bottomline.
- rdevsrex 3y agoPretty much all companies in China are required by law to co-operate with the government. They don't need a warrant or anything like that. There is no such thing as a truly private enterprise in China. Plus, as paranoid as the CCP is, they probably have agents in these big businesses keeping track on things. Hmm, that sounds a lot like the Twitter files story :)
- powerapple 3y agoIt is true, but normally CCP is not worried about private companies. Many times, they would ask private companies to help in developing an area, creating jobs. Sometimes private companies are asked to take over a bankrupted company to save jobs at the cost of private company, very few companies would say no because they know they are going to be rewarded later. It is very interesting dynamic in business sector. If CCP does have agents in those big businesses, there would be no recent bad news from the real estate companies.
- startupsfail 3y ago[flagged]
- vachina 3y ago[flagged]
- Matl 3y ago> I’d guess they are preparing for their move onto Taiwan and would like to have more production capacity to remain operational once the war starts I wish there was more of an attempt at analysis re China on the internet that just spitting out whatever the official Western line is, it's not that interesting or insightful. IMO China does not want war with Taiwan, not at present, it doesn't feel ready for it at the very least. From what I can gather it would just prefer to keep the status quo as is. As far as secret labs to build semiconductors, if anything that argues against your theory. It's much more likely China wants to catch up re semiconductor industry and is likely using various methods that all countries developing their industry used, that now they've sufficiently developed themselves they strongly oppose, mainly in the IP realm
- localplume 3y ago[dead]
- startupsfail 3y agoIMO Russia also doesn’t want a war with Ukraine. Only for some reason Russian military was doing major exercises near Ukraine. Which they then invaded.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated Register story just yesterday: China cooks covert chips, recruits global geeks to dodge US restrictions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37249523 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37249523 Guardian piece 2 days ago: Huawei accused of building secret microchip factories to beat US sanctions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37239793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37239793
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoThe headline on this one should be along the lines of "Semiconductor Industry Assoc Responds to Recent Story"
- themerone 3y agoWhen the Japanese government decided prioritized domestic fabrication equipment, Canon and Nikon took over the lithography market with equipment that outclassed everything else. I'm doubtful that sanctions can keep their technology generations behind over the long term. I don't know if it will come from research or espionage, but the CCP will throw enough resources at the problem to catch up with ASML.
- EA-3167 3y agoThat's the point. Instead of effortlessly being able to copy tech that's handed to them, they're going to have to spend time, money and talent to just catch up. While that's happening it isn't as though ASML and others will be standing still, and they won't have to make a national espionage project out of their attempts. Sanctions are about adding cost and friction, not some magical ideal of totally boxing countries off.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoExactly this. Increase cost of acquisition 10-1000x current market rates. The added benefit is that they may produce a competitor to ASML which actually drives down costs and increases innovation. Win win win!
- dwallin 3y agoIn addition, it gives the United States and EU the chance to catch up and build up their domestic semiconductor capabilities without being undercut by chips from China. Countries have too slowly realized the importance of this and are playing catchup after years of underinvestment.
- mathverse 3y agoIt's not sanctions alone. It's the chinese culture of guanxi and corruption that will. Individualism and exceptionalism is not rewarded.
- kridsdale3 3y ago
- engcoach 3y agoAre we ready for Stuxnet round 2?
- bob1029 3y agoI don't think something so sophisticated would be required in this case (but it would definitely do the trick). Semiconductor manufacturing is easily the most fragile industry on earth, inclusive of nuclear and aerospace. If you wanted to completely cripple a fab, you wouldn't need a fancy computer program. All you would need to do is sneak some copper dust into a filter for an air handler and wait for chaos to emerge from yield analysis a few weeks (or months!) later. It wouldn't take much. An amount trivial to get past security. IIRC, Intel had incidents that could be traced back to fertilizer being spread a few counties over. The amount of time it takes to perform this defect analysis is what an intelligence agency would want to target in its activities. Without stable root cause analysis, no practical forward decision making can happen. You can easily get trapped in a vicious cycle of complexity. Getting the fab clean again from this kind of contamination would be like starting over in many ways. You'd have to redo some recipes (because you'd have to throw away some tools) and many of your statistical baselines would be completely fucked - semiconductor mfg relies on statistical process control that takes time to settle, which is why you hear this term "ramping" a lot in the business. For flash memory or older LSI process nodes, you could recover a lot faster. When you are already operating at the bleeding edge, the slightest amount of malice is like the end of the universe by comparison.
- nebula8804 3y agoFascinating comment...but whats preventing China from performing the same actions against EU or American rivals? Surely the second biggest economy has the "potential" capability to damage their rivals in similar ways no?
- bob1029 3y ago> whats preventing China from performing the same actions against EU or American rivals? Nothing other than the automation rate. If a factory can achieve 100% full-auto (which we are pretty much at already), security becomes much easier to manage. I believe US/EU facilities achieve higher automation rates than China in practice, but that is an assumption based upon former experience in the industry. I haven't gone through fab security in over a decade, but I suspect protocols are much more intensive now.
- croes 3y agoHistory repeats itself https://www.history.com/news/industrial-revolution-spies-europe https://www.history.com/news/industrial-revolution-spies-eur...
- fidotron 3y agoIt is curious how the process of entrenchment and even ennoblement tends to lead to claiming others prosecuting the behaviour that got you into that position is the greatest possible evil. Arguable examples include piracy, slavery, intellectual property protections and nuclear proliferation. The ascendancy to the moral high ground does not require abandoning any of the benefits of past behaviour.
- croes 3y agoEconomic leadership is usually based on having been a copycat before and ignoring protective laws. The US did it, Germany did it, Japan did it, China did it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]