10 ms·
None of us are truly living off the grid
- mnky9800n 3y agoI rather enjoyed the book Earth Abides by George R. Stewart. It considers all these problems in depth through it's narrative.
- h2odragon 3y ago> If you think you're going to defect from the social contract but still get to enjoy all the benefits of society, Yeah, you can't do that all by yourself; that's for politicians and movie stars and business tycoons. There are preppers and "self sufficiency" fans who are not seeking to "defect from the social contract"; apparently that's a difficult distinction to make for people taking a quick survey of the field. They're the ones whose advice includes lots of "know your neighbors" and "coordinate with your neighborhood".
- PaulHoule 3y agoSee https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/preparedness https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/preparednes...
- perrygeo 3y agoI'm a fan of the Alone series on the History channel. Contestants are dropped off in a remote location and have to survive on their own with minimal gear. All of them are highly trained in hunting, wilderness survival, etc. but only the best (and luckiest) make it past two months. Humans are not meant to live alone. Even a small group could divide the labor and survive orders of magnitudes longer than a single individual. The most important survival gear is family and community.
- zingababba 3y agoI like that show also. It's interesting how some people seem to be able to go into a semi-hibernative, almost meditative state and others aren't.
- goodbyesf 3y ago[flagged]
- InitialLastName 3y agoI think you're getting down-voted because instead of adding to the conversation, you took a swipe at an off-topic straw man.
- walthamstow 3y agoYou've been downvoted, though not by me, because you introduced a petty insult about an unrelated topic. You then doubled down with an even pettier edit. It's not rocket science mate.
- goodbyesf 3y ago> You've been downvoted, though not by me, because you introduced a petty insult about an unrelated topic. What's unrelated? Many vegans claim that veganism is the natural human diet. That humans originally were vegan but became meat eaters. I've come across crazy vegans here who spout that nonsense. > You then doubled down with an even pettier edit. It's not rocket science mate. My guess is only silly vegans would take truth as a petty insult. Also, I really don't care about the downvotes. I know why I was downvoted by silly vegans. My edit was a lure more than anything. So I can get a big laugh at their expense.
- ndriscoll 3y agoMaybe many vegans claim that, but you can find many of any group that claims something because there are many people. Most vegans will probably warn you that the diet is likely to be nutritionally incomplete and require B12 supplementation, for example.
- ForestCritter 3y ago[flagged]
- ethbr1 3y agoI'm another fan! One of my observations, not sure if an artifact of editing or accurate, is how everyone progressively talks about missing their families more and more right before they decide to tap out. The winner from last season(?) mostly seemed to win by keeping relentlessly positive, whatever happened on a given day, thinking of his family fondly, and keeping his mind engaged with hobby crafts (i.e. making a fancier X for his shelter).
- bwv848 3y agoYou do realize that Alone has a lot of limitations, right? The show begins at the start of winter. Participants are geofenced, and hunting activities must abide by local laws. Not to mention, they don't even get to choose their sites, which is crucial in a real-life survival situation.
- 1-more 3y agoThe way they handle bears is very limited, for instance. Humanity's main defenses against bears have been 1) being in groups of more than one person and 2) sometimes you gotta kill a bear. In Alone you've got your airhorn and bear mace and that's it. I will say I enjoyed the early episode of one of the seasons on Vancouver Island where a cop tapped out within a day or two because there were bears. He even said (I'm paraphrasing) that he's not used to not being able to shoot them or call for help on a radio.
- claudiulodro 3y agoAgreed it would be way easier to survive as part of a small tribe rather than fully alone, but I wouldn't use the TV show Alone as proof. They purposely pick some of the least hospitable places for life, drop people off at the end of fall with no summer to stock up/prepare, contestants have to follow all the local regulations around how/what game they hunt, and (most importantly) nobody is allowed a gun. Plenty of small-time trappers and other pioneers survived on their own during the westward expansion!
- NoraCodes 3y agoAs with all (and especially self-identified) doomer literature, this piece stops just before the important realization: you can't do it yourself, but you can do it with your community. Our lives are going to get worse. Many people will die. If we form sustainable local communities, and build political coalitions to lessen the damage going forward, fewer of us will die, and our lives will get "less worse". It's not over until it's over.
- oniony 3y agoExcept it doesn't stop before that realization, it explicitly mentions it in the article.
- NoraCodes 3y agoIt mentions it in one sentence and then caveats it with saying oh but they're crazy and irritating. It then moves on to talk more about how we're all doomed. It's just unnecessarily negative.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoIt doesn't. It says that once you've built a proper community, you've built "the grid." You're not living "off grid." That's like the whole point of the article. You're never going to make it on your own. Like it or not, we're all in this together. And it's pretty clearly aimed at the folks that don't think they need anybody else to make it.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThank you Build community not bunkers Only one has the ability to last and be sustainable
- myshpa 3y agoHistory is full of communities that were eradicated and buried in the ditches meant to protect them.
- Havoc 3y agoI guess it’s best to see it as a short term edge rather than viable lifestyle.
- jpadkins 3y ago[Some of] You are not going to Make It. I live near the Amish, they are going to make it. Yes life will be harder for them, but they are prepared for a breakdown in civilization. As others have pointed out, it may be more difficult for a single individual to make it, but a large family or small community has a decent shot of survival.
- carlmr 3y agoEspecially a community that is already self-reliant to a large extent. Preppers are doing the IT equivalent of making untested backups. The backups may work, but since you didn't test it they might not work. Amish are testing their resilience daily.
- RationPhantoms 3y agoI thought the Amish were strictly non-violent? Isn't it one of the Christian tenets of "turn the other cheek"? Their predisposition for non-violence may change when they encounter roving gangs of wasteland bandits (from New Jersey) venturing about but that's not guaranteed.
- trumbitta2 3y agoTrinità and Bambino will fix that.
- h2odragon 3y ago> I thought the Amish were strictly non-violent? They aim for it, certainly. They're quite likely to have good relations with their neighbors who are less restrained or forgiving, and who value the company of the Amish and other neighbors.
- stronglikedan 3y agoNon-violent in context is just not violent by nature. Exercising violence in the course of self defense does not make one violent by nature. Self preservation is innate in both violent and non-violent people.
- deleted 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ethbr1 3y ago> We don't think about where we'd go to the bathroom. It's nice to see an article bring up the shit-management problem. Too many folks forget about how much they take toilet paper and plumbing for granted.
- justrealist 3y agoI mean people genuinely living off the grid know exactly where your shit is going — into your compost pile. That's how subsistence farming has worked for thousands of years.
- yencabulator 3y agoLots of rural houses have septic tanks. If you have a large tank relative to number of people living there, and the right biological additives, you can go without pumping it for 10-25 years -- in which time, the prepper will have failed in other ways.
- sverona 3y agoThat's the funny thing about life. No one gets out alive. Nobody's going to make it. Articles that try to scare me with collapse just can't anymore. (I have made peace with the likely possibility of not making it to 50 or having a "normal" death. I was suicidal for so many years that it just feels like an old companion.)
- kbos87 3y agoWhenever I see people talk about how they are planning for a societal collapse, I get the sense that deep down, a lot of these people want to see it happen during their lifetime (or at least they think they do.) If you look for hints about their motivations, it often strikes me as a way for people to feel like they have some sense of control over their future in a world they are disillusioned with. They sleep a little better at night thinking that they are going to get the last laugh while the boss that embarrassed them three years ago starves somewhere. The whole thing then morphs from “I’d better be prepared on the off chance something happens” to “I hope I get to show all of them before I die.”
- keiferski 3y agoI don't think it's necessarily that vindictive. Large-scale civilization is a very recent thing in human evolutionary terms and from a certain angle, a survivalist prepper life in nature does have some appeal, even if it's no doubt over-romanticized.
- badwolf 3y agoanecdotally, every prepper type I personally know falls under that category (the petty vindictive hope of everyone else getting screwed while they have the last laugh)
- eightysixfour 3y agoBit of confirmation bias, no? The other people that have prepared don’t talk about it because it isn’t a big deal to them.
- mgkimsal 3y agoOr definitional? A "prepper type", by definition, is one that talks about it (a lot).
- keiferski 3y agoWhile Reddit is hardly a representative sample, it's not a bad example – and there is basically zero vindictive content on https://old.reddit.com/r/preppers/ https://old.reddit.com/r/preppers/
- keiferski 3y agoI don't know, most of the things mentioned in the article seem like beginner mistakes that even I, as a casual reader of outdoors and prepper sites, already know about. The reality is probably that in the event of a serious global catastrope, the seriously-prepared people will be fine, the sort-of-prepared people will be one step ahead of 99% of the population, and everyone else will be totally helpless.
- pixl97 3y ago>the seriously-prepared people will be fine, If they have an island they happen to be at. The problem is now you're dealing with the law of large numbers. As an individual your plans are mostly meaningless when the catastrophe happens and you're caught on the 405 unable to escape. Having a bunker as an individual means nothing if 20 people happen to get together and rise up against you. This is why off the grid doesn't work. When the grid collapses everyone that you're not really good friends with is now your enemy. To survive you need to have/make new social grids of shared defense.
- dragonwriter 3y agoYeah, but the “seriously prepared” people aren’t hermit preppers, they are the people that have built resilient societies.
- blfr 3y agoThis is article is wrong on both sides of its reasoning. On one, yeah, people built grids and started farming, this is how our civilization came around. These people were more numerous and more dominant, pushing hunter gatherers out. However, they lived worse: they were shorter, worked more, played less, had less interesting routines. It is only recently that we matched hunters in health. And then almost instantly became massively obese. On the other, we* are not headed for any widespread climate disaster. Yeah, fires, waves of migration, etc, sure. None of that will be worse than things we have deliberately caused ourselves (like the collapse of Libya and its aftermath). It won't even come close to pointless slaughters of first and second world war after which our civilization flourished to new heights. * I mean the first world we.
- asimovfan 3y agoInteresting that you think that, don't you think a domino effect is possible regarding climate disaster?
- pixl97 3y agoI really think you need to study more history.... there are massive chunks of what was once fertile land in Iraq that will never be cultivated again. Humans had settled and cultivated it for millennia, but salinization has ruined the dirt. Humans moved away from there and now depend on other land. It was 'easy' back then because the other land was empty. But uh, we've ran out of that empty land. As we burn up more land with climate disasters, over farming, and land destruction via building and run off we aren't getting new land back. These are not short term problems like wars. These are problems that last at geologic time scales.
- blfr 3y agoIf the climate warms significantly, we are getting millions of kilometers of previously unusable taiga in what is now largely empty regions of Canada and Russia. And the population in most countries is already in decline. We will need less food and farming, not more. The fall of ancient civilizations is always a great story but I think we have fundamentally changed when we attained systematic knowledge. There will be no great collapse with massive loss of capacity because we put our understanding of the world and our tech into models and then wrote it all down millions of times. Basically, we know how to build a nuclear reactor, an internal combustion engine, and a computer, we will never forget it, and therefore can always run an industrial civilization.
- JR1427 3y agoPreppers forget that society preps, too, just not necessarily at the individual level. We have warehouses full of extra stock etc, and carefully-managed supply chains, and emergency services. This is all prepping. I think preppers should pour their energy in to helping society prepare, and not just turn their back on the very reason they exist. p.s. I don't consider taking sensible precautions like having a well-stocked medicine cabinet, fuel in the car, and some food in the freezer "prepping".
- JR1427 3y agoAlso, if civilisation breaks down, I'm not sure I want to be around to see the result anyway...
- black6 3y agoOnly we don't have warehouses full of extra stock and carefully managed supply chains. We have just-in-time supply models and spreadsheet warriors who have efficiencied surge capacity to death.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"We have warehouses full of extra stock etc, and carefully-managed supply chains, and emergency services." Did the Covid pandemic not exist to you?
- p_j_w 3y agoNot OP, but this seems like a weird gotcha. It did exist to me and I didn't go hungry. Certain luxury items became hard to get for a while, but necessities were never a problem.
- pixl97 3y agoI too remember people buying 3000 rolls of toilet paper, but it turns out at the end of the day I could still wipe my butt.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago
- photochemsyn 3y agoYes, industrial-technological civilization is only possible due to cooperation of human beings at a very large scale. If that cooperation breaks down, everything goes back to pre-industrial technology, at best - and even that required a great deal of cooperation, as any examination of pre-industrial agriculture-centric society demonstrates. The provision of wood for buildings and ships, fabrics for clothing and sails, simple metal implements as weapons and farming tools, etc all required social cooperation and division of labor, which in turned required legal systems to prevent internecine conflicts from constantly breaking out. If that in turn fails, we're back to tribal hunter-gatherer societies, an unlikely option without a collapse in human population to the 10,000 B.C. levels. This is fairly obvious to anyone who hasn't been completely indoctrinated into the myth of individual success based on hard work - a myth largely promoted to justify the consolidation of wealth and resources into the hands of a small ruling oligarch class in the modern world, see for example Margaret Thatcher's line 'there is no such thing as society' and so on. That said, it's possible that modern technological developments might be able to create the kind of technology that could allow people to survive quite happily with minimal external inputs of raw materials, via extensive recycling of finished goods back into raw materials, use of incident energy (sunlight and wind), but the problem would be creation of the technological tools and maintenance of those tools, which would almost certainly require high-tech factories operating at scale. If those factories could somehow be miniaturized and also be highly adaptable (still in the realm of science fiction, no backyard chip foundries at present) then concepts like a self-sustaining Martian habitat could become more plausible.
- DanielBMarkham 3y agoThis is ridiculous for a lot of reasons. I'll try to just point out the top one or two in the interest of brevity. 1. Predicting the long-term future is a bizarre and fruitless game. One might even say idiotic. If you're a prepper, and I'm not, prepare to live for a month or three. I do. Whatever the heck happens, within 90 days there will be some new normal. You're not trying to live forever. You're just trying to outlive temporary chaos. At that point, you're going to have to reinvent some kind of life. Who knows what that will be? Not me. Not this guy either. 2. He mentions wi-fi a lot. Gotta have that internet, gotta have that wi-fi, gotta have that bluetooth. I kinda doubt it. Can you go a day without internet? How about power? Just turn all of your stuff off. Most folks should be able to learn how to live like normal humans have for eons. There are various hobbies and occupations where you spend a lot of time without power or plumbing: scouts, infantry, etc. These people know what it's like. There are enough of them that the species itself will do just fine no matter what sort of apocalypse you can dream up. It seems the problem with this essay, like so many pieces of media I consume daily, is the desire for _certainty_. Here's problem A. Here's exactly what it means, what causes it, and so on. And you have to do B to fix it. (Or, in this case, there is no B) Disasters are chaotic and uncertain. Assuming climate disasters, moreso. But that both means that things are going to be tougher _and_ you can't have-wave your way around predicting how it all will turn out. Are many people who think themselves preppers disillusioned about their actual skills and their ability to adapt? Absolutely! But that's a one sentence essay. What's the fun in writing and commenting about that? Apologies to the author. I believe there is a good one sentence thesis in there somewhere. But this sucked. I wish you better in the future.
- runjake 3y agoThis is a terrible take. It sounds like the author is projecting their inadequacies. There are countless examples of people living off the grid, even for their entire lives. I’ve lived off the grid. It’s hard, you’re always exhausted you’re constantly having to work to get food and fire. And if you’re in the wilderness, you have to do all that while trying not to injure yourself because help won’t come. This means “going around” obstacles instead of trying to negotiate them. Often, “going around” means additional miles, which means additional calories, which means additional work. Perhaps they should have made a stronger point about the futility of millions of people doing it: - First, millions of people wouldn’t want to do it. They want comfort. They want media and social media and consumerism. - Resources are more scarce, because people must produce them. - People are soft, used to the comforts that civilization provides them. - People are untrained and often terrified of nature, that very thing they are an apart of. Edit: it seems prudent to point out that normal people get their kicks by just going camping. If you are considering going to live in the woods, try starting with short, two-day camping trips and gradually increase the days so that you can take notes and improve your skills and equipment.
- augusto-moura 3y agoYou can live some time without anyone else, but eventually you will need to get some help from someone, unless you want to use stone axes and split stone knifes for the rest of your life (which is possible, don't get me wrong). But if we are talking about post iron age tech, you eventually gonna need to join a production chain of some sort, you can't just find bog iron, smelt it and hammer into an axe by yourself, while also dealing with other topics. You eventually need a community, hence a grid
- runjake 3y agoI disagree. If you have the intelligence and desire, you can easily gain the required skills, likely in the matter of a year if you work hard, to go it alone indefinitely. I think a lot of people shit on self-sufficiency due to their own inadequacies. It will not be fun. It will not be easy. But it’s doable. No, you will not be using metal tools or having solar power. Funny thing about your “you can’t just find…” comment though: when I went to live in the woods, I went deep, miles from any highway and much farther to any town. And I always found signs of civilization in the middle of nowhere especially tons of metal scrap and ancient iron and usable plastic bottles. There is enough debris from civilization all over the planet for scavenging. It makes things a lot easier but you can get by without them. I even found an intact toilet once, in an area far away from even logging roads. My best guess is somebody with an aircraft may have wanted to play a daft joke? The other strange thing were these random staircases in the woods in the middle of nowhere… PS: If anyone reading this is thinking of leaving civilization, I suggest you start with short trips beginning with a couple days and then gradually working them up to longer periods. This will: 1. Allow you to see if it’s really for you or if just doing more camping will suffice. 2. Will show you your skill and equipment discrepancies and allow you to correct them before the next trip in a less life-threatening manner. My first trip was an entire month and it was rough.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoPrepping is hard. I've had the privledge of having access to enough land to theoretically grown enough food for me and my family. Howver, it isn't trivial. This year was a prolonged winter, which delayed planting. This summer was incredibly hot, which has been devasting on our crops. Also... the grashoppers this year have been insane, like nothing I've ever seen. If we were going at it alone, we might not be making it through the next winter. Haha.
- dvh 3y agoDid you planted potatoes? Wouldn't chicken eat the bugs?
- pixl97 3y agoDo you have enough feed for the chickens when the bugs aren't around? Do you have enough chickens to eat the bugs faster than they eat your crops? Do you have enough other food not to have to eat all the chickens? Do you have enough materials to build pens to keep the predators from eating all your chickens?
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoHaha. Yes, this is it. Our neighbor has chickens and we do a swap for vegetables and eggs. We will likely get chickens in the future, but like all things there is nuance. Our neighbor in particular lost 4 or his 6 hens a couple years ago to bald eagles. Turns out chickens don't do well in numbers less than 4 (maybe someone can clarify this, as I'm ot sure), so they eventually got sick or stressed and died. But yeah, to the GP point, chickens are actually pretty good hunters.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoOur potatoes did better this year than ever before. We planted in bags which was helpful for monitoring water which I think helped.
- phero_cnstrcts 3y ago
- krisoft 3y ago> He didn't realize his electric can opener wasn't going to work until after the power had gone out. > He was helpless. Sounds a bit just so? In my arguably not prepared home just in my sight line I see 4 different ways to improvise implements to open a can if I need to. Not counting the two manual can openers I have for just that task. Can openers were invented way after cans were invented. People just used chisels. If the lack of electricity makes you helpless you were helpless even with electricity.
- JodieBenitez 3y ago> A while back, a prepper tried to ride out an arctic blast with canned food and survival gear. He didn't realize his electric can opener wasn't... Wait... what kind of "prepper" is that ?
- em-bee 3y agoif you like to read fiction related to this topic, i can recommend the Parable or Earthseed series by Octavia E. Butler, in particular the second book 'Parable of the Talents' it describes a world where the national governments have lost control and people are fighting for resources. it's a rather dystopian view, but it points out that in addition to living off the grid, which is difficult enough you will have to face others who want what you have. only law and order and a strong community can protect you from that.
- terran57 3y agoI have a personal story that seems to dovetail with this article. Back in the days of the pre-Y2K "crisis" hype, I lived in Colorado and was young and more impressionable, I started developing a prepper mentality. While I was pretty sure that we'd get through that, it seemed wise to plan for the future. So, I fell into a group of like-minded people, and joined in conversations about what would be needed to survive in a post-collapse environment. We honed our hunting skills, pre-stocked camping backpacks, and formulated plans to flee into the mountains in case things went south. We also started looking into what it would take to buy a piece of property and build out a bunker, stock it, and prepare for whatever was to come. My enthusiasm for this individual prepper mentality diminished quite rapidly due to a single conversation. I was in a "seminar" where we were all discussing the advantages/disadvantages of prebuilt bunkers and how to disguise them on the property. During a break, when I asked one of the "consultants" what his plan was. He took me aside, looked around so that nobody would hear him and said something along the lines of: "Kid, don't waste your time with this hiding in a bunker nonsense. Me and my kids and grandkids live up in the mountains and know where a lot of these preppers have their stashes. If things go south, we're just going use our bulldozers and diggers to dig them out and take what they've stored away for us. They won't be able to outlast a group of us." I looked at him like he was Judas, but he then said. "Don't think I'm the only one in this business who's planning to do this, we'll gladly take their money and build whatever bunker they want, but at the end of the day, if things go to hell, we'll use whatever means we have to survive, and so if that means cracking open these stashes - so be it". Then he said "the key to survival is being part of a community you can rely on. Ideally, this is your family as they're much less likely to betray you, but a good like-minded church group could also work". I was a bit stunned by this, but it crystalized in my mind then, that the individual "prepper" was eventually doomed to fail at some point and it was pretty useless to prepare for it. So, yes, I now agree that the best approach to "prepare" is to work to strengthen your community.
- 1-more 3y agoI'm putting all my chips on the Mormons in the US to make it through for exactly this reason. Also because they keep a year of shelf stable food around.
- 3y ago
- readonthegoapp 3y agoi like some of the message and writing style but hate the changing title.
- 11235813213455 3y agoit's a false debate, it doesn't matter to be off the grid, what matter is minimizing our impact For example, with my lifestyle without a car, a fridge, A/C, hot water, heating, TV, €10/mo electricity, without most things people have, my footprint is 5% of the average person. If more people would go in this direction, it would solve all problems
- efields 3y agoobviously anyone broadcasting their off-grid lifestyle is not off-grid. the people that are off-grid do not broadcast their off-grid-ness.
- Justsignedup 3y agoI always saw planning for a social collapse as a way to not actually resolve issues because you feel helpless. "people gonna attack us? IM PREPARED!" you are not. You know what's better than prepping? Fighting tooth and nail to make sure the grid is rock solid and free of corruption. And every day is a battle, because there's always a schemer who will try to get in and hoard for himself. If preppers got depressed from thinking how things are in collapse, and how they need to improve things, as a society, in order to improve things for themselves, they'd actually maybe act. I see preppers as poor "throw money at it" rich folks. Rich folks don't care if the education system isn't working, they can find a private school which costs $100k a month to give their child the best education possible. They can get a bunker professionally built so if anything happens their thick doors and automated guns will take care of any people trying to get in. They can hire a chef and have the best food possible in an ideal diet to keep them happy, sated, and healthy all their lives while most of us have to suffer from over-sugared foods and affordable food being incredibly poor in nutrients Preppers are similar, they don't want to solve societal problems, they want to feel like _THEY_ are insulated from societal problems because they are "off the grid". But they are not. No living up in the mountain is gonna protect you from a bad harvest, or from a crop disease, or from a fucking splinter. I love something someone said recently "if you're in a zombie apocalypse, you won't get to have the cool hair, the cool bat, and go smash zombie brains. You'll likely die from diarrhea pretty early on."
- ryandrake 3y agoIf society actually collapses, a lone libertarian in a bunker with truckloads of fresh water and food supplies is not going to survive. A warlord with as few as 10 guys with guns roving the hills will be able to just kill the preppers and take whatever they need. They're not going to care that you have the deed to your land and you even built a fence around it to show everyone you own it.
- trogdor 3y agoThe one serious prepper I know has a legally-owned belt-fed machine gun - among many other arsenal items - guarding the entrance to his "bug out room." Good luck to the warlord :)
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThis guy really needs to lay off the Sudden dramatic sentence. approach to writing articles. It's not as impactful as he thinks, and really annoying when it's done every 3 sentences. tl;dr: any contact with other people and any trading with them constitutes "the grid".
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]
- RecycledEle 3y agoThe author (alias: Jessica Wildfire) points out some rookie mistakes, like one guy who did not realize his electric can opener would not work when the power was out, and was "helpless" when the power went out. I guess he's never opened a can with a bayonet. If you can not improvise your way into a tin can with hand tools, you should not be allowed to operate a motor vehicle. These kinds of errors are common to any first attempt. Here's a challenge for preppers: Pull your circuit breakers Saturday morning and turn off the water. See how things go. If you make it 3 hours I will be impressed. Then learn, prepare, and try it again a month later. When you can make it 24 hours, talk to me. Most of my friends were at that level before Y2K. You can not be prepared for everything, but you can: Learn to live without electricity or water for a week or two. * Grow a garden. * Move away from masses of unprepared people. * Learn to hunt (legally,) and fill your freezer with wild game. * Learn to shoot and learn to carry a gun legally where you live. If guns are "illegal," get a license. If you refuse to do that, learn to carry a knife. If all else fails, learn to carry a stick. Read "Stick Combatives" by Massad Ayoob, and practice. Then take a fencing class; that will help you with stick fighting. * Learn to repair things around your home yourself. * Keep extra food in the pantry, keep cases of bottled water. * Prepare go-bags, and test them on a camping trip, after you learn to camp. * Earn a Ham Radio license and learn to talk to your friends without Internet or phones. * Store data in such a way that you only need USB power to get access to it. * Rely on your vehicle when the power is out. Even the silliest little combustion powered econocar can recharge a ton of electronic devices if you have a low battery cutoff and devices with the right chargers. Most car chargers never get used, so most car chargers you buy will not last more than half a charge. * Test your gear. If you have something you have not tested, test it or throw it away.
- lioeters 3y agoFormatted: * Learn to live without electricity or water for a week or two. * Grow a garden. * Move away from masses of unprepared people. * Learn to hunt (legally,) and fill your freezer with wild game. * Learn to shoot and learn to carry a gun legally where you live. If guns are "illegal," get a license. If you refuse to do that, learn to carry a knife. If all else fails, learn to carry a stick. Read "Stick Combatives" by Massad Ayoob, and practice. Then take a fencing class; that will help you with stick fighting. * Learn to repair things around your home yourself. * Keep extra food in the pantry, keep cases of bottled water. * Prepare go-bags, and test them on a camping trip, after you learn to camp. * Earn a Ham Radio license and learn to talk to your friends without Internet or phones. * Store data in such a way that you only need USB power to get access to it. * Rely on your vehicle when the power is out. Even the silliest little combustion powered econocar can recharge a ton of electronic devices if you have a low battery cutoff and devices with the right chargers. Most car chargers never get used, so most car chargers you buy will not last more than half a charge. * Test your gear. If you have something you have not tested, test it or throw it away.
- yencabulator 3y agoYou might enjoy this: "He's Lived 50 Years Off the Grid in Appalachia" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LEoW81mUXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LEoW81mUXU (No, he doesn't truly live "off the grid" either, he's clearly buying products from a nearby town. Me personally, I define "off grid" as just the usual rural "no physical connection", as in solar+well+septic, and don't pretend that that's the same as not interacting with society.)
- predictabl3 3y agoI've got a question. What does "Prepperism" look like outside the United States where there isn't a sycophantic individualism-at-literally-any-cost mentality that underpins every psychotic decision we make as a country and as individuals living in it?
- brailsafe 3y agoI'm thankful to have access to a cabin that sits on a portion of the homestead my grandfather grew up on in what is now just a relatively rural area of the great plains in Canada. It's a pretty rudimentary cabin by modern standards, on a farmable, but not easily mass-farmable sizable hectarage. It has electricity, and a septic tank, but we haven't tapped a well, and bring our own drinking water, with a future possible rain filtration system. There's no wifi, but some spotty cell signal. Very good growing soil that doesn't tend to flood so badly, and gravel roads. This cabin, and brief camping/hiking trips, are a wonderful way to break from the city, but I'd never trade it for my rental in the city. I'll never likely own a home of any kind the way things are going, though it's never been on my mind until now anyway, and still I wouldn't live out there as my primary residence; even with a shower, even with good internet, even with a washer and dryer, and I wouldn't do it for the same reasons that my grandfather doesn't, some of the same that the author mentions. There are no nearby hospitals, there are not many nearby people to strike up a conversation with, and it's otherwise quite deliberately isolating; an experience that's fine for a bit, but only for a bit. Even car-dependent, seemingly anti-social suburbanites who hold up in their fenced-in backyards behind the McMansion someone built for them on former wetlands would eventually go crazy if they didn't have their neighbours around to complain about. That amount of time varies from person to person, it's easier if your hobbies or work don't seem to include any other people, until you want to give your crafts to someone, share your work in some way, or enjoy those that others have produced. Maybe that time is when you realize it's impractical for anyone in your family to visit you, or for you to visit them, even infrequently.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoWell that is rather sobering. It reminds me of Covid and the stockpiling of toiletpaper and telling my family how the sewage plants depend on people and power to run , wiping your butt is going to be the least of our problems if this is the end. So long and thanks for all the fish :).
- K0balt 3y agoWell, that’s a hot take lol. I guess the author defines off the grid as totally isolated from any kind of community? Sure, humans survive poorly in very small groups. We are very social animals and normally tend to live in groups. We thrive in groups. People need communities. But those communities don’t have to be cities. And while it is very difficult to be truly independent as a community, it is possible and humans have done it well for hundreds of thousands of years. I think the author just doesn’t know what the heck he’s doing. Ignorance will get you killed, and if it doesn’t, it’ll at least keep you chained to misery. That said… lone wolfing it for 5 years after the fall of civilisation? You’ll die, for two reasons. First, people need communities to thrive. Secondly, if you have the idea of lone wolfing the fall of civilisation, you don’t know what you need to know to survive, much less to thrive. A community however can survive for hundreds or thousands of years. It doesn’t have to be a modern city.
- machina_ex_deus 3y agoAnother climate doomer. First of all, statistically speaking you're less likely to die off the grid after global warming because death from cold is just much much more common than all the other effects that global warming will have. But I honestly don't buy the global warming narrative. And other physicists are starting to speak up against it, for example recent Nobel prize winner John F Clauser, known as the 'C' in CHSH inequality in quantum mechanics. https://clintel.org/nobel-prize-winner-dr-john-f-clauser-signs-the-clintel-world-climate-declaration/ https://clintel.org/nobel-prize-winner-dr-john-f-clauser-sig... Freeman Dyson, was also against the climate narrative. And these are two actual scientists which had profound unintuitive predictions about how the world works. It is so important when people like this OP are speaking contagious fearful narratives that seek to propagate based on emotions, that more skeptics speak up and diffuse this infectious irrational fear that is dangerous to our society.
- tamimio 3y agoIn case of society collapse, you have two options to survive: be part of a community, or as an individual, keep it locomotive! Never stop, never settle, and live the rest of your life on the run.
- bradgessler 3y agoThis article isn’t helpful. Most reasonable prepping resources start with, “do NOT go out and buy a bunch of survival shit. First thing: save some money. Lots of people have emergency expenses, like a doctor’s visit or car breaking down, that they can’t afford”. From there prepping is really about creating a “grid buffer” and getting as many people around you to do that same so if the shit does hit the fan, everybody isn’t immediately out trying to loot each other. FEMA suggests having 3 days of supplies at a minimum for disasters. I personally stock 30 days of provisions, but not a bunch of MREs. Instead it’s stuff we actually eat, but I buy it in bulk. If the grocery stores shut down for 30 days, I’d start drawing down this buffer and hope to hell that the supply chain opens up again in some capacity. Same for water, waste, etc. Pick a buffer that makes sense for your environment and build as much redundancy as you can into it without going overboard. I’ve never seen a sane prepping guide suggest that people should “go it alone” without access to external resources. In fact they suggest the opposite: build redundant networks of people and resources around you in case the primary is disrupted.