4 ms·
Burying the stuff now is a waste of money. It's cheaper to stuff the spent fuel into dry shielded casks and wait to decide what to do with it. This forecloses
by pfdietz 3y ago
Burying the stuff now is a waste of money. It's cheaper to stuff the spent fuel into dry shielded casks and wait to decide what to do with it. This forecloses no future options and allows the relatively expensive burial process to be delayed, reducing the NPV of that cost.
Waiting also reduces the difficulty of dealing with waste, since the fission products decay relatively rapidly. Aside from seven very long-lived fission products, they will be gone in 300-500 years (depending on your definition of "gone"). Indeed, the problem then becomes that the gamma emission of the spent fuel elements is so low they are no longer self-protecting against "amateur" diversion of the plutonium. (Note that this is fission products, not actinides, that decay relatively quickly.)
Personally, I suspect spent fuel will be dealt with by launching it beyond Earth. Think how cheap and reliable distant descendants of today's rockets will be several centuries hence.
- aspyct 3y agoSure, let's pollute outer space, earth isn't enough. Can't wait to see the reaction when one of these barrels inevitably hits something important to someone.
- pfdietz 3y agoThese are deeply foolish objections. Space is already chock full of ionizing radiation, and is so enormously sparse that waste ejected into interstellar space (for example) is not going to hit anything of value, even for many orders of magnitude of time beyond the half life of anything in there. This is clearly much preferable to putting the stuff a few kilometers away from an active biosphere.
- tomjakubowski 3y agohow certain are we of the effects if the rocket blows up in the atmosphere? or before it escapes orbit? the DOE currently thinks it's a bad idea https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/3-reasons-why-we-dont-launch-nuclear-waste-space https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/3-reasons-why-we-dont-lau...
- pfdietz 3y agoPayloads can be armored to survive launch accidents, if mass to orbit is cheap enough. Remember, we're talking centuries of advancement here.
- aspyct 3y agoYes, because everything is always exactly going according to plan. Right?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]