5 ms·
Paper cups are just as toxic as plastic cups
- hmmmcurious1 3y agoThats why I always bring my 2 liter ceramic jug whenever I go on a coffee date
- yladiz 3y agoYou never know what could be in that ceramic, though. I recommend to just use your hands and let your date drink from them.
- hexfish 3y agoDrink from my flesh chalice sister.
- BillTheDuck 3y agoThe pellet with the poison’s in the vessel with the pestle; the chalice from the palace has the brew that is true!
- londons_explore 3y agoGlass is probably least risky... There is a reason most chemistry equipment is made of glass... Even then, there are quite a lot of glass additives, contaminants and cleaning products which can pose some risk
- londons_explore 3y agoYou mean fancy ceramic which is usually glazed with lead[1]? [1]: https://digitalfire.com/glossary/lead+in+ceramic+glazes https://digitalfire.com/glossary/lead+in+ceramic+glazes
- veave 3y ago[flagged]
- theelous3 3y agoThis was a strange read. "Just as toxic" reads, obviously, as "as bad as", with the implication that paper is as bad as plastic. But the article ignores paper entirely and focuses on the use of PLA liners in (some) paper cups and lids. So, already there is obviously far less potentially toxic material and so already the title is untrue. Then the article states that there are "as many chemicals" in PLA as regular plastics. Ok? But what those chemicals are obviously matters? They say that mosquito larvae were negatively affected by both paper and plastic cups, but not to what degrees. This, at least as presented, is trash.
- stuaxo 3y agoStrange I had to scroll this far down to read what seems obvious on face if it.
- asimpletune 3y agoTaken literally, you're right, but in effect their point remains that paper (food containers) nonetheless can be toxic. I think the main point is this is a serious issue but there's still time to phase this stuff out of our lives without it causing a massive inconvenience. They mentioned at the bottom of the article there's an effort in the UN to organize an agreement to ban plastics, and the authors called for transparency requirements from the plastics industry.
- theelous3 3y agoThat wasn't really their point. Their point was that paper containers are toxic, but it's a lie by omission to call them just paper containers. If they had just written a good faith article pointing out that paper containers typically also contain PLA and this is known to be toxic in the environment, all would be well. "PLA lined paper containers are toxic in the environment" would be a fair title. This might seem pedantic but we have to draw a line between good faith activism and intentionally misleading activism.
- arp242 3y agoCups that are 100% paper don't exist, because you can't hold the liquids people drink in paper. Everyone calls "paper cups lined with some material" just "paper cups".
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoOh, yeah, that's no secret. Anything that touches food is lined to within an inch of its life with plastic. There's no escaping that. Every soda can you drink, most of your reusable water bottles, all that supposedly eco-friendly packaging is loaded with plastic. And they can BPA-free you all they want, but they just keep shifting to newer, less tested substances that don't have a bad reputation yet.
- morsch 3y agoThere's glass. Has been around for 3000+ years.
- veave 3y agoGlass sucks. That's why we stopped using it. It's expensive, it's brittle, it's heavy, it takes up a lot of space.
- chaxor 3y agoDon't forget, often contains lead or other heavy metals.
- adrian_b 3y agoThis is true only for old or expensive crystal glasses. Most common soda-lime glass has negligible amounts of undesirable impurities, while borosilicate glass, like I use for my food and drinks, is even more pure and it contains almost nothing besides oxides of silicon, boron, sodium and aluminum, and it is inert in contact with food.
- arp242 3y agoThe only thing I can find on this: https://www.plymouth.ac.uk/news/toxic-substances-found-in-the-glass-and-decoration-of-alcoholic-beverage-bottles https://www.plymouth.ac.uk/news/toxic-substances-found-in-th... In short, only the enamelled decorations may contain heavy metals, which leech in the environment after use. This is a serious problem, but not with glass as such.
- asimpletune 3y agoThe author's point out how before the Second World War, people had to be taught how to adapt to a consumable life style, and therefore we can (and must) continue to adapt to a more sustainable lifestyle.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI'll adapt as soon as they stop selling us unrepairable kitchen appliances that break 2 months after warranty expiration, and cars that are following the same path of enshittification.
- tamimio 3y agoMy grandma (who’s a 96yo healthy and strong individual) still uses pottery for almost all daily drinks/foods and was advising me to do so, guess that’s the secret.
- specialist 3y agoI dimly recall reading about single used clay-based cups. Lowest tech FTW.
- mikae1 3y agoAnd the water pipes that run to most peoples taps are made of… Plastic!
- tamimio 3y agoIn the case of my grandma, she actually lives in a farm, she gets the water from a well in there (yes, the type of well with bailer bucket!), but probably for everyone else including myself, yes, that water is going through all that plastic pipes including all these forever chemicals and what not.
- Tade0 3y agoStainless steel is a great replacement, but it gets stolen a lot in places that implement it. Hell, even reusable plastic containers get stolen: https://packagingeurope.com/news/reusable-mcdonalds-packaging-to-be-monitored-and-tracked-via-rfid-technology-from-checkpoint-systems/10025.article https://packagingeurope.com/news/reusable-mcdonalds-packagin...
- mordae 3y ago> ... A thin plastic film lines paper cups ... Sigh.
- Ekaros 3y agoHmm, is there at this point even possibility to have a safe drink? The containers are one thing, but what about the whole chain how coffee is made and water is sourced? What container is it brewed in, what about various steps in processing the beans? Growing the beans? And same goes for everything.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoIf plastic is worse than paper, and a paper cup has a plastic lining, where the total mass of plastic in the paper cup is less than a wholly plastic cup, this still seems a win. There seems a risk that articles like this that equate plastic to plastic-coated-paper will lead to people treating them as equal, so they may as well use the more convenient one, which seems at odds with the nominal agenda of trashing the environment less.
- another-dave 3y agoThe title of the actual academic paper linked in the press release is "Single-use take-away cups of paper are as toxic to aquatic midge larvae as plastic cups", which seems more focused. It's a real shame when universities themselves participant in the tabloidification of how their research is presented. Would much prefer to see them promoting scientific literacy rather than trying to be as 'attention grabbing' as possible.
- Helmut10001 3y agoAs long as we have separate "Communication and Marketing" departments at universities, this won't change because the people who work there are equally decoupled from research as are journalists. I really had to fight our Communication and Marketing office to _not_ modify the message of a research in order to make it more "appealing" to the wider public.
- max_ 3y agoWhy is it so difficult for us to switch to hemp plastic? It I said to be non toxic & biodegradable [0]: https://www.plantswitch.com/hemp-plastic/ https://www.plantswitch.com/hemp-plastic/
- arp242 3y agoI don't know if hemp plastic is better or not, but I wouldn't take a manufacturer's website word for it, as they're clearly not an impartial source. That website also contains a number of red flags: disable text selection and right click, excessive use of superlatives, no details on why it's better/less toxic than other bioplastics, no hint of even the slightest study on hemp plastic. Maybe hemp plastic really is loads better, that would be fantastic! But that link didn't convince me.
- gumby 3y agoEdible waxes or shellacs have been used for a long time, but PLA is easier to get and work with given the fossil infrastructure that already exists (path dependence). That being said, PLA is pretty benign. Back when I was in pharma we used it in a variety of formulations and never saw anything in animal histopath (as expected — that’s why we used it). It’s a pretty common excipient. This result is interesting, perhaps minor perhaps not. And let’s not forget that the discarded cups themselves clog waterways and interact otherwise with the local ecosystem (as housing for some animals, pests or not), change the local pH of standing water etc…