3 ms·
Would be nice to be able to centrally manage subscriptions through your bank. Or perhaps better yet, to roll them into taxes, which would avoid some issues goin
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
Would be nice to be able to centrally manage subscriptions through your bank. Or perhaps better yet, to roll them into taxes, which would avoid some issues going through banks would cause, and offer a nice symmetry to how one-time purchases work.
To me, all those subscriptions have a management overhead that's often greater than their sticker price. Here, $30/month is actually better than $3/month, because there's only so many $30 things that will fit into my "I like it but it's not a strit necessity" monthly budget. But that same budget will fit 10x as many $3/month subscriptions, and the amount is small enough that it's easy to ignore, and it's easy to lose track of all such subscriptions (and then tracking them down and re-evaluating whether you need them feels like more effort per subscription than that $3 or $1 or whatever).
The bigger overhead, however, is relationships. Each subscription is a business relationship, and one I do not want to have. This is where the tax angle, and aforementioned symmetry with one-time purchases, would come into play: for regular one-time payments for goods and services, I do not need to establish ongoing relationships with the providers, because government does it for me. It rolls them all into a neat package by means of generic consumer protection laws, which allow me to not care or remember about any particular vendor if all is right, and if something goes wrong, all I need is to have a standard proof of purchase (receipt or invoice), and a set of standard keywords to put into an e-mail ("warranty", "non-compliant goods", "GDPR", etc.), and things magically right themselves most of the time. Worst case, I need to also remember which form to fill to get courts involved.
That's such a huge win, that most people don't even see it. Whenever you go to buy your daily bread, or get a haircut, you do not need to stick to the same vendor, or sign a contract with them, or otherwise care about ongoing relationship. You can, if you want, but you do not have to, and that's despite the vendor very much wanting you to. The relationship exists, but it's managed for you, centrally, by your local regulator - making purchases O(1) with respect to number of vendors. Whether you shop at one place or a thousand, the overhead is the same.
I would like that to extend to recurring services too. There is absolutely no need for a random SaaS to force me into having a relationship with them. I would prefer to have a standardized process of billing and resolving disputes that lets avoid having to study everyone's individual ToS, or dealing with vendors' dark pattern bullshit. I want to focus on making use of the service, not on who provides it. That's the symmetry rolling subscriptions into tax system would provide.
- FridgeSeal 3y ago> Would be nice to be able to centrally manage subscriptions through your bank. In Australia we’re getting a new system called “PayTo” which will be replacing all current direct debits. One of the advantages of this new system is that you can do precisely this-manage direct debits from within your bank account. Other benefits include making it easier to setup than the current direct-debit-tire-fire. Obviously doesn’t help in all scenarios, as many subscriptions are just withdrawals, but it’s nice that it’s at least possible.
- TheFragenTaken 3y agoWe have PBS here in Denmark too, which sounds very much like PayTo. However, what you'll quickly find is, unless it's rolled into Stripe etc., that international businesses are not going to pay the premium of using PayTo on a subset of their userbase. Both implementation and billing through such a system is typically higher than continuing to bill debit cards directly.
- p_l 3y agoThere was, at one point, a very positive, non-ad related, Google project targeting microtransactions for supporting content on the net without having to create full business relationships etc. - Google Contributor. Like many google things touching payments, it unfortunately started in such limited area that it couldn't have any future other than cancellation for lack of interest, because most interested people couldn't use it...
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y ago> Whenever you go to buy your daily bread, or get a haircut, you do not need to stick to the same vendor, or sign a contract with them, or otherwise care about ongoing relationship. You can, if you want, but you do not have to, and that's despite the vendor very much wanting you to. The relationship exists, but it's managed for you, centrally, by your local regulator - making purchases O(1) with respect to number of vendors. Whether you shop at one place or a thousand, the overhead is the same. This seems to miss out on the difference between commodity and non-commodity goods and services. LWN, or the channels I watch on YT, or the people I support on Patreon, are not commodity services. They are not interchangeable in any real sense.