5 ms·
The real world caught up, and passed cyberpunk. The whole concept of a counterculture is gone. The closest thing we have to a counterculture in the US today is
by Animats 3y ago
The real world caught up, and passed cyberpunk.
The whole concept of a counterculture is gone. The closest thing we have to a counterculture in the US today is the MAGA/militia/Q-Anon movement.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- IggleSniggle 3y agoWow. I can't believe I'm on this side of the fence.
- suoduandao3 3y agoIt's worth remembering, by definition the majority of people are. Our civilization (and if you're American, your nation) just happens to fetishize successful rebels. It's probably a very unusual attitude, historically speaking.
- dfxm12 3y agoMaybe militia, if you're talking about people who've more or less removed themselves from regular society to live in a compound, likely off the grid, similar to the group who took over the national wildlife preserve in OR several years back. MAGA is way too mainstream to be a counter culture. QAnon is more like a belief in certain conspiracies than an ethos you live by, no?
- ta988 3y agoThe problem of militias in the US is that they are not removed from society. A lot of them were part or are still part of law enforcement and are keeping really close ties. They are a really strong culture and spreading fast. The thing is that they look so much alike and share so much with the "official" law enforcement, that could keep them in check, that not much is done to them or they even get support. Unfortunately America is just getting ready for a coup (there was one attempt already) and forces are gathering for the next one. Almost half of the population wouldn't be opposed to it. That's the reality, and from my point of view that's a little scary.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI'd argue the trans and gnederfluid movement is counterculture in that it is a major shift in social norms, language and self-presentation and isn't yet sufficiently mainstream to be noncontroversial. Aside from identity, is there no counterculture, or is everything so interconnected and observable via Internet and social media that nothing is in a "dark corner" anymore? I can see that argument.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoWhen your country flies your flag over its embassies around the world, you are not the counterculture. And let's not even get started on how the Fortune 500 has embraced this faux counterculture.
- Ekaros 3y agoIf you get wide ranging corporate support, per cyberpunk traditions you are on the evil side. And actually the grass roots movements that are against that sort of messaging by corporations and big political parties are the counter culture.
- femming 3y agoRadical feminists are the counterculture here. They're fighting against both the prevailing male-dominated liberal and conservative cultures, on so many fronts, including this. Particularly this, right now, as a matter of urgency, before women are erased and replaced in law and policy. Their messaging is grassroots - stickering, small-scale protests bringing together a network of like-minded women. They exist on the fringes of the internet, corralled off into their own online spaces after being forcibly removed from the mainstream.
- suoduandao3 3y agoBy Radical feminists I assume you mean what the mainstream culture calls TERFs? If so I think that's a good point, and funny how both the DEI enforcement officers in HR and the countercultural elements putting stickers on bus stops call themselves the same thing.
- kdazzle 3y ago> The whole concept of a counterculture is gone. The closest thing we have to a counterculture in the US today is the MAGA/militia/Q-Anon movement. You're probably just getting old
- coldtea 3y agoNo, he's just observant. Historical periods change how culture operates and what parts are relevant. There hasn't been a counterculture for some time, including there not being one when most of us here were young. The last throws were in the 80s. There are structural and cultural reasons that make it difficult to have one now (the internet's total immediacy and transparency of everything, post-modernism which means nothing is ever really new now, just recombinations).
- namaria 3y agoRock was just blues recombined and hip hop was just drum solos recombined. Everything "counter culture" a generation comes up with becomes cultural business for the next, when the youth who created it gets mortgages. But there's always subversive, alternative sub cultures out there. A world of 8 billion, where the Internet has been a thing for over 30 years, with literal hundreds of giant cities. And you think "there's no more counter culture because I ain't seeing any"? Really?
- coldtea 3y agoThat's the problem: rock wasn't just blues recombined, nor hip hop just drum solos recombined. And they didn't hit culturally like mere recombinations. Blues were an "folk" art form from blacks, expressiving everyday problems, heartbreaks, poverty etc, in a speficic expressive and cultural context. Rock even from its early days operated in a very different context (teen fun and rebellion initially), and developed into very different aesthetic and social spheres, from student protests and civil rights to anti-war and mind-expansion. Except from understanding that it had blues as part of its musical (and only musical) heritage, it wasn't perceived as a mere recombination of blues, and it didn't serve the same social role as blues did. >But there's always subversive, alternative sub cultures out there. A world of 8 billion, where the Internet has been a thing for over 30 years, with literal hundreds of giant cities. The recentness doesn't really change much about how fast something can spread. For example almost everybody of age in those 8 billions has a mobile phone now (even in the poorest African countries) and yet phones have really been a thing for 25 years. If your point is "we might not see subversive, alternative sub cultures out there" but surely there must be some in some of those "literal hundreds of giant cities" all over the world, I think it makes my point. Countercultures were major impactful movements in the western world for decades. And your answer basically amounts to "just because you can't see them doesn't mean there's not some still going on in Cairo or Okinawa". It's like saying "shoe cobbling isn't dead, there's some such shops in New York" or "Addis Ababa has quite a few".
- probelm 3y agoCounter culture is there it’s just abstract now: wfh automating away exploitative labor intentionally not having kids/imploding nuclear family as the norm <50% in US are convinced god exists local AI/ML threatening copyright rent seekers steam/proton online retail impact on brick and mortar
- coldtea 3y ago>wfh Spearheaded because of huge pandemic "extreme condition" measures, with more to come. >automating away exploitative labor And relegating of pesky ex-workers to slums Soylent Green / Ellysium style. >intentionally not having kids/imploding nuclear family as the norm Massive demographic collapse, with societies full of older selfish adults, Children of Men style. ><50% in US are convinced god exists But 99% still worships money and the rat race as god. >local AI/ML threatening copyright rent seekers And non-local AI killing the livehoods of artists and creatives, for the benefit of AI corporate overlords. >online retail impact on brick and mortar Consolidation of consumer market on a handful or corporate behemoths, Robocop style. You say all those things as if they're good... (And the fact that "steam/proton" even makes the list as something of similar importance is cherry on top)
- probelm 3y agoPoint to a period in time when things were perfect? Go in semantic circles if you want, these things are displacing old cultural norms; they run counter to established culture Maybe log off the fucking internet where you spin in circles in vain seeking a perfect solution and tackle those problems you called out? Nah, much easier to be an energy vampire from your armchair Here’s let’s lean in: So sad for Hollywood artists who covered for pervs and leches; if it’s about the art they can “slum it” in local theatre; capitalism never owed them glamorous lives as humanity never owed them deflating themselves for a handful of pretty people Taxes are an option for dealing with corporations but you're keen to propagate mopey whiner on the internet rather than “tax the rich” steam/proton undermines Windows market share, you know that thing produced by big corporate you so hate wfh has people talking about QOL more than money and the shitshow that is hustle culture …you’re crying about your chains, too unimaginative to see the bits and pieces around you that could serve as a lock pick I never meant to imply Heaven on Earth was around the corner. Was responding to the idea there’s no counter movement to contemporary cultural norms Social norms are not immutable physics https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37258231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37258231
- bpiche 3y agoCyberpunk didn't die, it just stopped being fiction
- contingencies 3y agoNice one. Added to https://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup https://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup
- bpiche 3y agoCool. I think I'm paraphrasing a meme that goes "{x} never died, it just became {y}" Almost edited s/didn't die/never died/ Look around the net and you'll see it now and then. https://jalopnik.com/the-porsche-928-never-died-it-just-became-every-other-1798401943 https://jalopnik.com/the-porsche-928-never-died-it-just-beca...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- falqun 3y agoI disagree. Take absurdism, or the deconstruction of gender for example. Or people using mastodon just to show the 12-ish friends that they repaired a their dirt cheap bike. I think also you could also argue that Meta-Irony is some form of counterculture. Just think things that are not commodified yet.
- fit2rule 3y ago[dead]
- puchatek 3y agoThat's a very amicable framing of what basically amounts to an inability to judge sources and adequately process information, coupled with a taste for consequence-free, amoral behavior and an authoritarian mindset.
- porkbeer 3y agoNot true and a bit trite. You don't get out much and are online alot?
- anthk 3y agoThose are just reactionary wackos. They want their old abusive status back. They'd love to lynch back the blacks, put women 'back' in the kitchen, beat up homosexuals, exclude Atheists... Counterculture existes in libre gaming, distros, hackers, underground games such as Nethack, IF games from IF archive, niche electronica/rock/metal/blues from Jamendo (Revolution Void, Proleter, Helfervescent, Nanowar (ok, now is half-mainstream, but still...) and now saved back in archive.org thanks to James Scott...
- prepend 3y agoHoney Boo Boo and rednecks with purple hair is over 10 years old [0]. What the counterculture movement of the 70s and 80s presented, at least externally through hair, clothes, tattoos, piercing, etc is now post mainstream. It’s like this huge portion of society “rebelling” against a Nixon that no longer exists, or is a much smaller portion of the population than it was when it was an oppressive majority. I remember in middle school I was paddled by the headmaster because my hair was too long. It touched my shirt collar in the back. [0] premiered in 2012, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Here_Comes_Honey_Boo_Boo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Here_Comes_Honey_Boo_Boo
- suoduandao3 3y agothe idea of counterculture being gone was a feature of cyberpunk too though. I've heard the core theme of cyberpunk expressed as 'whither bohemia in a hyperconnected world?'. There's not really a mainstream culture now. Even the biggest consent-manufactories like the 'mainstream media' are actually a minority in an overall fragmented and dissenting pseudoculture that's becoming more like an ecosystem than an expanding monoculture. What would have been 'the dominant culture' in the civil rights era, the domain of the Cronkites of that era, is now just another minority, perhaps the largest single minority but still distrusted or ignored by the majority.
- michael1999 3y agoI dunno. The Juggalos strike me as vibrant.
- rchaud 3y agoMAGA/militia/Qanon are conspiracist grifts that simply extend pre-existing societal wedge issues (god, guns, government). What cultural artifacts or innovations has this counterculture created? They appear to be entirely dependent on mainstream media and social platforms to carry their message.