3 ms·
Historically the notions of cleanliness and health are excpetionally strongly aligned with virtue, and filth, disease, ugliness, and disability with sin or evil
by dredmorbius 3y ago
Historically the notions of cleanliness and health are excpetionally strongly aligned with virtue, and filth, disease, ugliness, and disability with sin or evil. This appears across a large range of Eurasian cultures that I'm aware of, and quite probably even more widely elsewhere (though I'm less aware of those).
Even such attributes as handedness can be ascribed to virtue or sin, as with, well, sinister, literally, "of the left side", but with the evolved sense of "prompted by malice or ill-will". See: <https://www.etymonline.com/word/sinister https://www.etymonline.com/word/sinister>
(And apparently "sinister" and "sin" are not related, though that possibility had occurred to me whilst writing this.)
The same concept often extended to medicine and medical practice, and it wasn't until the emergence of germ theory of infectious disease that medical knowledge and practice began to emerge from its moralising of pathology to a general understanding of disease and dysfunction as being organic in nature. That shift is still incomplete, and there are places, institutions, individuals, and conditions in which moralisation remains a too-common occurance (obesity, addiction, sexually-transmitted diseases, and mental health most especially). We also see moralisation of pathology in other contexts, most notably in criminal law and politics.
- gumby 3y agoYeah, I believe that the absurd “virgin” obsession in some cultures is an archaic holdover to try to avoid STDs.
- giardini 3y agogumby says >"I believe that the absurd “virgin” obsession in some cultures is an archaic holdover to try to avoid STDs."< No shit, Sherlock!8-)) But to characterise this as an "absurd ...obsession" is wrongheaded. Of course people don't want STDs! STDs for the most part killed people (syphilis, HIV/AIDS, hepatitis B, et al). Only in the last century have we had antibiotics and only in the last 50 years antivirals. Were there a major war supplies of those drugs, along with the birth control pill, would dwindle or vanish. STDs are a scourge b/c we have nothing to make them go away permanently. Maybe someday we will, but until then being a "virgin" has certain very real advantages.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThere's that nagging little issue that female virginity is far easier to reasonably validate than male virginity. Whilst the disease transmission risks are not similarly asymmetric.
- butlike 3y agoExplain how? Cause as far as I know, the hymen is not a reliable indicator of virginity.
- dredmorbius 3y ago"Reasonably" is doing heavy lifting in my earlier comment. False negatives are possible, but not false positives, of PiV activity. (Other activities of course leave no such evidence.) And there's no equivalent physical indicia for males. Also, as noted, if the concern is disease, then the fact of a test (however fallible) creates a highly asymmetric burden.
- gumby 3y ago> But to characterise this as an "absurd ...obsession" is wrongheaded...[STDs bad] Of course they are but it’s archaic and thus absurd today when they can be avoided (ubiquitous condoms) and in most cases treated. Not to mention I like to engage in activities with others with a modicum of skill…not like I seek out novice chess or tennis players. Without the STD risk the characteristic has no benefit.
- mistrial9 3y agono - because sex has a biological cost. Many mammals have a "heat" cycle where adults become sexually active, then it goes away. Then everyone can return to survival. It is arguable that only certain niche creatures with relatively easy lives, can afford to be sexual more than that.
- dredmorbius 3y ago
- persimmiu 3y agoIt may be a primal aversion to illness and its manifestations because of a natural selection favoring the best and the fittest, as anything skewing from that could pose a danger to survival. Let me be clear that I do not justify any discrimination or prejudice but I also acknowledge that there are primal urges at play and it's from this point of view that I speak, not my human own.
- dredmorbius 3y agoI would agree with most of that. There still comes a point at which the notion that there are physical (as in real-world, manifested, measurable and discoverable) causes to dysfunctions rather than metaphysical or spiritual ones (and I'm including such phenomena as behaviours, social dynamics, and psychology as "physical", inasmuch as they exist within and not beyond the physical world). At which time the concept of moralising pathologies itself seems to become a pathology, hindering rather than assisting in resolving those issues. The primal aversion model works where such knowledge isn't present, and as that aversion is itself likely wired deeply within our genetics and psyche, it's not something easily banished. But it is advantageous in general to override that tendency, most especially if one's goal is to actually solve the underlying problem, as physical causes imply chains of causality and opportunities to influence outcomes.