3 ms·
The crucial thing for me to remember is that it wasn't my fault. I can do whatever I want because 100 companies are responsible for 71% of GHG. It is their faul
by renewiltord 3y ago
The crucial thing for me to remember is that it wasn't my fault. I can do whatever I want because 100 companies are responsible for 71% of GHG. It is their fault and their shareholders' fault and my behaviour has no effect. Once I remember this, I stop worrying because of that piece of the Prayer of Serenity:
> God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference
Since I cannot change this, I just need the wisdom to know the difference and the serenity to accept it.
- jerojero 3y agoBut what are you doing that actually is in your power to change things? What political options and movements do you support, for example? Have you gone out and participate in climate protests and the like? It's not much, but it's what we can do as citizens. The world changes through politics, and we should do more to participate actively in it.
- beachy 3y agoI believe you are responding to some rather lame sarcasm.
- haswell 3y agoPerhaps, but it’s a position that quite a few people misguidedly take very seriously. I think it’s good to counter these arguments where they come up if only to leave behind something for a future curious reader unsure of what to do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- clnq 3y agoWith our highly individualistic and stratified society, I don’t think we have the voting power or any negotiating power against deeply capitalistic corporations. They simply follow the capitalistic imperative - optimize capital gains. We - the society - on the other hand, have no such imperative to follow and can’t even decide what we want. Some think the capitalism needs to restricted to ethical boundaries, others think the former are evil communists. If people weren’t so echo-chambered and isolated to ideas different than their own, perhaps one day we could decide what our universal priorities and values as humanity are. Are they about maximizing capital, or preserving our planet and survival? Or maybe they are about something else. But we can’t even begin to have a serious discussion about this with the overwhelming majority of people today. And that would be just the first step to change. So I really think we are powerless to change how capitalism is dooming the planet. There are probably some people in the world capable of changing this - governments, presidents, kings, hedge fund managers, religious figures, and maybe some other leaders. I can’t make the needle move much even if I spend my life doing it. I’m just not in a position of power large enough to steer capitalism itself on a global scale.
- haswell 3y ago> I can’t make the needle move much even if I spend my life doing it. I’m just not in a position of power large enough to steer capitalism itself on a global scale. Steering things on a global scale shouldn’t be the goal to begin with at the individual level. This isn’t the needle individuals need to try to move. You absolutely can make a difference though. Change starts with you and me. And then the people around us. The way we choose to spend our money. By getting involved in our local governments. By supporting organizations that take action. By volunteering to take action. Every movement starts with an individual. Every massive human endeavor has required the collective effort of many individuals, and this is no different.
- clnq 3y agoDon’t expect people aren’t doing these individual things. Reuse, buying ethical products, recycling, public transit, and so on. It’s just that you’d never see the needle moved this way, so you probably wouldn’t be able to tell how many people are doing these things.
- jerojero 3y agoI will once again recommend Helene Landemore's "Open Democracy" as well as Camila Vergara's "Systemic corruption: constitutional ideas for an anti-oligarchic republic". I think seeing what the french convention for the climate produced is really helpful. I had flaws of course but overall a very positive opportunity that has been definitely further refined with the convention for the end of life. And now we are already seeing a push for others one to tackle the pension crisis in France. These are real political alternatives, as of now, there is little real power that are given to these. But mostly people don't even know what's possible so they're just not pushed by the public. I believe pushing for more popular power and better (real) representation that's not tied to voting is our only way of addressing the corruption that's present in our political systems, dominated by oligarchic/elitist/plutocratic ideas. We are not powerless, it's possible, we just need to be aware of what are the right alternatives that we ought to push for and start coordinating to bring these to the masses. At the very least, I believe, different social movements should be pushing for the same "tools" to be used to address the problem. I know climate change groups push for something similar to the citizen's convention for the climate in their own respective countries. But these things are "new". I encourage you to take a look at the books I recommended in the beginning, see if maybe your perspective is shifted a bit and you become a little more optimistic :)
- mr_toad 3y agoGlobal CO2 emissions need to be reduced by 45% very soon. Like by the end of the decade soon. Less than seven years. There is no political solution. There’s no hope of any government taking any meaningful action. It’s all words and greenwashing. A substantial reduction in consumption for everyone? Blame companies all you like, but companies don’t sell what people aren’t buying. Consumers around the world aren’t going to scale back consumption by double digit percentages in less than a decade. They’ll revolt against anyone who tried to make them. There’s no technical solution that can come on line fast enough. Renewable energy is just not going to scale up scale that fast. Especially not when governments are still subsidising fossil fuel, opening new coal mines, and coal power plants. So what’s left? You can hope that the ‘worst case’ scenarios aren’t that bad, (and hope even harder that the scenarios the official reports deliberately omit the worst of the worst case scenarios, never happen). And even in the best case scenarios if we don’t reduce carbon emissions we’re going to see famine, pestilence and war. Maybe in the end war will accomplish what politics couldn’t. If we destroy enough of the world’s economies it might be enough to stop all the ice melting completely.
- bushbaba 3y agoMore likely is a huge population decline from cost of living being too great for most to have kids.
- jerojero 3y agoWell, I know in France there was a citizens convention for the climate that developed citizens-led initiatives such as banning short flights and so on. That's significant. When you say "consumers would revolt against these policies", would they? Because representative citizens assemblies pretty much prove you otherwise, these are not political activists that got together to push an agenda; it's the result of a representative (through sortition) sample of the french people. Maybe in America things would be different, but I honestly wouldn't say with certainty that it is so. Although for the citizens convention for the climate in France from the ~180 proposals only 30ish were approved by congress. So this shows the tension between what people might want and what congress is willing to pass; probably because congress is under a much higher pressure from lobbying, so they're much less bold. But really, my point here is that there are political alternatives. These are not very well known but they're very much real. I know climate movements and activists in other countries, such as Norway, are very much aware of these and these are the policies they want to push for. So I would say, really, there's a big difference between not knowing and not being involved and actually not any viable alternatives to the problem being out there. I would say the first step is awareness and is involvement. Literally, just talking about it in a serious manner and not simply going "ugh, but politics is so useless!". Ask yourself why and what is being done and what people are trying out there. Because a lot is being tried, particularly in Europe. Just get involved locally and bring these ideas forward. Basically what I'm saying is we should be pushing for a "let us actually decide for ourselves" movement rather than specifically something about climate. And this I believe is something a lot of people can agree on, from the current polarized political spectrum. As there is a very real crisis of representation in our democracies. No one likes politicians.
- haswell 3y agoI agree that you should not spend your life stressing over things that you cannot change. But that does not imply that individual change is still not necessary. The one thing we can change is ourselves, and when we do, it impacts the people around us. The only thing guaranteed to doom us all is if everyone adopts the mindset that “I can’t do anything”. Maybe we can’t individually, but collectively, markets shift, political will shifts, and our preparedness for harder days ahead improves. We can’t undo the damage that has been done, but individual action still remains critical, and increasingly so.
- wolfgang42 3y agoCite for this figure: https://web.archive.org/web/20170710191300/https://b8f65cb373b1b7b15feb-c70d8ead6ced550b4d987d7c03fcdd1d.ssl.cf3.rackcdn.com/cms/reports/documents/000/002/327/original/Carbon-Majors-Report-2017.pdf?1499691240 https://web.archive.org/web/20170710191300/https://b8f65cb37... Yes, if you attribute all emissions to the company that originally took the fossil fuels out of the ground (“Scope 3 - use of sold products”), you get a fairly small list, for the simple reason that there aren’t that many energy companies in the world. But all of those “sold products” are being sold to somebody, presumably for a reason. So there are a bunch of ways to tackle the problem, both upstream (only 100 companies need to stop selling fossil fuels to massively reduce emissions!) and downstream (every drop in demand for those companies’ products!)
- wwnb 3y ago> I can do whatever I want because 100 companies are responsible for 71% of GHG. It is their fault and their shareholders' fault and my behaviour has no effect. I know the study you are referencing and this is an extremely bad and inaccurate summary of it. What it said was that 71% of emissions traced back to 100 entities ( including both companies and states - “china” is one of the entities iirc ) and attributed emissions from the use of fossil fuels to the entity that extracted it Fossil fuels are used for a lot of useful things that make the world go round and significantly improve the quality of life of much of humanity - food production , shipping and transport, industry, construction. You almost certainly are responsible for some of this consumption, as is most everyone else alive. If these 100 entities stopped production of fossil fuels, we would have mass starvation and impoverishment, not paradise.
- primax 3y ago> The crucial thing for me to remember is that it wasn't my fault. I can do whatever I want because 100 companies are responsible for 71% of GHG. It is their fault and their shareholders' fault and my behaviour has no effect. Those companies make things that you buy. If you didn't buy them, they wouldn't make them. Ultimately all of this can be drawn back to the consumption of the individual.
- boredemployee 3y agoI wouldnt say they have 100% no fault. I think it's more accurate to say they have _some_ fault AND no choice, because the world was already there, they existence wouldn't change anything and there's nothing one can do to change it (i mean, ordinary people like us). We have marketing, media, teachers, society, manipulating us since we were kids.
- inamberclad 3y agoMany choices are made for us by society. Without going to extraordinary lengths, how should I assure that my life does not produce greenhouse gasses?
- dools 3y agoCorporations produce things and are regulated by governments. Both corporations and governments are created and run by people. You too, can be one of those people.
- buzzerbetrayed 3y agoIt’s funny to see both you and GP having exactly opposite beliefs, but you’ve both likely done the exact same amount to prevent climate change.
- dools 3y agoWell, I started a company that has the potential to reduce consumption of a range of resources and carbon emmissions.
- clnq 3y agoIt feels like people are downvoting this because it’s religious and not because it’s a bad discussion point, which this is not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kubectl_h 3y agoI have a friend who will never idle his car with the AC on. His justification: 10 minutes of discomfort isn't worth the emissions output. He knows it's a minuscule drop in the surface tension of a drop in the bucket of carbon output but he will never ever do it, no matter how hot it is. And he'll subject his passengers to discomfort in service of his principles. At the same time he flys from LA to Europe 5+ times a year. It's hard to truly live ethically in such a deeply unethical world.
- c0pium 3y agoGPs coping mechanism is to remember that they can’t make a meaningful difference. Your friends coping mechanism is to do little things so they get the feeling of taking action. Both are actually the same thing; methods for emotionally dealing with the existential crisis on whose direction they cannot exert enough pressure to be observable.
- kubectl_h 3y agoGreat observation. Also true that these little fruitless acts of opt-out and opt-in aren't just limited to climate but also politics and living under capitalism. We are all just trying to make sense of complex systems that are outside of our control. In many ways the most healthy (for ones own mind) approach to all of this is to just give in to everything, or as some have called it: take the grill-pill.
- TurningCanadian 3y agoYou still have two votes: with your wallet, and with your ballot. Think back to the times of slavery. You could've said: "I don't own any slaves, so there's nothing I can do". In the end, we did the right thing, but unfortunately after much human suffering. Hopefully we don't wait even longer this time around. There were many things you could've done to help. You could've avoided buying from places that used slave labor. You could've voted for abolitionists. You could've donated to the cause. You could've stood for justice when serving on a jury. You could've convinced your friends that things had to change. You as an individual may be individually directly responsible for a small amount, but you are probably responsible for a greater than average amount. The little changes that you make will make a bigger difference than most people's. You can also be indirectly responsible for a much greater amount. Talking to your friends about the environment can have a greater effect than you acting alone. People don't realize just how much better EVs are, induction stoves are, heat pumps are, solar panels are, etc, if they haven't heard the benefits. Help to open their eyes. Your vote also likely controls a far greater amount than you are giving it credit for. Margins of victory are often small, and a few people thinking of the medium and long term can make a big difference.
- rcarr 3y ago> You could've convinced your friends that things had to change... You can also be indirectly responsible for a much greater amount. Talking to your friends about the environment can have a greater effect than you acting alone. People don't realize just how much better EVs are, induction stoves are, heat pumps are, solar panels are, etc, if they haven't heard the benefits. Help to open their eyes. From personal experience of when I went vegan for a year and rode a bike everywhere, people really don't want to hear it. I went out of my way not to talk about it unless people specifically asked me about it, and even then, they didn't want to hear it. Regardless of what you say when questioned, they either think you're sanctimonious and/or they will start associating their guilt and negative feelings with you. The end result is that you start getting frozen out. If you no longer eat meat, you stop getting invited to the BBQ, or the meal at the steakhouse, and when you stop getting invitations to these events, you stop getting invites to others because you're getting pushed further and further to the periphery. People are tribal and they don't want to feel bad about things they enjoy. It is far more likely that you will get kicked out of the tribe rather than the tribe changing it's behaviour to match yours.
- anonuser123456 3y ago>The crucial thing for me to remember is that it wasn't my fault. I can do whatever I want because 100 companies are responsible for 71% of GHG. It is their fault and their shareholders' fault and my behaviour has no effect. Once I remember this, I stop worrying because of that piece of the Prayer of Serenity: If you aren't part of the solution, you're part of the problem.