4 ms·
$528M Antarctic icebreaker too big to fit under Tasman bridge to refuel
- aftbit 3y agoCan't they just bring the fuel to the ship using a tanker? Presumably one that is small enough to fit under the bridge, or sails from further away.
- intrasight 3y agoOr a very long fuel hose ;)
- irrational 3y agoI wonder if it would be cheaper in the long run to build a new fuel depot and station on the other side of the bridge. Driving back and forth hundreds of extra miles must be tremendously expensive in terms of fuel, salaries, wear and tear, time, supplies, etc.
- RetroTechie 3y agoJust for this ship, essentially? No. Fuel consumption of ships is relatively modest compared to the load carried. Those other factors like time schedules would weigh heavier. But from between the lines, it reads like they'll work things out with some more training & paperwork.
- closewith 3y agoRefuelling underway is an extremely complex and risky undertaking and the cost in maintaining training currency and the actual time spent refuelling underway would almost certainly be more expensive than the longer round-trip (possibly by an order of magnitude).
- Gwypaas 3y agoBunker barges/tankers are standard everwhere, although not underway but docked or at anchor. Docking at a certain place simply to bunker just doesn't happen on larger vessels where utilization factor is everything. https://www.marineinsight.com/guidelines/bunkering-is-dangerous-procedure-for-bunkering-operation-on-a-ship/ https://www.marineinsight.com/guidelines/bunkering-is-danger...
- closewith 3y agoBunkering at anchor is nearly equivalent to bunkering in port, but requires a suitable anchorage. I presume if that was available, this wouldn't be an issue at all.
- hedora 3y agoThey could reduce the risk by mooring the tanker to one of the Tasman Bridge supports.
- RetroTechie 3y agoMooring ships to bridge supports (any ship, any bridge) is generally frowned upon for a whole slew of good reasons. If not outright forbidden (again, for good reasons).
- wolverine876 3y agoI'm aware of that, and that it's a big deal for navies to master it, but do you know why and could you explain it to land-lubbers? Of course, you just pull up along side, toss a long hose over (ok, fly the rope with a drone, pull over the hose), pump. Keep the ships far enough apart to prevent accidents. Easy!
- jcranmer 3y ago> Keep the ships far enough apart to prevent accidents. Easy! In fact, this is the hard part. Generally, the tanker ship and the ship being refueled are different sizes. They have different handling characteristics, keeping them at the same speed at the same heading is not a trivial task. If there's, say, 1 knot of speed differential, after a minute, now they're 100ft further (or closer) away. Furthermore, ships create wakes which means the handling in the real immediate vicinity of a ship is incredibly different from more or less open ocean. Drift too close, and now the water is literally trying to get the two ships to ram each other, with all the disastrous results that implies.
- bell-cot 3y agoThe Port Authority has excellent reason to be tight-fisted with authorizations for large vessels to attempt to pass under the bridge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tasman_Bridge_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tasman_Bridge_disaster
- Invictus0 3y agoNo it doesn't, if the AAD is right. > The AAD has previously said Nuyina “fits within the physical limitations set out by TasPorts for transiting under the Tasman Bridge”. If the ship fits the limitations set by the Port Authority and is denied anyway, then that is not excellent reason, it's bureaucratic overreach. The fact that people died in the past ignores that there are several new safety precautions in place since then.
- bombcar 3y agoIt sounds like "it fits the big size, but lots of approval and training is needed" and the second part is not complete. The question is if it can ever become complete, or if it's simply a no-go.
- mikeyouse 3y agoThis is just dishonest. They're not denying the ship because of any of the physical requirements - they're denying it because the crew hasn't completed the necessary training to safely transit the harbor. > TasPorts had previously indicated Nuyina may be able to pass under the bridge, but only after successful completing of training courses and simulation exercises at the Australian Maritime College. > The Australian Antarctic Division (AAD) has confirmed that approval has not been granted and the ship must instead travel to Burnie this summer, on the island state’s north-west coast, to receive fuel. This must occur before every voyage to Antarctica. It had conditional approval to transit the bridge last year but then ended up being sent to Singapore for maintenance work before they had finished. They were performing more trials earlier this year but apparently still haven't completed everything and are needed in Antarctica so are shifting their plans.
- 3y ago
- suprjami 3y agoBuild a new refueling port instead of the new stadium?
- t1234s 3y agoany reason boats like this aren't nuclear powered?
- koolba 3y agoEven if it did exist, I doubt any civilian port would let a private nuclear powered vessel dock. Plus there’s the whole piracy angle. A boat in the middle of nowhere, with no serious backup, would be a target for terrorists to acquire nuclear material.
- ooterness 3y agoIt's been tried a few times, but largely abandoned due to cost overruns. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NS_Savannah https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NS_Savannah https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_marine_propulsion#Civilian_nuclear_ships https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_marine_propulsion#Civi...
- burkaman 3y agoRussian ones are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear-powered_icebreaker#List_of_nuclear-powered_icebreakers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear-powered_icebreaker#Lis... It probably would have been substantially more expensive for Australia to build and operate one, since nobody there has ever done it before. There's also supply chain risk - most nuclear reactor fuel comes from Russia at the moment, and none of it comes from Australia. There is uranium in Australia, but it would take a long time for them to start producing fuel themselves or develop a robust supply chain with a trusted trade partner.
- wolverine876 3y agoIt already cost $500M without a nuclear reactor.
- somat 3y agoWhy does it need to go under the bridge anyway? There are extensive quay facilities outside the bridge(the cruise ship terminal and the tank farm just north of it). https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/-42.8766/147.3363 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/-42.8766/147.3363
- tedunangst 3y agoWhat are the tolerances involved? High tide, low tide? What's the biggest boat currently allowed under the bridge?
- wolverine876 3y agoI was wondering the same, and the article raises some other issues too: “Ensuring our team of highly qualified and experienced marine pilots are familiar with this bespoke vessel and the way it manoeuvres is pivotal to providing final clearance for the RSV Nuyina to undertake its first transit,”
- jiggawatts 3y agoAustralia has had a recent spate of hugely expensive government projects where the "thing doesn't fit into the thing it is supposed to fit into", or "is not compatible with the one thing it really should be compatible with." Some random recent examples were: 1. A billion-dollar purchase of train rolling stock that couldn't fit into the tunnels they were supposed to go through, and were too big for the stations it needed to stop at. 2. Another train line where the track curvature was too high, the tunnels were too small, and gradient was too steep for the existing rolling stock to handle. I know nothing about rail engineering except what I learned from playing Railroad Tycoon, but because of that "experience" even I know that those are the three of the four most critical parameters of a rail line! I'm shocked they didn't screw up the gauge and overhead line voltage. 3. Speaking of voltage, the upcoming Sydney South-West Metro is incompatible with the North-West Metro, for like... no reason. 4. The two new Tram lines are also incompatible with each other, despite intersecting and having a very viable use-case for interoperability. 5. The new ferries purchased for the Parramatta river can't safely fit under one of the bridges going over the river. The lack of planning and foresight is just staggering.