5 ms·
The one thing I wish was added - either in the guidelines or as a change to the actual web UI - was replying to a comment that you're downvoting; it's frustrati
by yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago
The one thing I wish was added - either in the guidelines or as a change to the actual web UI - was replying to a comment that you're downvoting; it's frustrating both to have one's own comments downvoted without explanation, and to come across a comment that's grey without obvious reason (Was it factually incorrect? Endorsing an unpopular idea? It's not always obvious).
(I'm not saying HN should do exactly the same thing, but one example is Slashdot's system where a comment can get downvoted in a way that tags it specifically as trolling/offtopic/whatever - https://slashdot.org/faq/mod-metamod.shtml https://slashdot.org/faq/mod-metamod.shtml seems to describe it alright)
- jedberg 3y agoIt's an interesting idea, but you'd end up with a situation where the worse the comment, the more discussion it generates due to the forced replies, which is sort of the opposite of what you want.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoPerhaps a system where a comment can only be downvoted if it has at least one reply? So someone has to explain, but only once
- jedberg 3y agoA perhaps viable idea. You should email it in and see what they say.
- hutzlibu 3y agoI think some sites have a feature, that when you downvote, you have to add some words/tags to why you downvote. I like that idea, it gives the commenter some concrete feedback, but also the downvoter a moment for reflection (is this really a bad comment, or do I just have a bite reflex because its language sounds like a (ideological) side I hate?) I know that I have stupidly taken some downvotes personally, but later realized, those comments were maybe not bad by itself, but in that context attracting flamewar OT debates. With some extra words, I would have realized sooner. And downvoting for merely not liking someones opinion is something I really don't like, but is explicitely allowed here.
- creer 3y agoThat sounds like a useful way
- pvg 3y agoIt has the exact same problem as the original idea - its motivation and purpose is really reducing the personal sting of getting downvoted, not 'producing an interesting set of comments ordered by some approximation of interestingness'. Notice how nobody ever suggests or advocates for 'receipts for upvotes'. It's a totally sane motivation it just doesn't obviously make a messageboard better.
- jedberg 3y agoIt depends on the commenter. Some truly want to learn and get better, and in those cases it will make the board better.
- pvg 3y agoThese things aren't mutually exclusive and the commenters who want to get better (and/or develop more resilience to mild online criticism) do so just fine without the noise cost. There are lots of other ways one could try to dampen the unpleasantness that don't involve the extraordinary burden of receipts for downvotes. I guess that's probably the best way to summarize this argument - the extraordinary burden demands extraordinary benefit and not even the people who are really into this idea often argue the benefit would be commensurate with the burden.
- arfafaerhgaq5 3y ago[flagged]
- TX81Z 3y agoIn the market of ideas you’re failing, and that’s the signal you’re getting. It sounds like you don’t care to adjust to “the crowd”, which is fine, but then you have to deal with the consequences.
- carlosjobim 3y agoI remember when there were no upvotes and downvotes on forums, and each comment stood on it's own merits. We have to remember that for every user down voting, there are a hundred lurkers just reading. There are also a bunch of activists here on HN as on other forums, who will categorically downvote every comment by certain posters because they maybe wrote something they disagreed with several years ago.
- sanderjd 3y ago> There are also a bunch of activists here on HN as on other forums, who will categorically downvote every comment by certain posters because they maybe wrote something they disagreed with several years ago. Interesting. How do you know?
- kergonath 3y agoConfirmation bias. It’s the same in most forums I follow; there is always someone complaining about an imaginary person downvoting everything. Which is always bullshit because even if a couple of posts had one single downvote by the time the comment was written (though there is nothing to say whether this was from a single account), it is never the case if you wait a bit. I guess part of us really want to be against other people and the shady systematic downvoter fills that role. It is always stupid, though. Luckily we don’t get much of that here.
- krapp 3y ago
- lliamander 3y agoYup, the incentive should always be to direct people toward high-value conversations.
- TRiG_Ireland 3y agoComments to explain downvotes are nice, and should perhaps be encouraged, but they certainly shouldn't be mandatory.
- pvg 3y agoThey are explicitly discouraged in the guidelines this thread is about.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoCommenting about downvotes themselves is discouraged. Commenting on the reasons why somebody was downvoted is a separate matter
- pvg 3y agoNo it's not. It's the whole meta-discussion about voting in general. And, it doesn't say it explicitly, but almost all meta-discussion itself. You can find both of these explained in the moderator commentary over the years.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Comments to explain downvotes are nice Downvotes are for material that does not support productive discussion, if it is productive to discuss a comment (even on a meta level like “why it is a bad comment”?), then downvoting is inappropriate.
- epanchin 3y agoI do not downvote for comments I disagree with. I downvote for off topic, or for comments which detract from the conversation. I believe most others with the ability to downvote do the same. Replying to off topic posts would be counter to the purpose of downvoting.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoI probably agree that if downvotes were only for off-topic/trolling/unhelpful comments the situation would be better, but I don't think we're there; I am fairly confident that downvoting for disagreement is common and officially okay.
- almostnormal 3y agoSimilarly, are up-votes expressing agreement or do they indicate something worth reading (opposite of thd topic/trolling/unhelpful)? Some comments can go yo-yo, but I don't think it is possible to see the two counts separately.
- em-bee 3y agoon a technical level, being able to see downvotes and upvotes separately would actually be interesting, as it does carry a signal, but it probably doesn't happen often enough to be worth the effort to implement.
- epanchin 3y agoReddit does this as “controversial” and it is a good feature.
- kccqzy 3y agoI asked this exact same thing a while ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36673613 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36673613 So yes downvotes for mere disagreements are okay here.
- codingdave 3y agoNo, because that allows one person to double down on negativity - it can turn something grey and detract from the comment, both of which then bias future readers to read it negatively. I'd go the other way - disallow downvoting if you comment, and disallow comments if you downvoted. You get one choice of how to indicate that you don't feel the comment is correct. Admittedly, teaching people not to downvote just for disagreement would be better. Personally, I downvote a ton, but never for disagreement - I downvote for exactly the reasons I see in the guidelines: non-substantive comments. Or, admittedly, I also downvote people who are just being a jerk.
- freedomben 3y agoHow do you then tell the commenter why you downvoted them? How are they supposed to improve without feedback?
- codingdave 3y agoThat is a great question, but I feel that making the commenter go through the exercise of reflecting on what they said and trying to understand the possible reasons is just as much a driver to become a better community member as handing them an answer would be.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> Admittedly, teaching people not to downvote just for disagreement would be better. That would be awesome were it possible. Got any special insight into how to do that? I don't have a problem doing so, 16 yrs on reddit, if I ever downvoted even 30 times total, I'd be shocked. Others I've talked to make it seem like that's a daily or at best weekly total for them... I think the trouble is that people fear others seeing the comment. Downvoting is used as a technique to prevent that contamination. It betrays some sort of mistrust in others' intellects.
- mschuster91 3y ago> it's frustrating both to have one's own comments downvoted without explanation, and to come across a comment that's grey without obvious reason (Was it factually incorrect? Endorsing an unpopular idea? It's not always obvious). Personally, I don't downvote anything unless it's either complete and utter bullshit (e.g. someone acting like PHP is bad based on arguments barely valid in the end of the PHP5 era), or it is plain and simple far-right/conspiratorial in nature. It used to be the case that this was how most people used the downvote feature. Nowadays? Seems like the tide has shifted, and even completely legitimate viewpoints (not just on politics threads) get downvotes for unexplainable reasons. It saddens me a bit. > I'm not saying HN should do exactly the same thing, but one example is Slashdot's system where a comment can get downvoted in a way that tags it specifically as trolling/offtopic/whatever Such a thing exists. You have to open the comment's dedicated page by clicking on the timestamp; if you're over 500-1k karma you can then flag it. Enough flags auto-kill comments and they only appear for those who have "showdead" enabled.
- kergonath 3y ago> Nowadays? Seems like the tide has shifted, and even completely legitimate viewpoints (not just on politics threads) get downvotes for unexplainable reasons. It saddens me a bit. Dead posts are far from the majority here, and the vast majority are dead for a very good reason. Grey posts just mean that some people disagree, but it does not really say much about the post itself. It might be that the tone was wrong, or the poster was being an arse. It does not prevent people reading it, and it does not prevent discussions about it. Grey posts are not a sign of persecution or a cabal against you, it’s just that it rubbed some people the wrong way. You are interacting with a whole lot of people here. Some of them will have had a bad day or just be irrational. You don’t need many of these to get a net negative vote count. It does not really matter.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Grey posts just mean that some people disagree, but it does not really say much about the post itself. It might be that the tone was wrong, or the poster was being an arse. It does not prevent people reading it, and it does not prevent discussions about it. Grey posts are not a sign of persecution or a cabal against you, it’s just that it rubbed some people the wrong way. Which is a good point, but nevertheless I think that if one disagrees with a post (excluding the post breaking site guidelines), it is good culture to explain to the poster why one has done so.
- Tao3300 3y agoThat would be redundant. If I make a factually inaccurate comment, I can expect at least three replies correcting me. We like to joke that they all start with "actually..." Maybe I've also been downvoted, but it's clear I was incorrect about something. If I'm downvoted without replies, was I being a jerk? This requires some self-reflection, but there's rarely any mystery. Maybe I made a joke that fell flat, wasn't appreciated, or was deemed unsubstantial. Flop on this one badly enough and the mod will let you know by word or act. Which brings us to the last possibility. If I haven't been incorrect, a jerk, telling dad jokes, or being generally pointless and my comment is still being downvoted, then it means I've said something that some people wish wasn't true. It might not even be a majority, just whoever happened to be passing by. Be proud and don't sweat the fake internet points.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 3y agoActually, Slashdot doesn't allow you to use mod points on threads you're a part of. It enforces the opposite of what you propose.
- kelnos 3y agoI do often see people asking why they've been downvoted (and seem genuinely confused), but I don't think it's the right move to require at least one explanation reply. I'm reminded of the xdcd "someone is wrong on the internet!" comment. I'm starting to get to the point where I don't feel like arguing or even explaining things; I just want to downvote, move on, and hope my moderation contribution has made the shape of the thread more useful to people. If I had to explain my downvotes every time, I'd hardly ever bother, and I suspect that's true for most people. A forum where no one wants to take the time to moderate is not going to be a healthy place.
- lliamander 3y agoThat's interesting: I don't think I've ever been unsure of why people downvoted anything I've said. I don't think we should make it any more complicated. You might benefit (on the margin) from some feedback, but that makes the conversation more noisy for everyone. I can say that personally, if I downvote something without also replying to it, it's either because I don't have time to write a helpful response, or because I know my own contribution would make things worse.