3 ms·
It is immoral to create a device, from the labors of someone, which is capable of replacing their labor, without compensating them. Unless they agreed to provi
by ethbr1 3y ago
It is immoral to create a device, from the labors of someone, which is capable of replacing their labor, without compensating them.
Unless they agreed to provide their work for that purpose for free.
Postulate #1: Image generation models would not exist without large amounts of training data from current artists.
Postulate #2: Every major AI company either trained directly on public web scraped datasets or is murky about what they train on.
Theft at scale does not somehow make it not theft. Stealing 1/100th of a penny 10 billion times is still stealing.
And when you repackage the results of that theft in a profit generating machine, and then label it not theft because "it's a whole new thing," you start to sound like a CDO apologist.
And look, I get it -- it's about money.
It's always about money.
You may not be making any off your work, but that's immaterial because lots of huge companies are making obscene amounts of money from doing this (or expect to be in the future).
At the same time, it is an excellent tool. Art without human time! It will eliminate a lot of artist jobs, but everyone as a whole will be better off (because we're swapping human labor for electricity).
However, the currently vogue "artists don't deserve anything" smacks more of "we don't want to share profits during the transition period" than a cohesive moral argument.
We can have an AI future, but we should be honest about what enabled that. And we should compensate those people during the transition.
Hell, AI tax. Paid to everyone who created a work in a scraped dataset. Sunset in 30 years. Done.
- CodeSgt 3y agoI disagree with you, simply for the fact that artists have been learning from one another for thousands of years. We can see a clear timeline of art and it’s progression throughout human history, and it’s often clear how a later work took inspiration from an earlier period. Art school teaches techniques and methods pioneered by earlier artists, for the express purpose of their students to know how to incorporate them into their own original work. Yet, no one is arguing that Van Gogh’s descendants should be paid a small royalty anytime a variation of on of his painting is produced, or even just when a painting in the style of one of his is produced. Were all visual artwork to disappear from the world and collective human memory today, then the first new pieces produced by artists would look dramatically different - and likely much worse - than they do today. What AI is doing is no different. Perhaps faster and on a larger scale than how humans learn from one another, but principally it’s the same.
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> Perhaps faster and on a larger scale than how humans learn from one another, but principally it’s the same. I like how you just tucked this at the end there without any introspection on what kind of a paradigm shift that is. If you wanted a "Van Gogh style painting," you'd contract with a painter who specialized in it, and no, his descendants don't get royalties from that (which is an interesting discussion to have, I'm not sure they should, but I haven't thought about it but anyway) but you are paying a human creative to exercise a vision you have, or, from another perspective, perhaps a person goes into creating these style of paintings to sell as a business. Again the idea of royalties isn't unreasonable here but I digress. Now, with these generative art algorithms, you don't need a person to spend time turning your/their idea into art: you say "I want a picture of a cat in Van Gogh's style" and the machine will make you dozens, HUNDREDS if you want, basically as many as you can stomach before you tell it to stop, and it will do it (mostly) perfectly, at least close enough you can probably find what you're looking for pretty quickly. Like, if you can't tell why that's a PROBLEM for working artists, I'm sorry but that's clearly motivated reasoning on your part.
- CodeSgt 3y agoI can tell why it’s a problem for working artists. I never suggested otherwise. What I disagreed with was the premise that it’s immoral or inherently wrong. A problem posing a difficulty to a certain group of difficulty doesn’t have any bearing on its morality.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI'm guessing you mean to say "A problem posing difficulty to a certain group of people doesn't have any bearing on it's morality." and that's just... so very gross in terms of ethical statements. Like just, hard disagree. Undercutting the value by entire factors of a whole profession's labor is incredibly immoral, especially when you couldn't have done it without the help of their previous works. Like... a very non-exhaustive list of problems I would say meet that definition are: - Generational/racial wealth inequality - Police brutality - The victims of the war on drugs - Exploitation of overseas labor I don't think we really have anything else to discuss.