5 ms·
ELI5: Why are 11 and 12 called eleven and twelve and not oneteen and twoteen?
- tgv 3y ago[flagged]
- kthartic 3y agoI for one found the thread very interesting. Why must HN always be so negative?
- unpopularopp 3y ago[flagged]
- tgv 3y agoThere's no content in the thread. Top reply is: "because it was like this 1000 years ago." And that is not even certain; it's just an assumption. Then there is the "12 has so many divisors" shtick, for which there equally is no evidence. And then it stops. Nobody even mentions that Germanic share this, and that Romance languages have something similar, even though Latin didn't. It's a very poor discussion. There's no proof, there's no reason, there's no science. Understandable, because it's just an artifact of language evolution, of which there are as many as there are words. It's surprising when you're a teenager, because it confronts you with the arbitrary nature of something that is totally natural to you, but that's about it. It's not exactly "prime numbers with quantum computers", "0-day exploits in Linux", or "advances in generative AI" territory. It makes for a cute half column in "Popular Science" magazine, not HN.
- scarygliders 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoIt happens sometimes: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=reddit.com%20points%3E20%20comments%3E10&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... The site is penalized, like a lot of other similar sites, but occasionally a good thread floats up.
- agency 3y agoTangentially related but I embarrassingly recently made the off-by-two connection between the later English month names and their numbers (September, October, November, December). I think the discrepancy is because of a calendar change at some point?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- solarmist 3y agoBlame the Romans for that. July and August were added into the middle. Specifically Julius and Augustus.
- efficax 3y agoJulius Caesar moved to a solar calendar with 12 months to better track the seasons compared to the 10 month Lunar calendar. Naturally he got a month (July) named after himself. August would come later (named after Augustus Caesar, his adopted son). The months that were added however were actually January and February (the calendar year used to end in December and start with March. July was Quntilis (5th month) and August Sextilis (6th).
- solarmist 3y agoI didn't know about the renaming and Jan/Feb. That makes sense. What about the other month names? February, March, April, May, June? Did they get renamed as well? I assume January is from Janus.
- efficax 3y agoLanguage is a product of history and does not necessarily have a logical explanation. The answer is "because" and the theory is usually that numbers bigger than the ones we use our fingers to count were not usually dealt with in pre-the literate societies from which our languages derive. That seems reasonable, since without writing it is difficult to keep track of large numbers. But it's just a theory!
- baerrie 3y agoYes, the answer is always, it is language not math. I hate when people die on grammar hills when English is so full of exceptions it is easier to just accept that just about anything goes
- ajuc 3y agoMost (all?) Slavic languages just go oneteen twoteen. There's a word for 12 (tuzin) and 60 (kopa) but very rarely used. On the other hand we have a word for 1.5 which is sorely missing in English - półtora. On the other other hand English does weird stuff with thousands - saying 2300 as 23 hundred.
- gmac 3y agoHuh, tuzin is interestingly close to dozen.
- senkora 3y agoBoth appear to be derived from the same source: https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/Dutzend https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/Dutzend https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/tuzin https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/tuzin https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/dozen https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/dozen The most recent common ancestor is Old French “dozaine”, and ultimately it derives from Latin “duodecim”.
- TheMatten 3y ago> On the other other hand English does weird stuff with thousands - saying 2300 as 23 hundred. Czech often does the same thing though, both when counting and naming years - "devatenáct set osmdesát čtyři" is literally "nineteen hundred eighty four" There's "půldruha" and "poldruha" in Czech and Slovak too, but I feel like it loses competition to "jeden a půl/pol" in terms of usage.
- OnlyMortal 3y agoIt’s US English that pronounces it that way. I’d say, two thousand-three hundred. UK English.
- kalupa 3y agowhat about 2 point 3 kay ...
- 3y ago
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y ago[flagged]
- yladiz 3y agoWow, these questions are not vapid. Understanding the weirdness of a language is absolutely not bland and boring, because there are often quite interesting reasons for things like this.
- fknorangesite 3y agoDo you feel all of linguistics is vapid? Is language not worth studying?
- jszymborski 3y agoI think what I like most about esperanto is the counting system. 1 - unu 2 - du 3 - tri 10 - dek 11 - dek unu 12 - dek du 13 - dek tri Etc...
- tmtvl 3y agoMandarin, Mongolian, and Japanese do the same. Dutch meanwhile always puts the ones before the tens: 42 is "tweeënveertig", literally "two and forty".
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoSo Dutch is little-endian?
- tgv 3y agoYou wish! 123 becomes "hundred three and twenty". 4723 becomes "seven and forty hundred three and twenty" or "four thousand seven hundred three and twenty."
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoOh, middle-endian; a classic:P (Why yes, I do have strong feelings about American dates, why do you ask?)
- timonoko 3y agoFrom Proto-Germanic ainalif and twalif "one/two left (over)".
- gremlinsinc 3y agoIn latin it's undecem, meaning 10+1 essentially. duodecem, etc. Until you get to 18... that's duodevigente, which is to say two from twenty, so kinda reversed. This continues on though for 28-29, etc... 19 is undevigente, 28 is duotrigenta, 29 is untrigenta, etc. Spelling may be off it's been 2-3 decades since I took 4 years of Latin in High School.