3 ms·
So I don't think this is an answer, certainly not THE answer, but I worry that aspects of the early universe like the local density of matter or electric fields
by ggm 3y ago
So I don't think this is an answer, certainly not THE answer, but I worry that aspects of the early universe like the local density of matter or electric fields were radically different to what we have now. If you imagine a beacon of light which is a signal from time "back then" which has to pass through both the early states of the universe with different densities of things between then and now, and us and them, AND has to be observed, I can think of ways both matter and energy could interfere with that signal differently across time. Consequently, the amount of red shift we see in modern times for more modern (ie closer) things reflects more modern states of the universe. As a correction factor, we'd be applying what we know, to what we infer, about the density in those times.
This is why I express skepticism: It's very hard to believe there are no confounding factors in the states of being then, compared to now, which might lie inside the error/noise thresholds of their calculations.
"it had to be time was different then" feels like "because I want it to" against all the sources of noise and conjecture, between then and now.
I hasten to add I am not an astrophysicist. So, I can be put firmly back in my box and told to accept good science says otherwise.
- 22c 3y agoI would say perhaps the key difference here is we're talking about cosmological scale observations. Yes, a few quasars might've had to pass through some gas clouds or an asteroid belt or space dust etc. but at the scale we're talking about, that's probably not going to skew the numbers too much. There's 190 quasars being measured here. Presumably more observations can be made over time and with other quasars involved but I don't think these scientists need more data to be confident in what they're seeing. If you think about a pebble getting in the way of old faithful, it's not going to make much difference if you're measuring how much water sprays out over a hundred years. Now you have 190 old faithfuls and they're all spraying out water in pretty much the same way, you don't really need to account for that pebble too much.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoThe general theory of relativity predicts that time would run slower, and if that was the case these ancient quasars would demonstrate certain properties when looked at by our telescopes. We then looked at ancient quasars, and the readings we got matched the predictions, with some amount of error. This can then be used as another piece of experimental data supporting the general theory of relativity, even though you are right that these readings could be achieved through some other bizarre set of circumstances.