5 ms·
While I understand and respect the general unhappiness with the TAL and Daisey situation. I think this is an unreasonable extrapolation. Both shows (TAL, and e
by apawloski 15y ago
While I understand and respect the general unhappiness with the TAL and Daisey situation. I think this is an unreasonable extrapolation.
Both shows (TAL, and especially The Moth) are about storytelling. There are times (like the Daisey incident) where TAL tries to take on the role of journalist, but, at the end of the day both programs are about entertainment and thought-provocation. Whether or not Gladwell told a tall tale does not diminish either program's value as a storytelling medium.
I think it's unfair to blame Malcolm for the fact that journalistic publications failed to research and understand
what the Moth is actually about. Yes, he could have done a better job of finding what people are writing about him and correcting it, but I feel like the primary failure here was on these secondary sources.
- the_rara_avis 15y agoAgreed. Malcolm is an author and entertainer. It would be a perilous decision to place his works on the same level as a peer-reviewed scientific journal. I wish we could expect readers (particularly journalists) to ingest everything with an open and critical mind.