4 ms·
Newspapers existed before advertising was invented, and they did just fine. The problem they're facing right now has everything to do with the tragedy of the co
by Alex3917 15y ago
Newspapers existed before advertising was invented, and they did just fine. The problem they're facing right now has everything to do with the tragedy of the commons and nothing to do with technology or the Internet.
- ryusage 15y agoCan you elaborate? How did newspapers thrive before the current traditional business model?
- Alex3917 15y agoCharging people. But then the industrial revolution created massive economies of scale for the first time, which lead to companies that were global in scope. So suddenly newspapers could make more money from advertising than from charging. And this put all of the paid newspapers out of business, because it's hard to compete against a free newspaper. So essentially what's happening now is that the corporate newspapers are getting put out of business by their own business model, the one they used to kill off all the working class and liberal newspapers. So long and good riddance.
- jbooth 15y agoBy selling the paper (broadsheet).
- RobertKohr 15y agoTragedy of the commons? Perhaps you could explain a bit as to how this is the case?
- timwiseman 15y agoThe Tragedy of the Commons refers to the overuse of a shared commodity that takes time to renew. I do not see how this applies to newspapers.
- Alex3917 15y ago* Any individual newspaper can make more money by giving their news away for free and selling advertisements than they can by charging readers. * If any one paper gives their news away for free, it makes it effectively impossible for other newspapers to charge money. * If all newspapers give away their news for free in exchange for advertisements, they all lose money. I guess the prisoner's dilemma would technically be a better term, but it's basically the same thing in this case, at least if you think of advertisers as an over harvested resource.
- TylerE 15y agoAs far as "Any individual newspaper can make more money by giving their news away for free and selling advertisements than they can by charging readers.", that is absolutely NOT true. Advertisers pay much more for ads in paid publications. Has to do with reader engagement.
- Alex3917 15y agoMaybe they make more per ad, but how many newspapers are making more money than Facebook or Google? The only reason that newspapers can't make that much money is they don't have enough volume, and the reason they don't have enough volume is that every other newspaper is free also.
- JumpCrisscross 15y agoIt's the free-rider problem. Prisoner's dillemma refers to making antagonistic decisions with incomplete information about other actors' intentions.
- sgwooduk 15y agoAdvertising has been bound to newspapers for a long time. Check out the front page of 1st edition of the Manchester Guardian (now the guardian) from 1821 http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/gallery/2007/jun/08/1?picture=329998189 http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/gallery/2007/jun/08/1?picture... In those days the business model was to cover the front page with small text ads! (as pointed out by currybet here: http://www.currybet.net/cbet_blog/2009/05/happy-birthday-to-the-manchest.php http://www.currybet.net/cbet_blog/2009/05/happy-birthday-to-...)