6 ms·
Three issues with the piece. First, its always important to talk about exactly you're measuring. I couldn't find anything in the piece to say whether the numb
by Symmetry 15y ago
Three issues with the piece.
First, its always important to talk about exactly you're measuring. I couldn't find anything in the piece to say whether the numbers being given were individual income or household income. I'm pretty sure these were household income, but then we run into the the problem that richer household tend to be larger, so the individual income disparity isn't as bad as what was in this graph.
Also, I'd tend to prefer to talk about consumption inequality instead of income inequality. The fact that the 1% nowadays pay a lot of that income out in taxes, and the elite in 1915 didn't is something we ought to care about. I think we should all be able to agree that a society with 100% income tax which redistributes all income equally would in fact be pretty equal, but that won't show up on that graph at all. For more nuance you can distinguish between total compensation, taxable compensation, normal income, consumption, and wealth.
A second point would be that they somehow don't mention the big discontinuity from when the 1986 Tax Reform Act passed. That strongly incentivised rich people to report things as income which they had previously claimed were business expenses. That does mean that the numbers after 1986 are more comparable to the numbers from before people started feeling the need to claim that things were business expenses, but it does mean that the numbers from 1988 aren't really comparable to the numbers from 1982. And its hard to compare across countries since AFAIK most of Europe is closer to the pre-1986 US system than the post-1986 US system.
And speaking of Europe, its important to remember than income inequality has been rising at more or less the same rate everywhere in the industrialized world (baring the US's 1986 jump). See pretty graphs here: http://www.scottwinship.com/1/post/2011/03/what-would-it-mean-for-theories-of-us-income-inequality-growth-if-the-us-experience-has-been-similar-to-that-everywhere-else.html http://www.scottwinship.com/1/post/2011/03/what-would-it-mea...
So the picture is pretty complex. I think we ought to tax rich people and redistribute the wealth to some extent, but if you just look at these graphs then you'll never see that working.
- refurb 15y agoGreat post. I wasn't aware that the numbers that people throw around concerning inequality were _before_ gov't payments (they basically ignore current redistribution methods). If you want to listen to a great podcast on income inequality: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2011/11/kaplan_on_the_i.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2011/11/kaplan_on_the_i.htm... The other issue is that the European country that has had the greatest _decrease_ in income inequality in the last few years is Greece. Is that a model we should be emulating?
- vannevar 15y agoThat actually works against the argument of US parity, since our tax system is less progressive than most industrialized nations. If you adjust for taxes, US income inequality would look worse, not better, compared to the rest of the industrialized world.
- anamax 15y ago> That actually works against the argument of US parity, since our tax system is less progressive than most industrialized nations. Actually, the US system is more progressive. It gets a much higher fraction of its revenue from higher income folk than do other countries. In terms of revenue per person, the US is right in the middle, between Germany and Canada (Canada is lower).
- vannevar 15y agoActually, the US system is more progressive. It gets a much higher fraction of its revenue from higher income folk than do other countries. Is there a reference for this? Germany and France have higher top rates, the UK slightly lower. But all three have higher capital gains taxes, which as noted above comprise most of the income for the wealthiest individuals. It seems odd that conservatives would fight so hard against things like universal health care and higher capital gains taxes if in fact they actually lead to less wealth redistribution on the whole. If that were true, the Republican campaign slogan would be 'make America more like Europe'.
- anamax 15y ago> Is there a reference for this? There are scads of sources - did you even bother to look? One is http://www.taxfoundation.org/blog/show/27134.html http://www.taxfoundation.org/blog/show/27134.html . > Germany and France have higher top rates, the UK slightly lower. So? Never confuse top marginal rates with revenue. For example, other rates matter, as does the definition of income. (About 47% American households don't pay federal income tax and a huge fraction actually receive tax "benefits".) > It seems odd that conservatives would fight so hard against things like universal health care and higher capital gains taxes if in fact they actually lead to less wealth redistribution on the whole. Huh? Your conclusion doesn't follow from your premises. However, it's interesting (to me) that you didn't try to make the complementary argument for Democrats.
- halostatue 15y agoI'm not saying that you're wrong, but my understanding is that higher education levels are positively correlated with income and overall wealth and negatively correlated with number of children. This is where I tend to have a disconnect with your statement that "richer households tend to be larger"; this does not match my personal experience or the folks I know.
- Symmetry 15y agoThat's true regarding children, but the difference isn't very large. On the other hand, people who are older tend to make more money and have more children, and people who are more educated tend to make more money and are more likely to marry.
- vannevar 15y ago[I]ncome inequality has been rising at more or less the same rate everywhere in the industrialized world... The link you cite excludes income from capital gains, which for the wealthiest Americans comprises most of their income and which is taxed at a much lower rate, as Mitt Romney's recent tax disclosure exemplifies.
- Symmetry 15y agoTrue, I don't have any good cross-national comparison that includes capital gains, if anybody has that I'd be grateful if they could post it. My guess would be that the effect would be pretty much the same from nation to nation, but of course I can't be sure of that without data.
- ppereira 15y ago1. These plots are derived from Thomas Pickety and Emmanuel Saez's famous work, http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/pikettyqje.pdf http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/pikettyqje.pdf. Their research has spurred similar analyses around the world, much of which is in the World Top Income Database, http://184.168.89.58/sketch/ http://184.168.89.58/sketch/. It is based on income tax filings, which correspond to the tax unit for each country. In the US, that would be by household. You prefer talking about consumption inequality, I prefer talking about wealth inequality, but the best data that we have is for income inequality hence the choice in this plot. The defect with measuring income inequality is that it does not directly correspond to each individual's ability to bear the tax burden, which leads to issues of tax fairness. The issue with consumption inequality is that the fraction of income consumed tends to decline with increasing income, so this metric is even less tied to an individual's ability to bear the tax burden. 2. I think you are greatly overstating the importance of the 1986 Tax Reform Act. During the period covered by this plot, the income tax essentially went from - a low revenue elite tax - to wartime tax grabs of greater than 70% of income, - to a permanent tax on the middle class with top marginal rates above 85%, - to a tax allowing a plethora of deductions, - to one with our current Reaganesque rates. There have been huge changes over the years, which are mostly captured in these plots. 3. Income inequality has been rising in many countries, although this is closely related to reductions in top marginal tax rates in each country. It is also related to tax avoidance and treaty shopping by multinationals in a global economy. In addition to income tax rates, other things that affect income inequality include longevity, birth rates, and the effectiveness of estate taxes since wealth is usually divided amongst children. Also important are capital gains taxes and tax sheltering. Right now, many modern countries are in a bizarre position where the incidence of income taxes, i.e. tax on net change in wealth per year) is higher on the middle class than on the very wealthy who have greater opportunities to take deductions, reclassify, and move income.