19 ms·
Graphene supercapacitors are 20x as powerful, can be made with a DVD burner
- jerf 15y agoDoes anyone know or have the capability to accurately estimate what the volumetric power density of these capacitors are (assuming they commercialize well)? In terms of replacing cell phone batteries or something, that's what matters, and I only see areal densities.
- missing_cipher 15y agoMaybe I'm not understanding correctly, but isn't that how they're presenting their findings(W/cm³)? http://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/energy-density-graphene-capacitor-640x399.jpg http://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/energy... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_density http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_density
- morsch 15y agoWouldn't you care more about energy per volume or weight? In other words Watt-hours/cm³.
- SuperFungus 15y agoThats the discussion. In reality, you care about both. Power density to move the energy into and out of the cell quickly to shorten charge times and supply thirsty loads. Energy density to run lower loads for longer.
- jerf 15y agoYes, I am a flaming moron today. Carry on. Edit: I'd like to personally thank everyone upvoting the previous paragraph. You are the wind beneath my wings.
- th0ma5 15y agoI read this with great interest when it came across another site. I have watched many of people explode bolts or something with homemade capacitors. This seems to imply that a home a solution for experimentation could be derived, but at this time it seems that while a DVD burner may be in the mix, it is in the middle of a very advanced lab and the further processing such a material would require for application.
- pbrumm 15y agoI can't wait for a DIY version of this. Turning old cd/dvd's into super capacitors.
- jackalope 15y agoThe discs appear to serve only as a temporary platter for holding the graphite oxide film. Once scribed by a laser, the graphite oxide is converted to graphene and peeled from the disc for further processing. The discs aren't used in the capacitors. The article says that blank discs are used, but doesn't mention if they are reused or even if they must be blank, but I get the impression that a viable method of production probably won't depend on wasting disposable discs.
- Cushman 15y agoTaking the article at face value, it sounds like they're talking capacitors with an energy density comparable to lithium-ion, and that's on the first try. (Although just looking at the chart it looks more like at least an order of magnitude lower.) But we're used to being disappointed by articles about graphene... Anyone got a reason this isn't as good as it sounds?
- snewman 15y agoA key point here is the tradeoff between energy density (how much energy the battery or capacitor can hold) and power density (how quickly the energy can be released). I'm not an expert, but just working from the graph in the article, the best energy density they show for the new graphene capacitors is roughly 1/8th the best energy density for lithium-ion batteries. What's interesting is that capacitor has roughly 500x the power density of that battery. Or if you look at a battery tuned for power density (lower-right end of the red arc in the graph), there's a capacitor that can offer 200x or more power density with the same energy density. More simply: for low-discharge-rate applications, lithium-ion still wins, though the new capacitors may narrow the gap a bit. For high-discharge-rate applications, these capacitors win by a mile. (Ignoring considerations not covered in the chart -- cost, durability, temperature sensitivity, safety, etc.)
- marshray 15y agoWhat's an example high-discharge-rate application where Lion could be displaced? Toy helicopters? EMP weapons? Weight would be an interesting graph axis!
- evgen 15y agoIt is not just about high discharge. In return you also get fast recharge. Something that can suck in a large chunk of power, hold it for a short time, and then dump it out again rather quickly has certain advantages. Consider the energy storage system for regenerative braking, for example, which needs to absorb a lot of energy quickly -- the trick is then figuring out what to discharge it into, starting a vehicle rolling is the prime candidate but there may be other uses of an intermediate storage device like this. In most cases I think that this will not displace Li-ion but would instead augment the existing battery setup.
- ctdonath 15y agoUnderdiscussed point: one reason we want such high capacity power storage is that recharging takes hours. Society has internalized long charging times as normal. Would we fuss quite so much about run time if a recharge took seconds instead? (Am thinking cell phones/tablets here, not the dangerously high power issues of recharging a car in one minute flat.)
- learc83 15y agoYou can already buy flashlights with supercapacitors that have low run times but recharge in seconds, and there is a bus in China that recharges its supercapacitors at every stop. In addition they last for many times more discharge cycles.
- anamax 15y agoFor many applications, we can get the equivalent of fast recharging by swapping batteries. Yet, we still want long battery life because swapping is inconvenient. Fast recharge is also inconvenient. Just as you must have a set of batteries to swap, you must have the means and opportunity to fast recharge. Note that a fast recharger is probably at least as big as a set of batteries. And, I can swap batteries in places where I can't plug in the recharger. Yes, fast recharge is less inconvenient than slow recharge.
- Tossrock 15y agoI don't think swapping batteries is a good analog for fast recharge. For one, the cost of a kilowatt hour in AA batteries well exceeds $100, even buying in 20-count lots. From the wall, it costs less than a dollar. Swapping batteries is also significantly more effort than plugging in a microUSB or whatever.
- tjoff 15y agoStill way to cumbersome. I would love to be able to get a quick fix but I won't trade any battery life for it. If I'm ever around to recharge quickly I can just as well let it sit there for a while, at least the vast majority of times. Please note how convenient it is to charge from a USB-port, a micro usb cable is all that is needed to be able to charge pretty much anywhere (and they are cheap enough leave one at home/work/laptop/pocket. With a fast charger I'd have to bring it along and plug it in everywhere - not worth it. And I most definitely would like at least the same poor battery life that we have today, otherwise you wouldn't be able to last a day without a charge and that it just unacceptable regardless of how easy or fast it is to recharge.
- mbell 15y agoHere is a video from the author of the article on the process used http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2012/0315sp_capacitor.shtml http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2012/0315sp_capacitor.shtm...
- drucken 15y agoYoutube version of same video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oEFwyoWKXo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oEFwyoWKXo Yes, it is very informative/clarifying.
- SuperFungus 15y agoThere's quite a few practical details that weren't addressed. Whats the self discharge of these caps? Sure, maybe they can hold a ton of energy in a small volume but who cares if it bleeds off in 2 hours? What's the performance over temperature? Does the capacity drop off at temperature? Does the available power drop off? A lot of conventional supercaps can even permanently age quite quickly at moderately high temperature.
- jbert 15y agoWhat about micro-fuel cell + hydrocarbons? The energy density of gas/petrol is fantastic. Recharge time is quick ("pour some in"). http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2011/12/a-gallon-of-petrol-can-power-an-iphone-for-20-years/ http://www.gizmodo.com.au/2011/12/a-gallon-of-petrol-can-pow... http://www.mtimicrofuelcells.com/ http://www.mtimicrofuelcells.com/ Sure, we have limited supplies of hydrocarbons in the ground, but to me the key energy technology would be "synthesise hydrocarbons from water + CO2 + energy in". i.e. stop focusing on hydrocarbons as a source of energy and start thinking of them as a 'transport' of energy. That would also mean we can move to clean, renewable power generation without retooling the globe's transport fleet.
- bh42222 15y agoMy understanding is that hydrocarbon using fuel cells run hot, really, really HOT. Which is why they are regularly used in race cars, but not in many other places.
- colinshark 15y agoThey share names, but racing fuel cells are just small tanks.
- Daniel_Newby 15y agoTough tanks, filled with foam so that leaks are slow.
- karamazov 15y agoI had the chance to analyze a solid-state gas engine a few months ago, based on this technology: http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2011/sun-free-photovoltaics-0728.html http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2011/sun-free-photovoltaics-07... The solid-state engine has much lower efficiency than a regular power engine would (a hypothetical 12%/realized 5% vs. a realized efficiency of about 30%), but it can be made much smaller - and even at a 5% conversion rate, the energy density just blows everything else out of the water. Aside from being energy dense, it's also much cheaper than high-end lithium-ion batteries; and unlike regular fuel-cells, the technology is just based on regular photovoltaics, and is relatively easy to manufacture.
- Tossrock 15y agoTo me the most astonishing part of this article is that they can 'bake' graphene out of graphite oxide with consumer-grade tech. Did I miss something, or is that not a huge step forward for graphene synthesis?
- jacquesm 15y agoAll it takes is a pencil and some scotch tape, it does not get much more low tech than that.
- joeycfan 15y agoYes, but you can't mass produce it with that - this seems to be a breakthrough.
- DrStalker 15y agoAnd if lightscribe can produce usable graphene for super capacitors an industrial machine that does the same thing faster and better shouldn't cost too much, and I can't see any reason why the low-tech approach can't scale up easily.
- noonespecial 15y agoYeah, I'm already thinking about "etching" graphene circuits with my old dvd burners. Is it really as easy as they make it sound?
- vlisivka 15y agoSo RepRap will be able to print it own circuit board? Astonishing.
- joeycfan 15y agoThis seems to imply the age of cheap mass produced graphene is upon us - if so, it's a whole new world.
- robomartin 15y agoI'll preface this by saying that I want my next vehicle to be electric. Here's my concern with regards to electric cars: There's a huge difference between failure modes of electric vs. gasoline powered vehicles in crash scenarios. In a great deal of cases a crash with a gasoline-powered car results in no spills or fires. No problems. In a few cases a spill might result. Fires are only a factor when gasoline vapors are involved. If a pure electric vehicle has a range equivalent to that of a gasoline-powered vehicle, say, 200 to 300 miles, this means that it is storing a tremendous amount of energy. Also, due to i-squared-c losses it is very likely that the system will be a high voltage system (hundreds of volts). In the case of a bad accident this energy could be released violently. There might come a day when we hear of an entire family electrocuted to death in their car after a crash. I hope this never happens, but I have a feeling it could. As I see it this is the PR problem with the technology: Huge amounts of energy that could do serious damage if something goes wrong. In contrast to that, a gas tank is a relatively harmless device. Yes, there are safety measures that can and are being utilized, like fusible links between batteries and intelligent management systems. Still, it doesn't take much at, say, 500 volts, to cause a lot of damage quickly. As someone who has worked with and designed very high power DC motor controls and have tested many designs to destruction I have to say that this is an area that really needs to receive a tremendous amount of attention. The last thing the industry needs is the media devoting weeks to cover how a family got fried in their electric car while the fire department was powerless to aid them until the batteries fully discharged (which could take a long time). That would be a truly horrific sight to behold and a potential industry-killing event. Close your eyes and imagine that for a moment. Then imagine trying to convince someone who saw that on TV to buy an electric car. Super-capacitors could help in this regard in very meaningful ways. If we could get battery packs to be small enough that leaves a lot of room for creating a crash and intrusion protection barrier around the battery. Today battery packs are very large and heavy. And, while I am sure that a lot of work has gone into safety, they could be made far safer if the batteries had higher energy capacities. The other way super capacitors might be able to help could be as paradigm shift enablers. Picture the case of not needing a range of 300 miles. For most of us, 60 miles might be enough. If that battery pack is small enough gas stations could morph into battery pack swap stations. The fact that a super-capacitor has a useful life of tens of thousands of cycles means that there would be no concern of receiving someone's almost-dead battery. The cost of re-fueling would include some amount of money to deal with packs near or at their end of life. If you did need to go farther maybe cars could be designed with room for a second range-extension pack or some other means to connect a larger battery pack. From a safety standpoint, I want to see the kinds of tests companies like Volvo and Mercedes are known for: Fling a car through the air and roll it multiple times. In other words, extreme stuff that is unlikely to happen in most accidents. After the tests the cars have to remain in a state that is safe enough for egress as well as for rescue personnel to approach, touch and render aid. In other words, electric cars have to be better in terms of safety than gasoline powered vehicles.
- forgottenpaswrd 15y agoWow, this is fantastic news! One of the fantastic things about grapheme is that it is so easy to work with and abundant material. This simple method of reduction means you could create a machine for making long sheets of grapheme just with an uniform focusing laser bar, this means mass scales and super cheap. Very exciting!!
- ChuckMcM 15y agoI've got solar panels on my house. During the day, on good days, they generate more power than I use in a 24hr period, except I'm grid tied because I can't economically store that power. Back when maxwell tech [1] was using them to start diesel electric locomotives I did the math to figure out how many I would need in my house foundation to 'carry me' over from day to night, and it was an additional $128,000 and probably 1000 sq ft of 'foundation' space to hold them. Graphene, and other high surface area + high conductivity solutions seem like they will make this configuration more feasible in the future. It would be interesting to be 'off grid' but without the cost/hassle of maintaining a bunch of batteries. [1] http://www.maxwell.com/ http://www.maxwell.com/
- 1053r 15y agoThese might replace other kinds of capacitors, but at the listed energy density, there is no way they are going up against cell phone batteries or car batteries. According to wikipedia, the lithium iron phosphate battery has an energy density of 220 mWh/cc. These are weighing in at 1.36 mWh/cc, according to the article. And existing battery chemistries can already charge fast enough such that the limiting factor for electric car recharge times is the grid. My Nissan Leaf can charge most of the way in 25 minutes at a L3 charging station. But PG&E levies enormous fees for people who want to pull down that kind of power, so there isn't a single operable L3 station in the whole bay area.
- aptwebapps 15y agoThat's 220 Wh/L for lithium iron phosphate batteries, or 0.22 mWh/cc.