6 ms·
A sad developer treatment, and a sorry-ass state for a platform, but not related to antitrust law, much less a "textbook antitrust case". For starters, Apple i
by coldtea 3y ago
A sad developer treatment, and a sorry-ass state for a platform, but not related to antitrust law, much less a "textbook antitrust case".
For starters, Apple is not a monopoly. You are not a monopoly on your own platform, especially if that platform doesn't even have the majority of the relevant market. A company makes a platform or product so that they dictate the terms and if it's a marketplace, what and how it accepts to sell in it.
- arrosenberg 3y ago> For starters, Apple is not a monopoly. You are not a monopoly on your own platform Doesn't matter. Antitrust laws address competition, monopoly is just a subset. The Apple App Store is an 800lb Gorilla is the app space, ergo, subject to pro-competition laws. The app developer can't sell his app on iPhones via another channel, iPhones make up a substantial part of the market, and that's why those laws exist and apply in this case.
- scarface_74 3y agoLuckily, we have a real judge in a real court in the Epic vs Apple lawsuit where the judge said that Apple isn’t a monopoly.
- hgs3 3y agoLet's say you're right and Apple is not a monopoly under current antitrust laws, then all that proves is the laws are too lax.
- scarface_74 3y agoIt’s not about me being right, it’s about what a real judge says.
- hgs3 3y agoLet's say the Judge* is right and Apple is not a monopoly under current antitrust laws, then all that proves is the laws are too lax.
- coldtea 3y agoOr it might prove that the current antitrust laws correctly deal with trusts. And that if we want new laws, to be e.g. about "each platform must be open to third parties" regardless of market share, we need to push for them and get them, not abuse antitrust laws for something they weren't meant to cover.
- summerlight 3y agoPlease do not distort the court decision. No official entities (such as FTC or DoJ) were involved in this case, it's just a private firm that failed to prove Apple's illegal monopoly (which is also different from market monopoly and/or antitrust conduct). Gonzalez has already explicitly revoked your statement. > "While the Court finds that Apple enjoys considerable market share of over 55% and extraordinarily high profit margins, these factors alone do not show antitrust conduct," Gonzalez Rogers said. "The Court does not find that it is impossible; only that Epic Games failed in its burden to demonstrate Apple is an illegal monopolist."
- _zoltan_ 3y ago[flagged]
- scarface_74 3y ago“Official entities” also don’t get to judge whether Apple is a legal monopoly - the courts would still decide. And if you haven’t been paying attention - government lawyers haven’t been doing too great lately making cases against BigTech. Yet, HN posters are sure that Apple is a monopoly. Did their high price lawyers miss something that HN posters found?
- owisd 3y agoNot ruled a monopoly only in the market of digital mobile gaming transactions. But it’s not illegal to be a monopoly, the judge still ruled they broke competition law by banning Epic from linking to their own store front.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd yet the judge let the ban stand…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ecf 3y agoI cannot imagine the effect a ruling like this would have on businesses if you actually got your way. It would very clearly lay out that investing in an ecosystem of hardware products and doing it well will only result in all that investment, time, energy, employee sweat and tears, ALL OF IT, to be rendered useless. Basically setting an entire business on fire. Quite frankly I find it ridiculous people here are even suggesting this.
- arrosenberg 3y agoThat's hysterical. If I had my way, Apple would be required by law to allow fair and reasonable pricing, alternate app stores, as well as transparency in whatever bureaucratic decisions they make. They'd still make an absurd amount of money on their hardware. I find it ridiculous that we allow a private company to act as regulator over any sector of the economy, let alone one they have over 50% market share in.
- ecf 3y ago> I find it ridiculous that we allow a private company to act as regulator over any sector of the economy, let alone one they have over 50% market share in. If you feel that way then there are countries with economic models that don’t allow this. Venezuela comes to mind. Maybe you should relocate there so you can experience the outcome of heavy handed government control.
- arrosenberg 3y agoAgain with the hysterical straw man. Right now I'm experiencing the outcome of heavy handed corporate control. There are a whole range of outcomes between that and full state control of the markets. Do you believe that competitive markets are good? The App Store isn't one, I'm advocating for more competition, more trade and prosperity.
- ecf 3y ago> Right now I'm experiencing the outcome of heavy handed corporate control Except, you’re not? Nobody has a gun to your head forcing you to use an iPhone. There are other options instead of crying on the internet about how bad Apple is.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Apple is not a monopoly. In what sense is it not a monopoly? Walmart doesn't have a monopoly on toasters because you can go across the street and buy a toaster at Target or order one from Amazon, and it plugs into the same power outlet and works with the same bread and may even be the exact same model of toaster. If you want to sell your toasters and Walmart won't give you a good price for them, you can sell them to the same set of customers through dozens of other channels. If you want to install an app on your iPhone, you cannot get it from Google Play. If you are an app developer who wants to reach your entire customer base, you cannot choose between Google and Apple, you must use both. Because the customer with one type of device cannot use the other store. > You are not a monopoly on your own platform It certainly isn't inherently necessary for you to be. For example, Microsoft has no existing monopoly on app distribution to customers with Windows. But if there is no on else who can distribute apps to that distinct identifiable set of customers, you have a monopoly on app distribution to those customers, because "monopoly" means no one but you can do that. And no one but you can do that.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoIt is textbook in that we have a pretty famous precedent with the Hollywood studios and the Paramount Case. None of the studios were a monopoly. Each of the studios were only dictating the terms of their own movies and how they could be purchased. It's a landmark vertical integration ruling. And that's what Apple are doing with their app store. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pictures,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pic....
- taeric 3y agoAntitrust isn't limited to only monopolies. That is just the most easily discussed violation, no? For example, you are not a monopoly on your own platform, but working with anyone to raise the prices on another platform is illegal under this framework, as well.
- scarface_74 3y agoThat has nothing to do with being a monopoly. That’s collusion.
- taeric 3y agoThat is... my point? Antitrust laws are not confined to monopoly concerns. To try and steer the conversation into that direction is a non-sequitur that doesn't necessarily matter. The headline isn't "textbook case of monopoly abuse."
- scarface_74 3y agoWell seeing that no one said that Apple is colluding with anyone, what is the point?
- taeric 3y agoThat antitrust != monopoly. That is it. Do I also need to add that antitrust != collusion? I am not even really arguing that they are guilty in this case. I flat out don't know. I do find it odd to see the unwavering defense of Apple in this.
- scarface_74 3y agoNo one is defending Apple. I’m pushing back against the silliness of the armchair lawyers on HN that say Apple must be a monopolist even though a real judge in the Epic vs Apple case said otherwise.
- lapcat 3y ago> You are not a monopoly on your own platform, especially if that platform doesn't even have the majority of the relevant market. iPhone has a market share of almost 70% in Japan, the location of the plaintiff. iPhone also has a market share of over 50% now in the United States, by the way. > A company makes a platform or product so that they dictate the terms and if it's a marketplace, what and how it accepts to sell in it. Historical revisionism. For more than 30 years prior to iOS, general-purpose computing platforms were mostly open with no vendor-controlled store.
- coldtea 3y ago>Historical revisionism. For more than 30 years prior to iOS, general-purpose computing platforms were mostly open with no vendor-controlled store. That's quite the historical revisionism. Phones weren't "general-purpose computing platforms" for the most part of those 30 years (Gordon Gecko's phone didn't have apps). Nor where they considered as such. And there were tons of capable of "general purpose computing" popular devices in those 30 years with closed markets or even restricted acccess to the SDKs themselves, almost all game consoles for example.
- lapcat 3y ago> Phones weren't "general-purpose computing platforms" for the most part of those 30 years (Gordon Gecko's phone didn't have apps). Nor where they considered as such. We're all well aware of that, but so what? There's nothing inherent to smartphones that requires vendor-locked stores, and indeed some other smartphone platforms allow various levels of so-called "sideloading". > And there were tons of capable of "general purpose computing" popular devices in those 30 years with closed markets or even restricted acccess to the SDKs themselves, almost all game consoles for example. I used the term "general-purpose computing platforms" specifically to contrast with platforms such as game consoles, which are by their very name single-purpose. By the way, I don't accept that vendor lockdown of game consoles is ok either, especially at present. My understanding is that the original motivation was that game consoles were sold at a loss to encourage adoption (which I don't think is true anymore), and thus a cut of the game revenue was required to make the consoles viable. So the console developers and the game developers had a kind of mutual interest in that. In contrast, iPhone was never sold at a loss, always at a massive profit for Apple. 3rd party app developers never needed to sacrifice their revenue to encourage iPhone adoption. It should also be said that Apple itself considered "sideloading" on iPhone before the App Store was introduced, as shown by the emails from the Epic Games trial. Scott Forstall even said that they implemented sideloading in an internal iOS build, which he discussed in an email to Steve Jobs. AFAIK it hasn't been revealed why Apple decided against it ultimately. https://embed.documentcloud.org/documents/21043913-2008-may-steve-jobs-scott-forstall-sideloading-was-a-thing/#document/p1 https://embed.documentcloud.org/documents/21043913-2008-may-...
- legohead 3y agoAnti-trust also encompasses anti-competitive behavior, such as limiting consumer choice and stifling competition. It's a bit grey since Apple's marketplace is pretty unique. We need actual litigation to bring out clear answers.
- scarface_74 3y agoWe’ve already had it. Ask Epic
- Apocryphon 3y agoRulings change all the time. You just mentioned an incoherent one in the thread about Amazon ebooks. Let's see how this one goes.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy does everyone act like 2013 is ancient history? https://qz.com/103169/how-apple-tried-to-turn-the-e-book-industry-against-amazon-and-lost https://qz.com/103169/how-apple-tried-to-turn-the-e-book-ind...
- Apocryphon 3y agoNon sequitur
- scarface_74 3y agoSo an article about what happened in the Apple ebooks case is a non sequitur about what happened in the Apple ebooks case? I guess I shouldn’t be surprised since people are ignoring a judges ruling that Apple isn’t a monopoly and saying it’s irrelevant.
- Apocryphon 3y agoJudges are actively ignoring each other’s rulings these days, what matters is the newest case that will ensue, what happened in the case you are citing is basically an eternity as far as legal regimes go.
- someguy7250 3y agoYeah you are right that people are applying the wrong laws and expecting results. Ideally we would consider creating new laws. But it is hard to explain why a company's control over its own platform can be harmful especially if competition exists. IMO the reason is that both customers and small creators end up losing in this scheme. They end up purchasing/making products often not for creativity or joy, but for necessity and FOMO. And yet these products are planned obsolescence. So even if this isn't a monopoly, it is exploitative. I'm not sure whether the US can/should make a law against exploiting customers. But people should at least talk more about this weird tech environment we are in.
- scarface_74 3y agoFrom what I can tell, the company in question is just another ad platform pretending to be a game maker. Nothing of value is lost
- Apocryphon 3y agoIf that's the case then Apple could have been transparent about it and then everyone would be on their side.