5 ms·
Wow $1000/ton instead of 20% carbon? Are you also proposing a $160/gallon fuel tax?
by jeffbee 3y ago
Wow $1000/ton instead of 20% carbon? Are you also proposing a $160/gallon fuel tax?
- empath-nirvana 3y agoThere's a very strong climate argument for taxing fossil fuels at rates that make it not economically viable to use for nearly anything.
- onthecanposting 3y ago[flagged]
- 3pt14159 3y agoJust imagine he said "say" or "for example" and see how it reads to you. This is internet work, not serious business.
- jeffbee 3y agoI don’t think you can wave off orders of magnitude with either of those clauses.
- anigbrowl 3y agoGP just pulled a number out of the air. You could have just said it was disproportionate to the actual cost of concrete rather than reacting emotionally. I was surprised to learn concrete is only $130/ton, I thought it would be a lot more.
- jeffbee 3y agoIt doesn't really have anything to do with the price of concrete, though. It has to do with the price of carbon. If valuing carbon captured in concrete at $5000 per ton, the equivalent emissions tax on burning carbon is absurdly high.
- karaterobot 3y agoIt's a skill we all need to learn if we are to avoid completely missing the actual point and getting focused on the least important aspect of what somebody said.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y agoIt's usually better to have a high fee for things you don't want people to do rather than outright banning something. For example, rather than saying "planes must not be louder than 80db to land at this airport at night", you could instead say "planes must pay a $$$$ fee to the city for each db over 80db to land at the airport at night". The large fee means loud planes will very rarely land, but when they do it was because it was really worth it to them. The large fee compensates local residents in the form of reduced city taxes over time. If it starts happening too often and the residents don't think they're getting a good deal, they can increase the fee.
- carlosjobim 3y ago> It's usually better to have a high fee for things you don't want people to do rather than outright banning something. Even better is putting a high fee on things normal people have to do, so that you can continue to finance friends and family in the nomenklatura and make sure they afford everything that pleases them.
- danielrhodes 3y agoWhat types of activities does this apply to and where does it not apply? Just for the sake of argument, could this also apply to something like murder? i.e. if you wanted to murder somebody, you can do so only if you pay a super high fee otherwise go to prison. If you pay the fee, it must be worth it to you.
- olddustytrail 3y agoThat was known as a weregild. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weregild https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weregild
- danielrhodes 3y agoSounds similar to life insurance.
- Reefersleep 3y ago
- bjterry 3y agoI was curious what it would actually be. Assuming a full offset with expensive direct air capture of CO2 ($238 / tonne [0]), the carbon tax would only be $2.12 per gallon for 8,887 grams CO2 [1]. [0]: https://www.iea.org/commentaries/is-carbon-capture-too-expensive https://www.iea.org/commentaries/is-carbon-capture-too-expen... [1]: https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-typical-passenger-vehicle https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-t...
- londons_explore 3y agoCapturing the carbon is only part of the cost... The other part is sequestering it for millions of years. Concrete is a great place to do that, where many other 'sequestering' techniques might only last tens or hundreds of years, requiring the capture fee be paid again and again and again.
- londons_explore 3y agoRegular concrete is about $130/ton. Concrete products like decorative paving can cost $1500/ton installed. Specialist carbon-free concrete for those would cost $1500 + $200 = $1700. An 11% surcharge doesn't seem an unreasonable for choosing to do something the 'hurt the environment' way - anything less and I suspect many would say 'nah, don't bother'.
- ben_w 3y ago> Are you also proposing a $160/gallon fuel tax? I've witnessed two political decisions that led to no cars on the roads (the UK fuel strike 23 years ago, and the COVID lockdowns), and in both cases they made the sub/urban environment better immediately. As soon as batteries or whatever can replace hydrocarbon engines for the average person, then sure $160US/gallon or whatever.
- michaelmrose 3y agoYou are going to need to grandfather users of existing used cars if you don't want a mob with pitchforks and torches. Even when electric cars are affordable on average its necessary to understand the effect on price and value that would be caused by changing incentives. There are around 250 million fossil fuel cars on the road and $160/gallon fuel taxes would make those cars value effectively go to zero while sending electric cars price to the moon. Even if scaled in over time to avoid breaking the economy you would have a long tail of cheap used cars which would be difficult for users to up and replace owned by those least likely to be able to absorb the shock. You have folks commuting in a $5000 car for 10 years for which $20,000 would be a financial death sentence. There are plenty of folks who absolutely need a car to be able to work and continually keep an older used car for a LOT less than average. Not all of these folks could even get a car loan for a compliant car so you would be basically telling them to go fuck themselves. It makes more sense to simply mandate phasing out manufacturing or importing new gas powered consumer cars and let cars age out rather than using extreme gas taxes as a lever.
- owisd 3y agoYou would direct the revenue from the tax into grants for those least able to upgrade to electric on their own. London is doing such a scrappage scheme right now for the latest increase in emissions standards.
- vGPU 3y agoYou mean another cash for clunkers scheme? Like the one that has caused the prices of cars to skyrocket already? Yeah, great idea there.